"consciousness"

Its disappointing to see this sub attracts / is filled with those who would leave critical thinking at the door. I assumed there would be more philosophical conversation- like real, well thought-out concepts, but I was mistaken.

Looking at the last few months of posts it seems that this community is missing good arguments and we'll reasoned theories. If you enjoy this woo filled nonsense then good for you. I'm done waiting for interesting contributions to appear in here. It's boring and frankly a waste of my time.

Dm me if you know any subs that have real conversations about consciousness. I'm unsubscribing after I post this.

Posted May 20, 2020, 11:20 AM UTC

616
H150180•

Could you have made a contribution yourself insted of criticizing others for making an effort?

5
[deleted]•

You are the ocean dying of thirst.

4
ArtificialBra1n•

THANK YOU. This is such an exciting time for consciousness research but you'd never know it by browsing this sub.

4
SoraVGC•

hey there you should definitely check out the leading consciousness researcher: https://www.quora.com/profile/B-A-Rehl (some of his claims: https://www.reddit.com/r/consciousness/comments/gkdm00/repost_meet_the_leading_consciousness_researcher/ ) - he will publish his papers early next year and it seems, of what I've seen, that he has solved consciousness scientifically.

1

Here's an argument you may like.

  1. No human intellectual activity, including science, can escape the fact that it has to make assumptions that cannot be proven using its own methodology (i.e. absolute presuppositions).
  2. The prevalent underlying assumptions, or world model, of the majority of modern scientists are narrowly naturalist in metaphysics, materialist in ontology and reductionist-empiricist in methodology.
  3. This results in the belief that consciousness is nothing but a consequence of complex arrangement of matter, or an emergent phenomenon of brain activity.
  4. This belief is neither proven, nor warranted.
  5. In fact, there are well documented empirical phenomena that contradict this belief. Among them are a. Veridical reports of near death experiences (NDEs) with complex intuitions, perceptions, cognitions and emotions during well documented absence of brain activity. b. Veridical reports of non-local perception that were confirmed independently during such near-death-states of absent brain activity. c. The large data-base of parapsychology and anomalous cognition research shows in a series of meta-analyses that such non-local perceptions are indeed possible. d. The large data-base of children who remember previous lives, some of whom have corresponding deformities.
  6. An increasing number of open-minded scientists are already researching these frontier areas using existing scientific methods, and are reaching empirically grounded conclusions that challenge the mainstream majority view.
  7. They therefore argue that we need a model of consciousness that is non-reductive and allows consciousness its own ontological status.
  8. A minimum-consensus model is a dual aspect or complementarity model, in which matter and mind, consciousness and its physical substrate, are two aspects of reality that are irreducible and simultaneously occurring perspectives of an underlying reality to which we otherwise have no direct access.
  9. If that is granted, we can immediately see that consciousness can have its own direct access to reality, not only through sense perception, as in classical empiricism, but also through inner perception or radical introspection.
  10. As a result, there may be a different and valid access route to reality, through consciousness, in addition to the classical one science is offering.
  11. This might include direct access, under certain conditions, to deeper structures of reality, which may provide important insights into ethics, meaning, and values.
  12. Indeed, insights from NDEs and other transformative experiences suggest that we are all embedded within a larger field of consciousness, with profound implications for ethics in an interconnected world.
  13. Integrating an enlarged view of consciousness into science will also yield a new methodology that will have to be developed: the methodology of radical introspection or inner experience.
  14. In view of the widespread perception that a narrow materialist world view is often uncritically passed on to young scientists by mainstream authorities as an adequate explanation of reality and as a pre-conditon for a successful scientific career, we call for an open exploration of this topic and we encourage the scientific community to become more critically self-reflective of the absolute presuppositions on which their activities are based and to consider expanding their scope.
3
Anonymoves•

Imagine an engineering convention that was free, and literally anyone could come and give a talk if they liked. Lots of people who've never studied engineering show up and start talking about how their uncle built a frictionless bearing and how modern engineering is a close-minded dogma around the supremacy of cement. That's how this sub relates to neuroscience and consciousness research.

1
[deleted]•

Looking for intersting thoughts on consciousness? Check out Russel Brand on youtube or podcast ...

1
PM_ME_INFORMATION•

I really hope this is sarcasm, please tell me it is.

1
Ziggle21308•

Lol says he wants to see more critical thinking and then criticizes the discussions in this sub as “woo filled nonsense.”

Ok buddy. Good riddance.

1
Anonymoves•

He's right though

1
Ziggle21308•

So you’re of the opinion that critical thinking means blindly accepting unsubstantiated dogma, rather than, you know, thinking critically about it?

2
Anonymoves•

Look up critical thinking

1
Ziggle21308•

No I think I’m good on it.

Go ahead and keep finding reasons to support the mainstream opinion just because. It doesn’t make you a critical thinker. It makes you a lackey.

1
PM_ME_INFORMATION•

Should a doctor engage with people who think crystals heal cancer...?

1
Ziggle21308•

What do you mean?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1