Pope Benedict contrasts science and morality
I love these words by our Pope, comparing science and morality in the Catholic spirit (edit to add: I realize this is not new, but I just read it for the first time):
First of all, we must acknowledge that incremental progress is possible only in the material sphere. Here, amid our growing knowledge of the structure of matter and in the light of ever more advanced inventions, we clearly see continuous progress towards an ever greater mastery of nature. Yet in the field of ethical awareness and moral decision-making, there is no similar possibility of accumulation for the simple reason that man's freedom is always new and he must always make his decisions anew. These decisions can never simply be made for us in advance by others—if that were the case, we would no longer be free. Freedom presupposes that in fundamental decisions, every person and every generation is a new beginning. Naturally, new generations can build on the knowledge and experience of those who went before, and they can draw upon the moral treasury of the whole of humanity. But they can also reject it, because it can never be self-evident in the same way as material inventions
Posted Apr 10, 2011, 4:41 PM UTC · edited
Wonderful, but I can easily see how those words could be misinterpreted (Just like everything else from the Church)
Words are ambiguous by nature. When taken out of the context of the teachings of the church or out of context of the entire leter, it is easy to do.
How might these words be taken out of context? I can see that if someone had an agenda, they could easily come up with something, but are you thinking of "reasonable" misinterpretations?
In a way, I'm not sure I fully understand what he is saying. You might think he would say that morality is a constant, and something prescribed by God through the Bible. But he instead says that each generation has the ability to change it. It is true in reality that things that were once considered moral are now immoral, and vice-versa.
I agree with the top, that people will only change the words when they have an agenda, but I don't know what you mean by "'reasonable' misinterpretations".
That was not a good phrase. What I meant was an honest and serious way of interpreting what the pope wrote that could imply some nefarious meaning. I think it would probably be a misinterpretation of what the pope intended, but I was leaving open the possibility that a "reasonable" person might have it.
Aside from that, as someone who is very involved in science, I found some really interesting things in this letter. Here is another that addresses the idea that some have, of science being some kind of alternative to religion:
Francis Bacon and those who followed in the intellectual current of modernity that he inspired were wrong to believe that man would be redeemed through science. Such an expectation asks too much of science; this kind of hope is deceptive. Science can contribute greatly to making the world and mankind more human. Yet it can also destroy mankind and the world unless it is steered by forces that lie outside it.
I agree completely.