r/daddit•
ARCDad

To Cut or Not to Cut, that is the question (Circumcise)

Advice Request

Hey guys, I've got my first son on the way this September, and I am pumped. I've always wanted a boy, and now I get to have that. However, unlike my daughter, there's an extra layer to consider here in regards to circumcision. My wife is really leaning towards not doing it, but I myself am a little unsure on that, as I've heard it's harder to clean/work with. She's sent me an article that I'm in the middle of reading, but I wanted to get some other dad's input on this, and if anyone has any other articles that would be good to read I'd really appreciate it.

So let the debate begin: Cut or no cut? Why or Why not?

Posted May 22, 2020, 12:26 AM UTC

445
Phagemakerpro•

I’m a pediatrician and I’m Jewish.

My son is not circumcised. My take on it was: “Why do elective surgery on a newborn? Why make a decision like that about a penis that isn’t mine?”

In my career (15 years) I have had to refer two kids for medically necessary circumcision. That’s it.

12
citygirluk•

This is a reassuring perspective, thank you for sharing. I had always assumed I would get my boy circumcised but then someone pointed out to me that it's no different to FGM (female genital mutilation) which has huge campaigns against it and is something I would never consider for my daughter - why cut off part of my child's body. So on that basis we kept the boy uncut and if he wants to choose to do it as an adult that's up to him.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

11
Redsox933•

I’m circumcised my son isn’t. Him not being circumcised has nothing to do with the fact that I am. I asked the pediatrician if there was any medical reason for him to be circumcised and when they said No, that combined with doing my own research to confirm convinced me there wasn’t a need.

7
Yamjna•

Wtf is wrong with americans. Noone in europe would ever even think about this. Except some very traditional jews maybe.

7
ltssms0•

It hasn't been any real extra work for my son. It is moist down there and needs a quick wipe once most days.

I figure he can always choose as an adult.

6
boombalabo•

I'm not cut, my son isn't cut either.

I can't say it's "harder" or not to deal with it, but it is not complicated, the only thing your son will need to know is that he needs to pull it "inside out" so he can clean what is hidden.

Also that before starting to pee he needs to pull on it a little otherwise the skin might shoot piss somewhere unexpected.

I always assumed that it was easier to take care of a penis even uncircumcised one than a vagina.

6
stibbons•

I'm not circumcised, my 4mo son isn't either. And to be honest I'm very strongly opposed to having it done unless it's for serious medical reasons (a few posters here have brought up things like phimosis, and fair enough).

But I just wanted to speak to this

I've heard it's harder to clean/work with

I don't have any problems with my foreskin. Pull it back briefly to clean under in the shower, no worries. It doesn't get in the way during sex. It's occasionally slightly annoying trying to urinate on cold mornings, gotta pull it back slightly to ensure I don't make a mess, but nowhere near the point of wishing I didn't have it.

I haven't needed to do anything about my son's foreskin. I just wash his bits and don't try to retract it at all. Eventually I will teach him how to take the little bit of extra time to clean his bits properly, just like I'll teach him to brush his teeth.

The only bit of reading I've done on the subject was in a book that I think gets recommended here and r/predaddit all the time; The Expectant Father by Armin Brott and Jennifer Ash. It's a great book in general, and you should absolutely get your hands on a copy. But like the rest of the book, the section where circumcision is discussed is pretty even-handed and cites a fair bit of additional reading you can check out.

6
majorslax•

I'm not cut, I don't have strong feelings about it, neither does my wife, so we left our son uncut at first. Turns out he had phimosis and it caused health issues for him (poor little dude literally couldn't pee), so he's cut now, and he happily pees everywhere.

5
tube_radio•

I am cut, my son is not. I think it is a ridiculous practice and think it is a great thing that the practice is dying out. In the future, your son might really resent the fact that you put him through that for practically no good reason, especially since it is falling out of popularity even in the US.

5
waterbuffalo750•

If you want an unbiased opinion, Reddit is a terrible place to get it. Reddit has a huge anti-circumcision bias. The AAP says that the benefits slightly outweigh the risk, but it's enough of a wash that they don't make a recommendation either way. They essentially leave it to a parenting decision. Any doctor I've talked to feels the same way, essentially. My wife is a pediatrician and both our boys were circumcised, whatever that's worth.

4†
tube_radio•

Most of the rest of the modern world doesn't practice it... Perhaps Reddit's "anti-circumcision bias" is simply the fact that not everyone comes from a culture that has convinced itself that circumcision is okay.

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
waterbuffalo750•

I understand what that's saying, it's the same talking point that's repeated over and over on every one of these threads.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
try_____another•

The AAP is pretty much alone in the developed world in its opinion (apart from other american institutions which rehashed their statement). Also, at least one member of their panel has admitted to deliberately skewing their report to provide political cover for his coreligionists in Europe. They also excluded all consideration of the functions and benefits of having a foreskin even though they acknowledged them in their previous publications.

1
Picker-Rick•

Actually the AAP doesn't recommend it. They only say that the health benefits of the surgery outweigh the risk by about .1%. Not that the circumcision outweighs the risk of being uncircumcised.

Their official statement is that they leave it up to the parents. Though it is disgusting that they took out the part about foreskin benefits.

"The American Academy of Pediatrics believes that circumcision has potential medical benefits and advantages, as well as risks.... however, existing scientific evidence is not sufficient to recommend routine circumcision. Therefore, because the procedure is not essential to a child's current well-being, we recommend that the decision to circumcise is one best made by parents in consultation with their pediatrician..."

2
TWYFAN97•

I’m appalled with all the nutcases being against circumcision when it does have its benefits I’m living proof along with other family and friends who have required it and not due to cultural beliefs. I have a brother who suffers because he didn’t get circumcised when he probably should have.

1
backpackdigital•

Brit here. I’ve never had any trouble. Don’t worry about it, it’s weird to everyone else in the world to cut a piece of a person off, but you’re the parents, it’s your call in the end :)

Also, it’s much easier to clean behind your ears without your ears in the way. Also, cleaning dirt from beneath your fingernails ever get you down? Get rid of them.

Haha, I’m only joking, it really is your call.

If you want the gruesome truth about how we keep it clean (“the secret that the anti-circumcision folk don’t want you to hear!!!!”) - when taking a leak, we hold the end, let it fill up like a fire hose someone is standing on and then try to aim the explosion into the pan. (Fellas.. am I right?) (also we take the 4-7 seconds to wash it in the shower).

Btw everything that appears sarcastic in this message truly is in jest, it’s all good :)

2
waterbuffalo750•

If you want the gruesome truth about how we keep it clean (“the secret that the anti-circumcision folk don’t want you to hear!!!!”) - when taking a leak, we hold the end, let it fill up like a fire hose someone is standing on and then try to aim the explosion into the pan.

I've never had any desire to be un-cut, at all.... Until this moment.

2
stibbons•

I take exception with anybody claiming that we aim when doing this.

3
lawlawlandrover•

Well, after the first time. You only try to aim once.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

2
lalolalo21•

As someone who had it done at age 22 I definitely prefer it. My son is coming in a couple weeks but I'm also on the fence. I probably wont do it because it just seems like an unnecessary risk.

2
Picker-Rick•

He can always have it done later. Why not give him the same choice you had?

1
chojnacm•

Unless you are Muslim or Jewish, there is no point. I still have all my junk (so perhaps I am biased), and I never had issues. I am American btw. This procedure is not even an option in most of the world and is falling out of fashion in the US. I mean just think about: the kid just came into the world, why cut him if there is zero medical need. That's my two cents.

2
AnusStapler•

I can imagine that 2000 years ago in the desert climate without running water it had somewhat of a healthy advantage. That this became a religious tradition is absolutely bonkers and should be forbidden.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1†
[deleted]•

[removed]

-1†
jsCaboose•

I am not. Wasn’t really an issue except feeling weird that everyone else was. The only real opinion I have on the subject is- if you decide to do it, wait a bit after birth. There is nothing sadder than a hungry confused new born, until you add angry sore junk to the mix.

1
Picker-Rick•

Another good point to bring up is that the percent of circumcisions had dropped dramatically. So In a class that's only 60% cut, the only determining factor for "normal" is what you were born with.

Ironically circumcising a child now may actually make him not fit in in many places. Some states are reporting as low as 25%

1
dwightschrutesanus•

Thats what we are doing.

Can confirm. I spent quite a bit of time in the military, anyone with an anteater got fucked with during drug tests.

-2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
stibbons•

I have no idea what you just confirmed.

3
dwightschrutesanus•

Military does drug tests with someone from your unit staring at your unit. Usually this is a younger NCO. (first line supervisor) it was not uncommon to be waiting in line to piss in a cup and hear the "cockwatchers" laughing at some dudes dick in the bathroom- unless the "observer" was un-circumsized, it was almost a guarantee that something would be said.

The infantry during the height of GWOT was a weird place. Kind of like a frat intermixed with a prison gang, with access to heavy weapons.

Oh, the things your tax dollars pay for.

0
stibbons•

Not my tax dollars.

1
spacenut37MODBaby Girl b. June 2019•

Please keep the conversation civil on this controversial topic. If you have not commented on r/daddit before, or your account is dedicated to the topic, your comments will be removed.

1
waterbuffalo750•

Now that's some good modding. We don't see a lot of that on Reddit.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
rockdupuss•

My side of the family has had incredible difficulties with being uncut and usually later on in life had to undergo the surgery which is much more complicated and painful. So when my son came along we got him circumcised due to those factors. Otherwise it’s really really a personal matter. My boy didn’t suffer at all, they numbed him up good and he healed quickly. So do what feels right to you. If your wife doesn’t want it cut don’t make a battle of this.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1