plungergod•

Why isn't this in r/covid19 yet?

9
thicc_eigenstate•

It's a month old, so it was already posted a month ago. Someone tried to repost it on r/covid19 today but the mods removed it (because it was a repost).

3
Yamatoman9•

I was expecting to see it on the front page there but nothing yet.

1
[deleted]•

I’m not the smartest person out there haha can someone translate the results of this study for dummies like me?

7
Trumpledickskinz•

The first author on this paper is one of the worlds most cited epidemiologists. He’s been advocating for a few months now that the risks are much lower than we perceive. He was the principal for the serological study (blood samples testing for antibodies) in Santa Clara that attempted to show this was far more widespread than testing revealed and therefore far less deadly. There were some concerns with how people were recruited (it’s actually really hard to get good data with such low rates of infection and volunteers only). But, dozens of other tests all over the world are in rough agreement that infection is way higher than actually reported (10x or higher!). This actually reduced the estimated infection fatality by a factor of 10 (it’s dead divided by the number of people infected).

Here he is again looking at the absolute risk. Not everyone will be infected and outcomes depend a lot on location. If you look at the death rate per million people and then break it down into age groups (which is probably still the strongest and broadest predictor for outcome) then you again see a huge discrepancy.

Finally, if you look at the absolute risk of dying from covid versus other common activities then you will see that humans are really poor at assessing risk. We often fall for dangers right in front of our faces rather than over the horizon (eg virus vs heart disease).

My own view of the risk is that 2.8 million Americans die every year with the biggest slice going to heart disease (700k). There isn’t an estimate or model out there that even doubles the number of dead on a year due to covid19. That means, on average across the whole population, the risk of death has not even doubled. In fact, it could be less than a 10% bump if 280,000 were to pass especially considering that some of those were likely to die this year anyways.

22
hellrazzer24•

But, dozens of other tests all over the world are in rough agreement that infection is way higher than actually reported (10x or higher!).

The Santa Clara study had a lower bound of 50x! The Los Angeles study had a lower bound of 28x! Most scientists agree that we can safely assume 10x spread to confirmed tests at the moment.

4
FavRage•

If you are under 65 your risk of death from the rona is similar to driving a long commute.

20
dsjoerg•

I live in NYC.

Driving 415 miles per day is more than a "long commute".

2
FavRage•

Most places are much more like Germany than New York City as far as fatalities vs miles driven. The median speed driven in NYC is closer to 25-35 and in most other suburban and metro areas would be closer to 45 or higher.

1
dsjoerg•

Of course. I'm simply disagreeing with your blanket assertion "If you are under 65 your risk of death from the rona is similar to driving a long commute."

May be true for some, not true for me and my millions of fellow NYCers.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
14thAndVine•

Inb4 "you just want grandma dead so you can get a haircut"

4
dankseamonster•

I was particularly struck by the section mentioning the under 65s who have passed away with no documented pre - existing conditions as potentially lacking records of their medical history. I think that this is very likely among under/uninsured Americans, I'm sure a lot of conditions fly under the radar.

2
AutoModeratorMOD•

Thanks for your submission. New posts are pre-screened by the moderation team before being listed. Posts which do not meet our high standards will not be approved - please see our posting guidelines. It may take a number of hours before this post is reviewed, depending on mod availability and the complexity of the post (eg. video content takes more time for us to review).

In the meantime, you may like to make edits to your post so that it is more likely to be approved (for example, adding reliable source links for any claims). If there are problems with the title of your post, it is best you delete it and re-submit with an improved title.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
tep3000•

Am I reading this right? Page 16 middle paragraph says that the highest age category has a 0.24% chance of dying when infected with corona?

1
constxd•

0.24% chance of dying from COVID-19 period. It's the product of the attack rate and the IFR.

1
tep3000•

Ok so this study is a definitely swayed towards painting the corona as less deadly.

Not sure if you’re willing or care enough to do this analysis for me but.......

0.24% chance of dying from corona versus all other causes of death right? 100% chance you’ll die from something and about 0.24% chance it will be corona if you’re in the highest age bracket (which is 65+ I think?)

Well the counter is that the death rate would be higher if we weren’t in lockdown sooo... this doesn’t help make the case for easing lockdowns

I want to know chance of dying from covid-19 if you’re infected. Problem with what I want is that the missing data piece is how my people are infected.

Couple estimations based on antibody tests here and there but they aren’t conclusive.

Also adding the car shit made it confusing.

0