Hordak, Light Hope, Adora and why one of the last scenes in the series are so important. A theory.

SpoilerGeneral Discussion

Spoilers for all the seasons, as well as the finale of Season 5. You have been warned. You have also been warned that I wrote this at 3am last night.

At the end of Heart II, when She-Ra banishes Horde Prime from Hordak, Hordak regains a memory of the first time he meet Adora, in an open field, newly arrived through a portal that Mara created. I have a theory as to why this memory is so important.

In Destiny Part 2 (S04E13), Adora learns the truth from Light Hope. It was she that brought Adora to Etheria when she was still a baby, using a portal. But wait, haven’t another character we know also arrived via a portal?

In Huntara (S03E02), Hordak gives his backstory to Entrapta. He says that he was once Horde Prime’s top general, before being thrown down to the front lines because he was defective. During a battle, a portal opened and sent him to Etheria. Pretty much the same as Adora. One could draw the conclusion that Light Hope retrieved both Hordak and Adora to serve her plans of activating The Heart of Etheria. But why bring Hordak?

During the episode Light Spinner (S02E06), Shadow Weaver has flashbacks to her time in Mystacor. Even during this time, the Horde has grown powerful and dangerous, so it must have been some time since Hordak arrived. Shadow Weaver defects to the Horde at the end, and recalls when Hordak went out to search for something by himself. He came back with baby Adora. Then, 15-ish years passes before The Sword (S01E01) begins…

Light Hope’s plan must have been as follows. She needed a person with First Ones heritage to pick up the sword and become She-Ra for the Heart to work. But as far as we know, Etheria was at peace before the Horde came. She needed conflict on the planet in order to foster a strong She-Ra that could be used against Horde Prime, the greatest enemy of the First Ones. She brought Horde Prime’s former top general, a clone that would have the ability to build an empire after arriving on Etheria.

Light Hope waited until Hordak had secured a runestone, The Black Garnet (as seen in Light Spinner, S02E06) before using her last strength to bring Adora through another portal. Her hope was to have Adora grow up among the Rebellion, having her live in fear of the Horde all her life before picking up the sword. This She-Ra would go on the quest to balance the planet by taking back The Black Garnet and in so doing, defeating the evil Hordak. This would have created a She-Ra that was willing, and now able, to use The Heart of Etheria to finally wipe out Horde Prime and his empire.

But Light Hope miscalculated. Hordak tracked the second portal and arrived at the place it had been opened, and retrieved Adora. Not knowing her importance, he placed her in the care of Shadow Weaver. This by itself doesn’t alter Light Hope’s plans much. Adora still finds the Sword of Protection and becomes She-Ra, but she also become friends with Glimmer and Bow, something that maybe wouldn’t have happened if Adora grew up with the first best family that had found her in that field. We don’t see a lot of commoners walking around in Bright Moon.

Without being friends Bow, Adora wouldn’t have found Mara’s message (Signals, S02E03. Reunion, S02E07. Once Upon a Time in the Waste, S03E03), that threw doubts on Light Hope’s motivations. Without Glimmer as a friend, maybe Adora wouldn’t have had the self-worth to see through Light Hope’s manipulation, and would have believed she was only meant to be a weapon. And don’t forget that Shadow Weaver only kept Catra around because Adora was fond of her. No Adora in the Horde, no Catra in the Horde to delay their defeat until the gang could find the clues left by Mara (Horde productivity increased by 400% since Catra took charge, The Price of Power, S03E01).

In conclusion: If Hordak hadn’t found Adora that day in the field, Light Hope’s plan might have actually worked, and billions of lives across the universe would have been lost.

And also no Catradora!

TLDR; Crackpot 3am theory that Light Hope brought Hordak to Etheria, but Hordak was smarter than she gave him credit for, which after a complicated series of events gave us kissing lesbians and crackpot 3am theories.

Posted May 19, 2020, 12:02 PM UTC

30927
Loading comments…