Cosmos Elite or Index?

Hi all o/

I've been planning to get a VR system for myself as a reward for when I finally paid off my credit card debt for a while now, and that day is finally here!

Trouble is there's a few great options right now and I'm not finding a lot of helpful reviews online :/

My main two contenders right now are the Cosmos Elite and the Valve Index, but I'm having a very difficult time picking between them. I'm not really interested in anything from Oculus, but I'm keeping an open mind so if someone feels passionately that I'm wrong and Oculus is best feel free to change my mind :D

I have a good job right now so I'm not worried about price as a factor, I just want the best system as a long-term investment in VR gaming. I have an above average gaming PC already and am planning to upgrade that too later this year.

My main "con" against the Cosmos Elite is the controllers, and my main con against the Index is I feel kind of uneasy about making a long-term hardware investment into Valve as a company. This is just based on my research so far, but I'm happy to be told I'm wrong if either are non-issues.

I've also seen a video that alluded that it was possible to use the Index controllers with a Cosmos Elite headset - is this possible and/or viable?

Thanks in advance for any help! If I left out anything important I'll update the post with the new info :)

Posted May 14, 2020, 6:29 PM UTC

18
unrelentingdespair•

If money isn’t a problem then the answer is Index in pretty much every way

3
SilentCaay•

The Index is going to be better, mainly for the controllers. The Vive wands lacking an analog stick makes them very much outdated. Other than that, the Elite is a Cosmos with Lighthouse tracking which is far superior to the tracking of the normal Cosmos. It's decent aside from the controllers.

2
fat-sheep•

I have the Cosmos Elite coming from the first Vive. I am using Index Controllers aswell as the Vive Wands. Depending on the game I sometimes prefer the one or the other. Also the Vive Cosmos Elite is compatible with the Wireless Adapter from htc. I like the combination of all of this although it might be the priciest combination. I got everything over time and not at once so it felt not as expensive as it really was 😉

2
MoslyOP•

What's your experience been like using the index controllers with the cosmos elite? Do they work exactly like they would with the index headset? Sorry in advance for my ignorance about how some of this works :/

I'm almost leaning towards this option now if the index controllers work the same since I don't really want to wait 8 weeks for an index unit

1
fat-sheep•

They work just fine and as expected. Never had an Index though. I used them with the old Vive before. They all use the lighthouse tracking system so there should be no difference based on the headsets as the controllers track themselves and just use the headset‘s radio.

1
TofipokTheFirst•

Do not be worried about buying from valve, they have existed for a looong time. Go index if you can afford it. You won't regret it.

1
Phalex•

Unless you want the Wireless adapter for HTC Cosmos Elite I would go with the Valve Index or Oculus Rift S.

1
michealvsauce666•

Valve index is miles and miles ahead of the cosmos elite

1