Taxation is theft, inequality is bad - arguments for and against
I've been mulling over these two questions, I don't come at it from any particular a priori, just trying to work it out.
Tax is theft, seems like a self evident truth, best arguments against that are...?
Inequality is bad, seems like that's a 'just so' story, best non circular argument is...?
Pointers to smart writings appreciated
Posted May 11, 2020, 7:47 AM UTC
The problem with 'taxation is theft' is not that it isn't theft (definition of theft makes that one pretty clear).
Most people who object to 'taxation is theft' do so because they think it's ridiculous to compare taxation to something like an armed robbery (these clearly are different things in some respects).
This is a reasonable objection, because what most people mean when they say 'taxation is theft' is that 'taxation is bad', which is certainly not obvious from the definition of theft.
So then you have to argue about whether the state is allowed to do things to its citizens without their consent, which you quite easily could have done without bringing up whether or not taxation is theft.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effects_of_economic_inequality
I object to "taxation is theft", not because of its connotation (although I do think "taxation is theft" is sophistry), but because taxation is legitimate and I think non legitimacy is part of the definition of theft.
Consider, for instance foreclosure. Is it theft? It is the taking of another's property against their will. Or taking back something you lent other person. Are these things theft?
Isn't foreclosure taking another's property with their explicit written consent? I am not aware of any scenarios where you can foreclose on property without the owner having previously given you consent to do so under certain circumstances.
Sure, past consent, not current consent. And past consent is what gives this legitimacy in this case. In a different case, if someone withdraws consent mid sex, and the partner keeps going, that's rape. Here, past consent does not gives legitimacy.
Ok, would you prefer if banks stopped issuing mortgages and instead did repo? (Bank owns house and you buy it back over time at a guaranteed price.)
Note that the facts on the ground at identical here. Bank fronts cash, you pay bank over time and are forced out of house if you don't pay.
1/ I've seen the argument against 'tax is theft' that argues the semantics, seems a bit facile, all that is necessary is 'tax is coercive'
2/ It is evident that inequality causes negative effects. However, does that give a fundamental moral imperative to act in a coercive way?
Edit: Is it morally justified for a starving man to steal a loaf of bread? If so, how? No 'just so' stories.
Are you arguing that tax is bad because it's coercive? Is that what you were asking for arguments against?
If you're a utilitarian, yes.
Agree with u/typell. The main thing, however, is probably how you conceptualize the role of the State, and what system of morality you use. I mean, I'm broadly a consequentialist, and I'm not so Big Government - I'm happy with a tiny government if it works. And as far as I can see, the Free Market hasn't been able to Fix Problems like inequality, and the environment, and things like that. The coercion part of taxation honestly doesn't bother me too much.
However, I would suspect that you're coming at this from a whole Rules-and-Principles thing - lots of libertarians do. And that's what our good host might call a high-level factor of disagreement, and so I doubt you'd find a convincing argument here or anywhere.
This is not evident to me. At most I see some cross-region correlations which proponents of the theory take as ironclad proof of their case.
However, when naughty people make methodologically equivalent scatterplots but change the X-axis to things like "% black" or "% single mother", the proponents of "inequality is bad" theories suddenly find the methodology lacking.
Moreover, the proponents of these theories also have a stark contradiction between their problem statement and proposed policies. Specifically, they tend to claim the problem is with pre-tax/pre-transfer inequality (since post-tax/post-transfer inequality is much smaller). But then their proposed policies are nearly all changes to tax/transfers which tend to exacerbate pre-tax/pre-transfer policy by disincentivizing work. It's really strange.