Hollow Knight: Voidheart Edition V1.1
drive.google.com/open?id=1YhFLQnbP-C0wrCEZzDm...Posted May 10, 2020, 8:41 PM UTC
Posted May 10, 2020, 8:41 PM UTC
Oh, this looks great!
If you don't mind me asking, can you clarify some details as to how the Charm system interacts with the Jumpchain?
In the Charms section, you say that you can "only bring so many with you as you leave", (as you can only equip so many of them at a time), but if Charms are items, then why can't you take all of them with you, and just leave the ones you're not using in your Warehouse? Even if Charms aren't items per se, the protagonist had little trouble (in canon) with holding onto as many Charms as they could find, even if they could only use a handful of them.
Secondly, how are Charm Notches handled? You describe them as items which you can learn to craft, but is there a specific mechanic which prevents you from using more than 11-16 Notches - e.g. "your soul can only power so many Charms at a time" - or is it just a matter of Jump-fiat?
Thirdly, the Godseekers and Scenario 6. If you complete the Scenario and take the Godseeker(s) as a companion, can the Glorifiers use their powers in order to augment any new Charms you create with Memento of the Soul?
The whole reasoning for only bringing as many as you can notch is more for balancing than anything else. I think it's more interesting done like that, as it adds an additional layer of choice to things. You have to think "what charms most compliment my build or chain in general?" Getting them all just feels a bit cheap to me, especially since they're given for free here.
On Notches, again, matter of balancing, but you could take the power method too, if you desire. Notches themselves are weird. Like, they're physical items you can pick up off the ground and such, but what do they attach to? Are they pins, are they actual notches you put into the skin? How do multi-notch charms function? It's really hard to say. I'm rolling with them as items that you can clip onto armor or flesh alike, with the charm limits more coming due to to actual convenient space than anything else. But that's just my two cents, take it as you wish.
On the Glorifier thing, i'd say 'yes' tentatively, but it takes a fair amount of time to actually do per charm.
Maybe add a either or option which lets you find all and keep all or get the free option with the limits. Because you can get all the charms in the game so it feels a bit cheap that you can't get them as a jumper.
Even extra noches should probably be should for cp for those who have item replication of creative mode etc.
Alright, thanks for responding :)
Is there a change log?
There is, just above the Notes section at the end.
Saw this as it was coming together on the discord, the OG Hollow Knight Jump isn't necessarily bad but Voidheart is some high quality work, and touches on a lot of extra content. I'll probably do a lot more Hollow Knight builds now.
Thank you, Riko. I do have more Voidheart updates and possibly supplements slated for the future.
'Herald of Unn' perfect with the green. Good to set up dyson trees and arboreal megastructures with.
So I thought I might make a few suggestions? Hope you're interested. I was mainly thinking about the items section.
I think you should drop the currently origin-specific discounts and just group them all together, then give discounts on the items of one's own choosing. Look at the Kickboxer: Vengeance jump if I'm being unclear about what I mean.
I also thought there were a few additions you could make, namely the hunter's journal, the delicate flowers, and a map.
The journal could just update itself to account for any observations you make on a target (behavioral patterns, weaknesses, strengths, etc.), the delicate flowers could communicate to someone how much you truly value them, the map could auto-update.
I'm sure there are more additions you could make. Maybe a perfected nail for example.
Lastly, I noticed you got the description for Isma's Tear slightly wrong. In the game it's actually a fruit, not just a solidified tear, and its affects get applied upon being eaten. Maybe if you don't want it to basically be a perk you can make it so that after someone eats it they can recreate it, at which point they lose its benefits but are free to pass them down unto another, or alternatively you could make it a replenishing supply.
On the first point, updating the items section is my priority for the next update. Journal's a good idea, want to steer away from the Flowers though, since their powers with Godmaster are incredibly hazy and I'd rather not step in that realm. Auto-updating map just sounds odd to me and in game it seems more of a concession than actually being that fast. Perfected Nail I didn't wish to give, since that's super powerful, so it's more tied to the Smithing perk or actually employing the Nailsmith's services, since that's still a thing, you know.
On Isma's, I did it the way I did for three reasons. One being I didn't want it to be a perk, as mentioned, secondly for the fact that i'm not even sure if the Vessels can eat and wished to account for such, and three is combined with two, as if the Tear is a fruit, and it's on your person, I don't think you'd want such a thing to rot away over time.
Fair enough on all points, especially the map. You could maybe add a free or cheap map and quill to the items section without any special qualities I guess but that'd feel kind of redundant since you could easily just get that stuff from Cornifer. Also, I forgot to mention this, but does the Hardiness of a Bug perk enhance your jumping? It sounded like it was just protection against fall damage but the example you gave was of a flea jumping many times its own height.
The example more refers to the latter portion, the 'lands safely' part, but you can interpret it as a jump boost as well, if you wish.
So, for charms, do we have to pick which we want to take at the beginning or are we free to do so after the pantheon battles?
I'd say the former.
Hello again, fellow jumpers. Have recently updated the recently released Voidheart Edition jump. This includes an entirely new origin and perkset with the Mosskin, some new drawbacks, and more alongside general typos/grammar fixes.
Might wanna shift the item sorting by origin and then price rather than price then origin.
Would've done that, and usually do with sections like I did with the Half-Life 2 jump, but in terms of items, it's kind of lacking in that department, biggest weakness of the doc. No 600s, not every origin has 400s or 200s, it's the one area that i've been a little stumped in, so I just put what I had and let it roll. Would make it more organized if I could fill it out more, but i'm low on ideas in the item department, especially for higher tiers, since most of the other stuff I might use has it's niches already filled by other items or perks.