Taxation is theft, inequality is bad - arguments for and against

I've been mulling over these two questions, I don't come at it from any particular a priori, just trying to work it out.

Tax is theft, seems like a self evident truth, best arguments against that are...?

Inequality is bad, seems like that's a 'just so' story, best non circular argument is...?

Pointers to smart writings appreciated

Posted May 11, 2020, 7:47 AM UTC

038
typell•

tax is theft

The problem with 'taxation is theft' is not that it isn't theft (definition of theft makes that one pretty clear).

Most people who object to 'taxation is theft' do so because they think it's ridiculous to compare taxation to something like an armed robbery (these clearly are different things in some respects).

This is a reasonable objection, because what most people mean when they say 'taxation is theft' is that 'taxation is bad', which is certainly not obvious from the definition of theft.

So then you have to argue about whether the state is allowed to do things to its citizens without their consent, which you quite easily could have done without bringing up whether or not taxation is theft.

Inequality is bad

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effects_of_economic_inequality

5
Omegailesecretly believes he is a p-zombie•

I object to "taxation is theft", not because of its connotation (although I do think "taxation is theft" is sophistry), but because taxation is legitimate and I think non legitimacy is part of the definition of theft.

Consider, for instance foreclosure. Is it theft? It is the taking of another's property against their will. Or taking back something you lent other person. Are these things theft?

4
stucchio•

Isn't foreclosure taking another's property with their explicit written consent? I am not aware of any scenarios where you can foreclose on property without the owner having previously given you consent to do so under certain circumstances.

2
Omegailesecretly believes he is a p-zombie•

Sure, past consent, not current consent. And past consent is what gives this legitimacy in this case. In a different case, if someone withdraws consent mid sex, and the partner keeps going, that's rape. Here, past consent does not gives legitimacy.

1
stucchio•

Ok, would you prefer if banks stopped issuing mortgages and instead did repo? (Bank owns house and you buy it back over time at a guaranteed price.)

Note that the facts on the ground at identical here. Bank fronts cash, you pay bank over time and are forced out of house if you don't pay.

0
HomarusSimpsonOPSomewhat wrong•

1/ I've seen the argument against 'tax is theft' that argues the semantics, seems a bit facile, all that is necessary is 'tax is coercive'

2/ It is evident that inequality causes negative effects. However, does that give a fundamental moral imperative to act in a coercive way?

​

Edit: Is it morally justified for a starving man to steal a loaf of bread? If so, how? No 'just so' stories.

3
typell•

all that is necessary is 'tax is coercive'

Are you arguing that tax is bad because it's coercive? Is that what you were asking for arguments against?

It is evident that inequality causes negative effects. However, does that give a fundamental moral imperative to act in a coercive way?

If you're a utilitarian, yes.

4
ramjet_oddity•

Agree with u/typell. The main thing, however, is probably how you conceptualize the role of the State, and what system of morality you use. I mean, I'm broadly a consequentialist, and I'm not so Big Government - I'm happy with a tiny government if it works. And as far as I can see, the Free Market hasn't been able to Fix Problems like inequality, and the environment, and things like that. The coercion part of taxation honestly doesn't bother me too much.

However, I would suspect that you're coming at this from a whole Rules-and-Principles thing - lots of libertarians do. And that's what our good host might call a high-level factor of disagreement, and so I doubt you'd find a convincing argument here or anywhere.

2
stucchio•

2/ It is evident that inequality causes negative effects. However, does that give a fundamental moral imperative to act in a coercive way?

This is not evident to me. At most I see some cross-region correlations which proponents of the theory take as ironclad proof of their case.

However, when naughty people make methodologically equivalent scatterplots but change the X-axis to things like "% black" or "% single mother", the proponents of "inequality is bad" theories suddenly find the methodology lacking.

Moreover, the proponents of these theories also have a stark contradiction between their problem statement and proposed policies. Specifically, they tend to claim the problem is with pre-tax/pre-transfer inequality (since post-tax/post-transfer inequality is much smaller). But then their proposed policies are nearly all changes to tax/transfers which tend to exacerbate pre-tax/pre-transfer policy by disincentivizing work. It's really strange.

0
ArkyBeagle•

"Taxation is theft" is just bad 1990s Internet balderdash. The Murray Rothbard version of humanity never existed. It's at best an artifact of high marginal rate taxation.

Inequality is a variation on the principle of specialization. Remember that all our institutions are deeply flawed and partial. This is not a conspiracy. Institutions are hard. At worst, it represents gamification of said institutions.

3
hh26•

Scott Alexander addresses the taxation question in:

https://slatestarcodex.com/2016/05/02/be-nice-at-least-until-you-can-coordinate-meanness/

Relevant section:

Consider: society demands taxes to pay for communal goods and services. This does sometimes involve not-niceness, as in the example of the rancher in (3). But what makes it tolerable is that it’s done consistently and through a coordinated process. If the rule was “anybody who has a social program they want can take money from somebody else to pay for it,” this would be anarchy. Some libertarians say “taxation is theft”, but where arbitrary theft is unfair, unpredictable, and encourage perverse incentives like living in fear or investing in attack dogs, taxation has none of these disadvantages.

By the rule “be nice, at least until you can coordinate meanness”, we should not permit individuals to rob each other at gunpoint in order to pay for social programs they want, but we might permit them to advocate for a coordinated national taxation policy.

I generally agree with this assessment. Taxation is a noncentral example of theft. It technically meets the criteria under reasonable definitions, but it is sufficiently different that it doesn't inherit badness that most thefts have.

2
HomarusSimpsonOPSomewhat wrong•

This is the sort of thing I'm looking for. A shorthand could be "has Scott written about this?"

Edit: read the SSC. As ever, very clarifying. I can now modify to a useful synthesis statement - "tax is appropriately coordinated meanness"

I find it interesting that the discussion around "Inequality is bad" has been far less conclusive, it's the one I struggle with most. Clearly, inequality beyond a certain point is non-viable in terms of societal stability (except with coercion), but I'm looking to explore any fundamental moral imperatives, and they seem in short supply.

1
hh26•

Paul Graham talks about inequality in quite a number of posts. This one focuses on it:

http://www.paulgraham.com/ineq.html

It's hard to find a specific quote that summarizes his view, in this or in other posts, in large part because it seems to be "it's complicated", but necessary. I guess I'd summarize his view as:

-Inequality happens automatically as a result in variations in productivity. Some people are vastly more productive than others and create vastly more wealth (he usually references startups). If we allow them to keep it, they'll have vastly more wealth. If we don't allow them to then nobody would be willing to take the risk of creating startups and technological process and thus the wealth of our entire country would be vastly reduced. Some people get rich by taking it from others, but some people get rich by creating it themselves and the good from the latter outweighs the bad from the former.

So sort of a necessary evil. Again, I'm bringing this up because I mostly agree with his assessment.

1
HomarusSimpsonOPSomewhat wrong•

I mostly agree with his assessment.

I also

1
LeanDopeFanta•

All of these arguments stem from leftist theories, which tends to all rely on a cornerstone principle that the average man is competent, cares about other men, and when is not oppressed can create value.

And consequently, study the failings of any far left/communist society and you can pinpoint how that statement being false. There is a reason why the communist parties, which are supposed to be a collective that represents the interests of the populace, quickly turn to authoritarian regimes - turns out that to get people to act against their interests requires strict oversight. And these systems fail because a central party doesn't have the necessary knowledge or control or even manpower to respond quickly enough to the demands of the population (i.e, Holodomor and foot shortages in Vietnam) (unless in a hypothetical future world where you have massive surveillance and AI), not to mention the general distrust of the government if you are one of those people forced to do stuff that you don't want to do.

For inequality, this is the nature of how humans are. Some people are going to just be able to naturally create more value than others because of x and y reasons, and that value is often reflected in their financial status in life.

Imagine an Amazon distribution center was worker run. Do you think they have the capability to both fulfill the orders, as well as the know how or even time to work on expanding to provide more people with cheap delivery options? No, you need some sort of oversight. Some people are going to make the right decisions as to not fail or waste money, and its more efficient to put those people in charge. And because these people can create value - i.e in our example, providing quick delivery on goods to more houses leading to better life quality of those people living in those houses (especially when something like COV19 happens).

Follow that logic all the way up and you get to Bezos. His wealth isn't built on exploitation of working class, his wealth is built on the fact that he can increase the overall value in society that leads to quite a few people having better lives, directly, or indirectly.

This is why capitalist economies often lead to prosperous countries - the people who have the skills and talent are unrestricted in what they can do and can attain a better quality of life with the opportunist to use that talent, which also serves as a motivator to improve skills and talent. This is what is called as the free market forces that correct a lot of the problems that would otherwise lead to huge issues under communism.

The flipside of all of that is that, taxation is absolutely needed, because capitalist economies need to be regulated. While you can let people get ahead if they have the talent, you also don't want people to get left behind. It turns out that the success one has in life is largely determined by their childhood and upbringing. To a pure "capitalist brain" that only operates on value, a child is worthless because he/she cannot work or produce any value, and there isn't any way to even predict what someone will become in life. So what you want is to essentially improve the chances of someone actually developing skills/talent (or alternatively and equivalently, improve the number of people that develop some sort of talent that is valuable). To do this, you need to guarantee some basic living standard for everyone. Taxes is how the government does this, because it collects money then uses that money to fund things.

For a silly example, if there were no roads (which are all government funded), then a family without a capable offroad truck would be at a disadvantage to a family with one. It could happen that the disadvantaged family has a kid who is really interested in engineering and if given the opportunity to study and practice can be of great value, but he is otherwise hampered by not being able to get to school because of a lack of an offroad truck.

1
typell•

Follow that logic all the way up and you get to Bezos. His wealth isn't built on exploitation of working class, his wealth is built on the fact that he can increase the overall value in society that leads to quite a few people having better lives, directly, or indirectly.

And yet the bulk of services provided by Amazon are provided by Amazon's workers, not Jeff Bezos. What exactly is he doing that he deserves to make hundreds of times more money than the average Amazon employee?

1
LeanDopeFanta•

And yet the bulk of services provided by Amazon are provided by Amazon's workers

Very naive way of looking at it.

They are not providing the service out of a goodness of their hearts, they are signing up voluntarily to do this service in exchange for money, trading value for value.

Amongst many other things, in order to enable that contract to exist, someone had to

  • go find the business case for them to have that opportunity in the

  • find outside talent in order to develop a website so people can buy shit and pay money which goes towards their payroll

  • purchase vehicles (which requires upfront capital) so that workers don't have to bring their own for delivery.

  • Pay for the power that the warehouse consumes

  • Pay for equipment like loading docs, conveyor belts, and so on.

Or do you expect a common worker to have the skill and capital to do all that on their own without anyone orchestrating that?

Or better yet, because the deliveries are made possible by the workers at the auto plant who provides vehicles for delivery, should they be making more than the amazon workers?

The combination and optimization of these multiple moving pieces is what causes an increase in overall value as someone either starts the first warehouse, or expands that warehouse to 2 or 3 or the total number that amazon has. Doing this is not straightforward or easy. It is true that some people have an upbringing that enables them to this better than others through education, connections, and experience, but nevertheless, most buisnesses fail than succeed.

So its natural that Bezos's value is reflected by the value that Amazon provides to people.

Also, as a general thing, when you start talking about who "deserves" x amount of money, nobody with sufficient education in economics is going to take you seriously, because they are going to correctly deduce that you don't understand even basic economics.

3
typell•

They are not providing the service out of a goodness of their hearts, they are signing up voluntarily to do this service in exchange for money, trading value for value.

I simply meant providing in the sense that they're doing the work. The fact that they were paid is besides the point, because the money isn't capable of performing any of those tasks on its own. Furthermore, the money given to the workers is clearly not equivalent to the value of their work, since Amazon makes billions in profit that isn't going to the workers.

Amongst many other things, in order to enable that contract to exist, someone had to

I know CEOs do some things that are necessary for businesses to function. My question was why they are getting many hundreds of times more money than their workers. Are their roles really that important in comparison?

Or better yet, because the deliveries are made possible by the workers at the auto plant who provides vehicles for delivery, should they be making more than the amazon workers?

They're both doing work and therefore both should get paid in accordance with the value of that labour. This is a dumb question.

its natural that Bezos's value is reflected by the value that Amazon provides to people

No, it's natural that Amazon's value is reflected by the value it provides to people. How much of Amazon's value is Bezos responsible for?

when you start talking about who "deserves" x amount of money, nobody with sufficient education in economics is going to take you seriously, because they are going to correctly deduce that you don't understand even basic economics.

You're going to have to explain to me how making a moral statement about what people deserve has anything to do with economics, let alone demonstrates my ignorance of it.

1
LeanDopeFanta•

So lets first get Bezos's actual pay out of the way. His actual salary from Amazon is fairly low - 1.6 million, which is still a lot in the grand scheme of things.

Most of his immense wealth comes from stock holdings, which is hugely dictated by the willingness of an average person to buy a share of Amazon for whatever its trading for.

Secondly, Amazon warehouses employ about 125k workers. If you consider how much the collective income those workers make at 15 an hour, this is magnitudes higher than Bezos.

An individual warehouse worker is replaceable. They are not working with the goal to value of Amazon, they have no vested interest in the company. All they care about is doing x amount of labor and getting y amount of money. Thus an individual worker contributes very little to overall Amazon value. Nobody is forcing them to work at Amazon either.

However, smooth operation of the warehouse is something that the worker cannot oversee because of inexperience and skill. If a warehouse stops functioning because conveyor belts have not been maintained and break down, or there are conflicts in scheduling of arriving shipments, it represents a significant revenue loss to Amazon. Therefore the person in charge of the warehouse gets paid an appropriate salary, higher than the average worker.

And this effect bubbles up all the way up to Bezos. Bezos (figuratively) has the ability to take money that he earns from AWS and use that to fund a new warehouse, which in turn creates ~1000 new jobs, which increases Amazon revenue, and is a net plus for society, so his overall value is high.

So its natural that he gets paid magnitudes higher than an average worker.

You're going to have to explain to me how making a moral statement about what people deserve has anything to do with economics, let alone demonstrates my ignorance of it.

Because you cannot make an appeal to morals, while simultaneously dictating peoples salary which is an economic principle. Saying someone deserves x salary is effectively you dictating someones value in an economy, which has to be based on a concrete metric. There are plenty of cases where salary can be dictated - for example, farmer subsidies are a form of that, but that decision is based on a certain economic principle that results in an overall better economy, and not any moral principle.

And if you want to talk about morality in the sense of improving the standard of living, you have to talk about what is best overall for a population, rather than hyperfocus on a particular group of people.Lets say you are faced with a scenario where the Amazon has extra x dollars, which it can redestribute between existing warehouse workers like a bonus, or it can use that money to set up a new distribution center, which will lead to more people having the benefit of Amazon delivery and will create new jobs for an additional $100 workers. What is overall better for society?

1
ArkyBeagle•

Attributing all of Amazon to one man is just a very human error of attribution. It might be the narrative fallacy - not much of a story without a protagonist.

Jeff Bezos' salary is ( according to Goggle search ) $81,840.

The rest is options.

"he deserves to make hundreds of times more money" because that's how the rules play out in the present time. I hope I'm not seen as mansplaining this, but he was on board when the stock was issued and subsequently went public. That's literally the mechanism in play.

it's rather like asking "why does a man who owns property with water on it deserve all that water?"

2
LeanDopeFanta•

Sure, its just easy to put Bezos as the head of amazon for the purposes of explaining the economics. In reality, he essentially hired people to figure out the hard stuff, and paid them accordingly, which is how any business gets started.

The fact that he did those actions (which can be summed up as investment) and raised the overall value of society is pretty much the same effect as an athlete putting out a sick promo video featuring a product, which in turn results in significant growth of the company behind that product due to additional sales, and the athlete making a bunch of money in return. The aspect that gives those actions value is not the difficulty of the work, but the resultant outcome, post hoc.

2
ArkyBeagle•

I get the feeling that the total consumer surplus generated by Amazon as a firm is much greater than that of an athlete. Bezos is involved in "product" decisions, sometime to a detail level. I don't know how much input, say Micheal Jordan had into shoe design :)

1
typell•

"he deserves to make hundreds of times more money" because that's how the rules play out in the present time.

This is, in fact, what I'm objecting to. The idea that he can make this much money simply by owning something and having others do the work.

1
ArkyBeagle•

Owning things is generally considered a pretty good resource allocation strategy. You get into significant governance issues when a resource is considered to be in common. Sometimes it works great though. I would not think that making Amazon a public good would be all that great an idea , at least not right now.

The argument used by senior people at Amazon ( senior enough to be interviewed on the recent "Frontline" ) is "they don't have to be here if they don't want to be."

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
returnofthething•

Tax is theft, seems like a self evident truth, best arguments against that are...?

I disagree with the idea that taxation is theft in any meaningful way, but I don't think the majority of people using that phrase are seriously arguing it. At least in my experience, they aren't actually arguing for ending all or almost all taxation, which is the logical conclusion of the idea.

1
generalbaguette•

To give a slightly different view:

The problem with most taxation ain't so much that it's theft, but that it's bad for the economy.

High marginal tax rates suppress economic activity.

Fortunately, we know of a few forms of taxation that don't have that problem. Unfortunately, they are not politically popular.

- The first is taxes on pollution, like a carbon tax. Here you actually welcome the suppressing effect of the tax, perhaps even more so than the revenue.

- The second is taxing things we have a fixed amount of, so taxing can't suppress anything. The main example for that is a land value tax (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax).

If you find someone really hung up on the 'taxation is theft', you could have the government own all the land, and rent it out to the highest bidder on eg ten year contracts.

That would raise a lot of revenue, and would not involve any ongoing taxation or 'theft'. (Just a one time acquisition of the land. But you can argue that the government in some sense already owns the land.)

As for inequality: it might be bad or not. Taxation and redistribution might help. But real world tax and spending systems fall far short of what we could do.

Governments are the worst perpetrators of inequality in the world: they are the ones that uphold restrictions on international migration.

1
LetsStayCivilized•

Tax is theft, seems like a self evident truth, best arguments against that are...?

I consider taxation as belonging to the same general category as:

  • Paying rent for your lodging
  • paying fees on things you sell / buy on amazon
  • Paying for utilities like water and electricity

... or at least, it's closer to those than it is to things like "someone pointing a knife at me and tasking for my money" or "someone breaking in my home and taking my stuff".

There may be a definition of "theft" under which "tax" falls but rent and amazon fees don't , but if so I'd like to hear it because it's certainly not a "self-evident" definition.

1