Dr. Anthony Fauci says staying closed for too long could cause ‘irreparable damage’
cnbc.com/2020/05/22/dr-anthony-fauci-says-sta...Posted May 22, 2020, 4:24 PM UTC
Posted May 22, 2020, 4:24 PM UTC
Everyone knows the lockdown is not forever. This is consistent with the message he has been delivering the entire time.
If the federal messaging around him was consistent and not politicised there would be a lot less confusion.
Experiment with gradually reopening...
...but let the trade-off be that employees and customers/patrons/shoppers are all required to wear protective masks (with the kids 2 and under and people with special medical conditions being the exception) and require 6+ ft social distancing (10+ feet in my humble opinion).
THIS! This right here is honestly all I want. Out here in Ohio, I don't see anyone social distancing or wearing a mask, and people look at me like I'm crazy for doing so or for asking them to keep their distance. I just think we need to set up some ground rules for this thing and enforce them. It would be so much safer than the haphazard approach see are taking now, with "recommendations" of social distancing etc. that a lot of people seem to be ignoring.
Same in Indiana. It's gotten to the point that I'd be happy if everyone just wore a mask and stayed the fuck away from each other. But that's too much to ask for too many people.
So we'll see what happens! Not a fun wait-and-see. I'm staying the fuck home, though. I'm not catching this and potentially sending people to the ICU (guess we have to stop talking about the dead people because those, apparently, don't matter), and possibly having long term organ failure, or having to file bankruptcy over medical bills.
[deleted]
[deleted]
We’re still distancing and masking in Cleveland. Just south of I480 (the modern, proverbial Mason Dixon Line) is a very different, terrifying story. The next two weeks there should be... revealing.
I wish everywhere were like Cleveland then. :/
Of course everyone is masking up there in Cleveland, it's a Scooby Doo Ghost Town ;-p
Out east of Cleveland near Mentor everyone's apparently over masks. It probably just varies a lot based on the city. But I really hope people get back to the mask wearing.
[removed]
Really? I live in Ohio too and there’s TONS of people wearing masks. Whenever I go to the grocery store it seems like the majority are wearing at least some sort of face covering, and I live in one of those small hick towns that everyone likes to make fun of as these lawless swamps.
My workplace has a lot of mask wearers too, even though it’s not yet required. That doesn’t mean there isn’t a substantial amount of people who don’t bother with masks, but I honestly can’t recall ANYONE who looked at me funny because I was wearing a mask. It just isn’t stigmatized here. Nobody gives a shit.
Don’t really know what environments where you’re not seeing people wearing masks, but it seems like wherever I go the people wear masks.
I live in a decent sized city. Up until a few days ago most people I saw out were wearing masks. At Lowes this morning very few customers had masks on. At Walmart Thursday, more people with fewer masks on. stopped into a game store, nobody had masks on. The atmosphere where I am has changed.
Going out the past week, it's almost as though the pandemic was declared over and done. Workers are wearing masks, but less then half the rest of the people I see are. It's like everyone just said "fuck it, YOLO!"
Yup, that's been my experience as well
Same in rural Texas
[deleted]
[removed]
[removed]
What medical condition would prevent a person from wearing a mask? I saw a lady yesterday with an oxygen tank wearing a mask over her nose thing
Idk if this is a “medical condition” per se, but some people/kids with autism have sensory issues and cannot handle wearing a mask.
Ok so maybe don’t have your autistic child do the grocery shopping :/
Everybody else, mask up so we can turn the freaking world back on.
Edit: okay, single parents of autistic children who also can’t afford Instacart or something can skip putting a mask on their kids BECAUSE FUCKING OBVIOUSLY. If everybody else is wearing one it doesn’t matter anyway, you fucking outrage-monkeys.
Well they probably won't handle a ventilator too well either
It can trigger people with asthma
Asthma sufferer, here. I'd rather use my puffer more frequently than be... you know, dead. Personally, I choose to suck it up.
[deleted]
I have asthma. It's highly unlikely. It's that or, you know, death. We're way more likely to die of this than the elderly
Masks also trigger people without asthma apparently
Oh b***sh**.
Asthma, COPD, Emphysema may all be unable to breathe with a mask. People with claustrophobia may suffer a panic attack. PTSD sufferers may experience a traumatic flashback which can cause them to act out and endanger themselves and others.
I'm sorry but I don't think anxiety is a good enough excuse to endanger yourself and primarily others(me). I don't want to die because some asymptomatic jerkwad has allergies. And anyone with breathing issues should only be out for absolute emergencies like an ER visit, that's on par with being immunocompromised; for example my friend is going through chemo and the only reason he leaves the house is for just that, and he counts on everyone around him to be wearing a mask so he can live.
I have moderate asthma, no trouble wearing a mask. I'd rather wear a mask than die from the virus.
Also, do Americans not think that people in East Asian countries don't suffer from these things? Yet, they were still wearing masks during flu season way before COVID-19...
I imagine if she didn’t have an oxygen tank, her existing condition would pose a problem
her nose thing
Nasal cannula.
Either that or a septum piercing? lol
A nasal cannula, yes thank you!
The mask triggers panic attacks in my husband if he wears it too long. Anywhere it’s mandatory he complies, and avoids going indoors in places where it’s just “encouraged”. If we’re outside (walking trails and the like) he just follows social distancing without a mask though.
[removed]
Why kids 2 and under? Are masks harmful to them?
I take it you don't have a toddler in your life. It's just damn near impossible to get them to keep anything on their head.
Haha that’s a damn good point that I wouldn’t have thought of! 😂 You’re right - no kids in my life
Yeah, it's like trying to put a hat on a dog.
Yes. Kids two and under can't wear masks according to CDC. It's to dangerous for them.
My issue is my 2.5 year old. Technically she should wear a mask. Realistically she won't. We just don't let her in any building not our house. I hope they don't make masks required for walking down the street, though.
Can’t express when they are struggling to breathe.
I thought my two year old would want to wear one so he could look like us, but he immediately pulls it off.
They should make cool masks for kids to wear. Like a ninja mask or something. Make it fun for them.
[deleted]
May as well not reopen since places can't properly function with such requirements.
Let's just cut the foreplay and federally mandate an eternal lockdown per Constitutional amendment.
I live in a state where hardly anyone is wearing masks, we have been open for nearly a month, and our numbers are going down. I think in most places, masks make no difference.
I feel like a lot of people commentating on this article are interpreting Fauci's words the wrong way. He didn't say we shouldn't wait too long before relinquishing orders pertaining to business closures and other social distancing measures otherwise irreparable damage could be caused, period. He said nothing of the sort in the interview.
He was always careful to say that any reopening done anywhere should be following the phased approach outlined in the government guidelines that he has been championing for weeks.
That said, the comments made by the CEO in that interview were retarded. Fauci was just thoughtfully answering the question without ridiculing him.
I read the headline, dammit! That's all the information and understanding I need! An by god, you had better believe I'm going to argue with people who read the actual article and be convinced that I'm right!
Exactly...
That headline is going to be used and abused...
I'd hate to be in Fauci's shoes, you're walking a thin line all the time, and get the occasional misinterpretation, and get blamed for that...
But you get to be played by Brad Pitt on SNL soo..... tradeoffs?
It’s already happening.
[deleted]
Gonna pee myself from laughing at this. And then cry. Both because its true.
The Trump administration wants confusion. They thrive on it.
Everyone? Maybe you're new to this sub...
#TwoMoreWeeks
politicized.
How do you hold any power in America without being political? Religious groups know it. Hollywood knows it. Power first, wellness second.
That's not the way the rhetoric is going. Any easying is being met with insane hysteria, but the point is to divide.
Today I learned: Reddit as a whole thinks all issues are light switches and can't seem to grasp there are possibilities between "too soon" and "too late".
Correct. I can only assume you've been here for like....2 days?
"too" days....
Regardless, somehow this issue has become black and white and all gray has been eradicated and it makes it very difficult to have logical discussions on a path forward. At this rate, I fear that there's no going back to a rationale discussion either unless it goes really bad.
The problem is that our society has gotten to a point within the last 40 or so years that we expect the most troubling things in our society to be solved overnight.
They invented the dimmer switch for a reason and it feels like Reddit isn't aware
We should all accept that reddit doesn't think. But instead, is a website made up of a bunch of individuals.
[removed]
Your comment has been removed because
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
can't seem to grasp there are possibilities between "too soon" and "too late".
are there? Or is opening now both "too soon" and "too late"
My cat, which is both dead and alive inside a box, finds this intriguing.
Jk about the cat. Or not. Maybe both?
When you have over 150000 sick and 100 000 deaths opening now is too soon You are going to see a spike in covid and peopme with two neurons are going to.be like 'we told you so'
[deleted]
[deleted]
Just give it Two Weeks^tm
I saw a tweet saying “just wait till fall. September/October/November is when it’s going to get bad”
People seem to want a dystopian reality lol
September/October/November is when it’s going to get bad
Well, Fauci himself did say it likely will be bad then, due to the overlap with flu season. So that's not an absurd concern. That said, it also doesn't mean that we should be on full lockdown until then, or even during then. We might need to dial things back a little, but I think if we turn the dial forward now in a slow, reasonable way, we won't need to turn it back so hard in the fall.
Basically, I don't think that most people worrying about the fall actually think we should remain on full lockdown until then (I'm sure there are some, there's always some, but they're usually a loud minority). We just need to be careful of the steps we're taking for the time being.
Was that the message? Or two weeks of a downward trend?
Omg I'm 500 lbs and have 3 different heart diseases. Lifting lockdown will literally kill me with no fault of my own. Typical conservatives!
I saw someone sneeze on the street yesterday and three old people watching him from their windows dropped dead on the spot
/s
[deleted]
Yeah these people are silly. We make a decision even in non Covid times to accept some deaths to live life normally. It's balance between doing what ever you want and staying in your house forever.
It's a morbid thought but there's a reason economists put a 5-10 million dollar value on a human life.
I happened to not notice this submission yesterday and posted it from another source today: there were still plenty of upvoted panicked nutjobs in that one:
that questioned the source (fox news) and the content .
Yea... no shit.
Just today a coworker told me now some scientists are saying the lockdowns are making it worse and they don’t know what to believe anymore. I genuinely think we as a society have an issue where nobody reads the articles anymore. You can’t take in all the nuance of the issue from a one sentence quote.
I think the biggest problem is people refuse to read news that might be pretty unknown but accurate. They continue to read or watch the same polarized news that only reports to fulfill an agenda. Ik that the unpolarized ones are far a few between, but people have to watch or read more than Fox or CNN
Know what's even worse? Fucking social media pages. A local page called 6ixbuzztv or something pumps out single sentence headlines on highly complex issues, and always with a negative view. Example, cases dropped to 258 in a day here and there was no word of it (thought it was with a flawed testing methodology imo). Now that testing methodology was vastly improved, and will continue to improve, 441 cases were reported. They immediately take to making a post about this with no auxillary info on how testing had significantly changed. When someone mentioned it was due to a change in testing, they stated that tests were half as many as previous weaks, completely ignoring the change in methodology. They proceed to censor comments and ban users who tell the public to do their own research rather than listen to an instagram page. There's absolutely no transparency to these pages at all.
Ah I’m from the Toronto area too and 6ixbuzz has been seriously infuriating. Idk when they switched from posting memes to trying to be a serious news outlet but they’re really not doing it right.
What really kills it is that even if they’re in the right in terms of sentiment, the practice of censorship is very undemocratic. If I go tell people not to listen to CBC in the YouTube comments of a CBC video, at least CBC won’t censor it. It’s scary that these guys could be getting paid to push certain content with absolutely no disclosure.
The problem is deeper than that but you bring up a good point. Even as someone who gets news from many places and examines biases, it becomes extremely challenging when you see countless articles with purported experts constantly contradicting each other and numerous "studies" that report opposite findings. Like it or not, our news media is polarized and not diversified and you end up with most of America getting news from not even articles but just sensationalist headlines. I don't blame either "side" (although there aren't really sides here) from being misinformed because right now it is damn near impossible to be properly informed.
Yea, you do raise a good point. I think the sad reality is, this virus has been around almost since November (iirc) and still it seems we know nothing about it. So I guess the best thing is to assume that their really are no experts about it at all
I see stuff shared so so often that when I check out the "expert" they're not one. BUT I don't understand how people are supposed to know that? Like I'm a scientist and it even gets me sometimes.
There's obviously no strict definition for who qualifies as an expert. Your status as an expert is generally defined by how much your work and opinions are trusted by the public. The problem is that on the topic of a divided issue, both sides will trust the "experts" that support their opinions. This essentially means experts don't mean anything anymore because each side will point to their experts and no one even considers they are possibly wrong. The media should inform readers about an experts credentials before they make statements imo. Would definitely help, but still not when people run with headlines worded with the "Experts say" titling.
it becomes extremely challenging when you see countless articles with purported experts constantly contradicting each other and numerous "studies" that report opposite findings
Absolutely. As an example, I got downvoted to hell on Reddit (which means nothing in the real world BTW) but when masks started becoming a thing I read alot of studies online that convincingly laid out why most masks don't work, I think they even bashed N95s. So when I see people screeching "the science is clear on masks" I'm like, there is science on both sides. I can't unsee the data that contradicts what you're screeching at me about.
The science is clear as long as the scientist’s conclusion agrees with their preexisting opinion.
You got me.
Can I get a TL;DR?
/s
[deleted]
The JP Morgan study that came out today does indicate that the lockdowns may have little to no effect, or in some cases even make things worse. It's important not to dismiss new evidence just because it goes against your preconceived notions.
I'm having a hard time finding the study itself. As for your link, it's an article by a news outlet that is a step above a tabloid, about an epidemiology report authored by a financial analyst at a banking institution, which says we should reopen the economy.
I'm all for considering new evidence that goes against my preconceived notions, but it needs to come from a more credible source.
I don't have higher confidence in those news outlets, but that's really the smallest of the issues I listed, so for the sake of argument I'll assume the articles portray the original report accurately. That still leaves the issues that the report was authored by someone way outside of his field of expertise, with a vested interest in restarting the economy, and the report itself does not seem to have been made public.
It's an interesting and challenging hypothesis, which I am open to accepting if the data and actual epidemiologists ultimately back it up, but to quote one Twitter reply to the post that you linked:
Without an underlying report, these are just dots someone drew on a graph
-@CT_Bergstrom
Daily Mail is a far right British tabloid
So wait, you're saying that a study funded by an investment bank thinks that people should get back to work? SHOCKING!
The point was to use this short and precious lockdown time to implement a competent plan. We see how that went.
He sees the shitshow around him, and knows it will just continue indefinitely.
It will continue indefinitely provided that Trump is reelected. The way he has botched his handling of the crisis is going to bite him in the ass because he did not take the issue seriously, and absolutely refuses to.
Eh, I disagree. His supporters think he has has handled it "perfectly" or "he's done the best he could given the circumstances." So he's not lost any voters. Which means the alternative candidate has to pick up supporters, specifically in the swing states. As of right now, I see no convincing evidence he has done so.
[removed]
Your comment has been removed because
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
Absentee ballots would make that a non-issue.
Would make what a non issue? Studies have shown that mail in ballots do not substantially benefit either party. Turnout out is increased on both sides.
[removed]
Wow, your really think "orange mad bad" contributes anything here, or even makes sense in this regard. First off, Trump is probably not pro-continued lockdown, so you're saying this continuing indefinitely because of Trump makes no sense. Not to mention, most of the stuff people are criticizing is state/governor specific.
I believe the poster you replied to was saying that the shitshow will go on indefinitely if Trump is re-elected, not the lockdown. Trump is very much about ending the lockdown and he’s made that pretty clear to anyone listening.
Sorry what specific "shitshow" do you think they're referring to? I know some state/local ones but nothing at the national level, unless we want to somehow retaliate vs. China, which I would think Reddit would definitely be against.
It's because of how poorly he has handled this in comparison to other world leaders (Vietnam, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Iceland, Greenland, Australia, New Zealand). Australia has a Prime Minister who bungled the response to the wildfires, and yet even he took this with a more serious air than Donald Trump is.
I only give a shit that Trump takes the matter seriously like the majority of world leaders, and the fact that he is actually acting like an absolute child about wearing a damn mask out in public does not instill confidence in me.
It's more like he is more focused on being re-elected than actually proving he can handle this crisis.
[removed]
I'm asking, in what way, specifically.
Idk what’s going on anymore
Indefinite lockdown is not a luxury everyone can afford. Most can’t ...even if it is the safest option.
EDIT: Thanks for the gold kind stranger!
Unfortunately, Reddit’s base is disproportionately composed of either white-collar corporate professionals or dependents, and can’t imagine what the experience of lockdown is like for people who aren’t.
My pink collar friend got laid off and is currently making more playing World of Warcraft full time and collecting unemployment than he did working two jobs 50-60 hours a week. He's aggressively paying off debt and considering going back to school for a masters degree. I think that says more about the disappearance of the middle class and embarrassing wealth distribution in the states than anything though.
The real victims of lockdown are the "essential workers," AKA serfs, that still have to work their shitty minimum wage job with a bonus chance of catching the virus, and maybe a dash of reduced hours. Maybe they'll get an extra pittance, if their corporate overlord is benevolent enough to bestow it upon them.
My pink collar friend got laid off and is currently making more playing World of Warcraft full time and collecting unemployment than he did working two jobs 50-60 hours a week
That is neither permanent not that long lasting. It's going to end sooner than people think and if they don't/can't get back to work for some reason and don't have money saved up they're going to be in a world of hurt.
I work IT in healthcare so i've been "essential" since the beginning, but since I have to occasionally unplug and plug things back in I have to be in the office. I also had my hours reduced to 30 so I don't qualify for unemployment in my last state (illinois) because I make too much, and I don't qualify in my current state (Missouri) because I haven't worked here long enough. If I'd just been fired/laid off/furloughed I'd be making the same amount that my 30 hours would give me, plus the extra $600.
I'm basically working for unemployment rates at this point.
Does he think this unemployment is going to last forever?
[deleted]
and can’t imagine what the experience of lockdown is like for people who aren’t.
White collar professional describes me. I absolutely can imagine the lockdown experience for others, as my family were farmers and not very wealthy growing up. At the same time, people like my family members keep voting for economic systems that screw them over, and I'm kind of over it. They made choices about what kind of economy they wanted - a very fragile one for most people. I think my own parents should have to live with the consequences.
If the world's wealthiest country has about 2/3 of people being unable to live off savings for a few months, you need to gut check who you think the problem lies with.
I don’t think anyone should “have to live with the consequences”. That’s a regressive, even spiteful idea. We should look toward making the world better for everyone.
Imagine being an older millennial raising a 5 and 3 year old during this time.
Checking in with a 2yr/2mo combo. Pros and cons for sure.
ouch that one hurt
I'm not sure either bias is valid but both trivialize and dismiss the social pressures of the federal and state government officially locking down or reopening. If the state officially says go back to work it's not as simple as "stay quarantined if you want to but let me go back to work". And if the state officially says to lock down it's not as simple as "just stay at home". But in both cases the state needs to take a bigger role to either safeguard at risk employees and customers or in the latter case mitigate poverty. But everyone wants to boil it down to two simple choices because the public has a very short attention span even when they have all the time in the world.
Its not even all about money. People cant do zoom social hours forever. We need human to human interaction. All my friends are starting to have get togethers because contrary to the anti social reddit nerd, most people enjoy times with other people and severly miss it.
[deleted]
Oh I’m definitely not pro indefinite lockdown. I’d start openings now in NY if you could guarantee people would wear masks and maintain a safe distance. I wish I didn’t know so many people my age that didn’t want everything open just so they can get haircuts and go to bars.
Unfortunately we are too damn selfish to wear masks even in NY. The worst hit state and people still can’t put a piece of fucking gauze over their nose and mouth for short periods.
The sad part is it’s not even that annoying just fuckin wear the thing
Well, you can downvote me to hell, but everyone at my job agrees with me....between subway and work and lunch and subway most people would need them on a minimum of 12 hours a day. Sorry, people can virtue signal all they want, no one can be expected to wear a freaking covering OVER THEIR MOUTH THAT THEY BREATH OUT OF for 12 straight hours. Not to mention the need to drink and eat. Or the fact that it's really hot and humid for 4-5 months a year here in NY and that thing is going to get sweaty and nasty by the time people walk into the office in the morning, so people will all be going straight to the bathroom to wash their faces and change masks between June - early Sept. Which also needs we'll all be going to the laundromat more often because most people don't have in unit washers here
It's not safe, it would create a generation of weak humans. We need sunlight, exercise, and importantly, germ exposure. We'd be doing the human race a huge disservice to not return to normal as soon as is reasonable.
No one has told you to not go outside...
Italy was pretty bad. So was france
I'm not aware of any place that has mandated staying indoors all the time.
In my state, I could go for a walk whenever I wanted, and I often did.
Exactly. As an example my mother is semi-disabled...well, disabled, and goes to PT to keep from becoming immobile. I keep telling her to go out and walk around. She needs to keep moving. If she sits inside waiting for this to end, she could definitely end up wheelchair bound (very bad arthritis and related issues). Her PT place needs to open the hell back up.
Go for a walk dude. We are not in China. You're not going to get shot because you went for a lap around the neighborhood.
Look at the comment I was replying to. We can’t eternally lockdown, that’s the most ridiculous idea ever. It hurts your ability to exercise if you can’t access a gym. Some people like to do more than run
How does your brain work? Do you just pick random excuses and throw them out? You can still do all your things you listed.
It’s questionable if that’s the safest option. Coronavirus sucks. Poverty sucks too, and lasts a lot longer.
I've been saying this for ages and people treated me like a grandma killer. Finally this sub is starting to wake up to the reality of the situation.
How do you define safest? Safest against death or safest against covid death? Because its looking like we're going to cause a whole hell of a lot more deaths, negative outcomes and depression that overrides the deaths caused by Covid. But hey, if it buys someone's Grandma a few extra months of isolation inside a nursing home, well that's our metric for success apparently.
What's going on is that complete lockdowns were never a long term strategy even in the health community. It was necessary to bring us out of exponential spread and get the R value down to manageable levels. (the success of that in many areas can be debated I agree but it doesn't change what the plan was).
Lockdowns are damaging to a lot more than the simple "muh economy" that this sub likes to say and has real effects on people's health. We can and will find ways to limit the spread of the virus while starting to return to some normal activities because we have to.
Oh I’m aware but Fauci has been “we’re opening too early” now comes out with this idk
I don't think his message is inconsistent. Here's acknowledging that "too long" is also a bad thing.
Sounds like hedging to me. Probably learned his lesson after the 'don't wear masks' fallout.
If they had spent all their political capital telling people to wear masks instead of locking people down in their homes, they might have been more successful.
Basically shutting up the people saying “we cant lock down forever” like its the actual plan. Same as he always has :)
“But now is the time, depending upon where you are and what your situation is, to begin to seriously look at reopening the economy, reopening the country to try to get back to some degree of normal.”
“But now is the time, depending upon where you are and what your situation is, to begin to seriously look at reopening the economy, reopening the country to try to get back to some degree of normal.”
Reopening in any location at all wasn't his previous stance, so I don't know why you said "Same as he always has :)"
[removed]
Your comment has been removed because
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
Same it’s impossible to follow, no one is on the same page
There's a difference between the soup that is too hot and the soup that is too cold. The subtext is that fauci is being pushed to be a "team player" and advocate for the economy over lives. The farthest he appears willing to go right now is to basically state the obvious
Astroturfing, mostly
*eye roll*
I won’t be surprised if half this subreddit starts saying Fauci and science are wrong.
This subreddit is full of people who are not mentally, emotionally, or academically prepared to grapple with the development of new information through scientific studies. Most of these people have not encountered science that was less than 10 years old and verified 10x over, nevermind evidence that was gathered yesterday. It was always going to be a wild ride.
11 day old account with thousands of karma with PhD in their name trying look smart. Interesting at least...
Stick to his points. Are you implying that this sub is full of very reasonable scientific and medical professionals? Seems to be mostly people interested in apocalypse LARP and heavily censored political commentary.
That post didn't have a point. It made a werid wide sweeping judgment. It's just an interesting account that seems to be trying to discredit one side
No, but they're all backtracking now - "We never meant lockdown until it goes away"
I hate this fucking sub but it's like a trainwreck I can't look away from.
[deleted]
It's amazing for entertainment. There was a guy here that claimed there would "most likely" be 750,000 US deaths by August 1st, and when I asked how he thought that was possible he said "ur obviously unaware of exponential growth, take a math class or two"
When did he say this? Because back in February to the beginning of March, before the appropriate measures had been taken by state officials, the death toll was predicted to be far higher than it is now. 750,000? Maybe not, but still far higher than what we have thanks to the measures in place.
It's fine for entertainment but if you actually come here looking for information or just a sane conversation it can be really alienating and depressing. It's really opened my eyes to how out of touch and hopelessly biased reddit's userbase is.
[deleted]
Lmfao I like how you just make shit up. Like there was ever people saying lockdown forever. People like you live in a fantasy world with constructed villains
However, Fauci also cautioned states against reducing social distancing measures too quickly, adding they must take “very significant precautions.” “In general, I think most of the country is doing it in a prudent way,” he said. “There are obviously some situations where people might be jumping over that. I just say please proceed with caution if you’re going to do that.”
There's nothing he's said in this article that is contradictory to any statements he's made in the past. He's literally pushing the same CDC guidelines to phased reopening that he has been for over a month now.
FaUcI fLiPpEd FlOpped aGaIN
"Fauci is being forced by Trump to say this!"
I've already been seeing it all over social media.
Yes Billy Bob, all of the experts who spent decades studying information that's now being used to dictate public health policy are wrong. You know better though, because you've got "common sense".
Too many people think that everyone else is crazy. But the comments that have been upvoted seem to say otherwise.
Lockdowns can't go on forever obviously but reopening too soon will also cause economic damage as a result of having to shut down to contain the spread again.
Fauci has also said this multiple times, and it's reiterated in the article that we're all commenting on. Reopening safely is necessary to economic recovery and there are still a number of areas where it's not necessarily prudent to do so right now.
Not sure what science you're referring to, but Fauci has made it clear that reopening before the numbers indicate it's safe to do so is a mistake that will have serious consequences, economic and otherwise.
The fact that long-term lockdowns will cause even greater economic damage isn't an excuse to rush to reopen, it means regional and federal governments need to step up to ensure reopening safely is possible.
Fauci and science are wrong
I don't think Fauci is wrong, but what science are you referring to? There's no evidence that avoiding lockdowns or loosening restrictions with such poor containment measures would be beneficial for the economy or that it would have avoided any long-term damage.
It's all rather speculative at this point, and Sweden is sustaining economic damage despite not implementing strict lockdowns.
E: don't know why I'm getting downvoted for asking what science OP is referring to but k.
He’s right and people that would say that here would be downvoted, called grandma killers, called selfish, etc.
Did you read the article?
Fauci also cautioned states against reducing social distancing measures too quickly, adding they must take “very significant precautions.”
“In general, I think most of the country is doing it in a prudent way,” he said. “There are obviously some situations where people might be jumping over that. I just say please proceed with caution if you’re going to do that.”
He's saying to reopen, slowly and manageably, and ensure everyone maintains social distancing, etc. That was always part of the plan.
This isn't telling people to get back to normal; this is telling people you can go out, stand away from other people, and wear a mask, and that's probably okay. But then people read the headline and assume it means we should just give up altogether and return to "normal", which actually would push the death count up.
Odd because the people I saw on here being called grandma killers, myself included, weren’t saying open up everything tomorrow. In fact, many here have been advocating for a slow opening.
So perhaps instead of asking me if I read the article, ask yourself, have you been reading the comments?
I guess that the person who downvoted you before didn't like being told facts.
Most people in this comment section found a headline that validates their pro-reopening stance and heralded it as proving their opponents wrong, but they did not read the article. They are misunderstanding what Fauci meant.
Yeah. I've been pretty vocal about wanting different strategies other than blanket lockdowns as well as being really, really disappointed with what we've seen from the states with regards to preparing for a responsible re-opening (e.g. testing, contact tracing, measures for isolating the vulnerable, mandated updates to sick policies, etc...). I also expressed disappointment that masks aren't mandatory in public spaces in all states, and I've refuted many of the claims on here that say millions will die if we ease the lockdowns, because it's just not mathematically likely at all given people's propensity to self-isolate.
Unless I specifically appeal to this crowd now, no one reads, they just downvote. They see you refuting that millions will die and think that means you are an advocate for killing people so you can get a latte in the morning.
So to u/Cum_Victor's point, unless it comes from Fauci, people will downvote these exact sentiments.
I dunno, go look at some S. Korea threads, people are generally pretty accepting of the point that they never locked down and they didn't even stop travel. Maybe they just don't trust their local governments to be competent enough to do what S.Korea did.
He's saying to reopen, slowly and manageably, and ensure everyone maintains social distancing, etc. That was always part of the plan.
But no one was really saying "re-open without any precautions and go completely normal." Most people with pro-reopening stance were saying "re-open with precautions" which is exactly what Fauci said. But pro-lockdown people kept bringing up discussions about protesters without masks on or people who wanted haircuts as if we were one of them... even though we didn't suggest any of that...
I think the pro-lockdown people fear that the vast majority of the masses will hear "re-open" and immedaitely conjure that image of people standing outside without masks on.
If this headlines around calls to reopen were vehemently about safe reopening, that'd be one thing, but that's not the message being sold to most people right now. Heck, people are freaking out at places where mask-wearing is mandatory. You know, the minimum basic safety thing we can do? Just look at all of the anecdotal reports in this thread about people saying they were at stores where only half of the people were wearing masks.
Sure, if everyone acts sane and safe, reopening is fine. But at this point it's pretty clear that isn't going to happen, because too many dumb people aren't taking the necessary precautions. So our options are unsafe reopening or continued lockdown. Neither is good, but one leads to fewer people dying of COVID-19.
who's upvoting this crap
I was once very pro-lockdown. This thing was scary and there were a lot of unknowns early on. But it's now becoming more apparent that this thankfully isn't as bad as the intial models led us to believe. More importanly IMO, it's become apparent that we should really be concentrating our efforts in protecting elderly and seriously ill.
We need to listen to peer-reviewed science. Not Presidents promising testing will ramp up tomorrow. Not governors who make knee-jerk decrees forcing infected people into nursing homes, nor mayors telling people to completely ignore this and "go out and catch a movie".
We need to be careful but be pragmatic about where to allocate our care.
[deleted]
I like the local subreddits that post pictures and say they're calling the mayor and you should too.
My God when did everyone become taddle tale Karens?
[deleted]
Yeah my city's subreddit is filled with people asking things like "My neighbors have two friends over and are drinking beer in the backyard right now, WHAT CAN I DO TO STOP THIS?"
Or the never ending posts about seeing children playing together outside. OH THE HUMANITY
The models weren't wrong mathematically, they were just extremely bad at predicting human behavior. When you tell billions of people over and over again that their parents and grandparents are gonna die or they could wind up in the ICU, they perk up and listen. Voluntary mitigation efforts were over and above what any of these models predicted at all.
If you look at the methods used by the ICL group who famously predicted that 2.2 million Americans would die without non-pharmaceutical interventions, they basically predicted 50-75% compliance with all these measures. As in, they figured in the government mandated social distancing, then we'd still have 25% the number of birthday parties, house parties, movie nights, group trips, etc... He assumed that 30% of people who were diagnosed would basically say, "fuck it, I'm going out anyway."
Then some researchers from Sweden in early April took that same model and cried out to their government, "look, there will be 96,000 deaths by the end of June if we continue down this path." The government ignored that report and continued. Today they are around under 4,000 deaths. Why? Because people take precautions. Because even when you don't mandate social distancing, house parties and birthday parties and movie nights plummet to well below 30% of normal values in the middle of a once-in-a-century deadly pandemic.
We may find the true challenge is not in containing this to well below Ferguson's best case scenario 1.1 million deaths, but in managing to get people to safely spend money to keep the economy going. "May" being the optimal word there. It is an evolving situation.
I am a mathematician by training and a software engineer because money. I do not have formal training or education in epidemiology, as a disclaimer, but my comment is not criticizing any assumptions the early models made about the disease or human behavior.
The Imperial College model was atrocious. If anybody in the software industry delivered code that was even half as bad, they would be fired. It was completely unreadable (and thus unmaintainable), tests did not provide a reasonable level of code coverage, and no documentation is anywhere to be found.
A mathematical model cannot be trusted if it is written like this. There would be no apparent way to identify bugs or mishandled edge cases, aside from the most obvious ones. I wrote more reliable models as an undergrad researcher, and my undergrad research models were terrible.
That the world made such heavy-handed policy decisions on the basis of code that wouldn't even be considered viable by the lowest of industry standards is shocking.
I'm not a mathematician or data scientist, so I didn't mean to specifically criticize the model itself. But somewhere between all the data we were/are collecting and the policies that were implemented by governments there was a problem.
And I'm not one to jump on every little problem. I get that models and predictions aren't perfect and that mistakes happen. What we want to avoid is these trillion-dollar mistakes.
[removed]
That's the problem, no one has used peer reviewed science since this started. Where are the studies for pro lockdown?
He’s saying we can reopen if we take drastic measures and changes in the way we do things.
He’s not saying it’s time to go back to normal
My dream scenario for how to reopen...
Lock down at the beginning to hammer the exponential growth.
During the lock down, ramp up production of tests and PPE.
Give short term aid to the people who need it.
Set up contact tracing so any future outbreak can be better managed.
Inform your population of proper preventative measures they can take (ie. social distancing, mask wearing, hand washing).
Set up protocols with your businesses to minimize risk of transmissions going forwards.
Assist any businesses that simply can't reopen without putting people at undue risk (aid).
Slowly reopen as new cases drop to manageable levels.
By now you should have enough testing capabilities to do randomized mass testing of reopened business employees to limit potential spread and boost confidence of customers.
Incentivize local purchasing over foreign goods with tax credits or some form of monetary benefit to prevent local businesses from dying off. Plus the economic benefits in accordance of the 'velocity of money' concept.
Overly simplified of course, because there should also be proactive changes like renting out hotels for homeless people so they don't become a spreading vector. Among other things.
That would have been absolutely ideal. Ramping up tests and PPE alone would have gone so far in order to facilitate reopening. Ideally we should have strived to produce enough tests to test every American twice with enough PPE for every American to have multiple masks, gloves and bottles of hand sanitizer. Obviously this would have taken months but a vaccine will take years. Unfortunately we still haven’t ramped up like we should have been doing in February.
This is very well laid out. Thank you.
Yeah everything you said has some minor nuances that get in the way, but it's SUCH a reasonable plan. Another thing to add is an information campaign on how takeout food or delivery is NOT of significant risk. Lot's of people my fathers age still believe if you get takeout you're going to get the virus and die, and that is definitely not benefitting local restaurants.
My mom and dad claim to be pretty relaxed about the whole thing, however this was as my mother was wiping down a bag of chips with bleach, and my father was telling us that we were being unnecessarily risky by ordering takeout once or twice a week. We’ve definitely been able to see some different risk thresholds for people in the past few months...
Its been time to go back to normal.
Bruh, what? We won't be going back to normal for a while.
Ok. Everything should be though. Old people and at risk quarantine and everyone else carry on. Pretty simple.
You realize places like restaurants are incredible spreaders of the coronavirus, right?
How old were you when you first realized you were crazy?
Im the crazy one? 40 million people dont have jobs. Children are going to starve to death. How the fuck does it make me crazy to know this virus attacks primarily old people? People like you are so sheltered in their bubble you dont even realize what the fuck is going on.
Yes.
This while be the new normal for a while, reopening or not, and regardless of whether or not you think its fair. If not a lockdown, a limiting of events and prolonged social-distancing and mask-wearing.
Reopening won't make the virus or the economic issues magically vanish.
A lot of doomer back peddling going on in this thread, which is promising.
[removed]
2 more weeks!
lol ok I'll bite: "2 more weeks" what?
r/coronavirus just divided by zero
r/coronavirus punching the air right now
He said couple of other things but this is the headline for some reason. Yeah, of course, the lockdown is temporary situation only possible for limited time and preferably during the peak of cases.
edit: the full interview https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0S-zBs_WaKI. Sounds different in context after 10:30 .
This morning- "le drumph is literally a murderer and repubs are literally satan for suggesting we start to reopen business reeeeeeeeee!!!"
3 hours later- "its definitely time to start rolling back restrictions. It's the sensible and smart thing to do."
Fuck this community so hard. There is literally no thought other than what your political overlords tell you to think.
The article is a little more nuanced than this. Fauci is still very pro-caution. This headline doesn't capture everything Fauci said and seems a little out of context.
“I don’t want people to think that any of us feel that staying locked down for a prolonged period of time is the way to go,” he told CNBC.
Fauci also cautioned states against reducing social distancing measures too quickly, adding they must take “very significant precautions.”
“In general, I think most of the country is doing it in a prudent way,” he said. “There are obviously some situations where people might be jumping over that. I just say please proceed with caution if you’re going to do that.”
The article is a little more nuanced than this.
Thank you, tool. That's exactly my point. This morning there was no nuance. Anybody suggesting any sort of reopening was a grandma killing devil. The top post of the past day is actually a CJ where people were raging that it was too early to talk about reopening. Have a fucking backbone and try taking an opinion that isnt 100% based on what your political party told you is the correct way to think.
While I agree and this validates a lot of what I've been experiencing on here lately, I also think the upvote system contributes to this. People who don't even feel that way will literally change their comments to be more pro-lockdown or anti-reopening because they don't want to be downvoted. This creates a positive feedback loop leading to groupthink.
This is why reddit has to bring back the feature where you can see how many upvotes AND downvotes every post has.
Ok so I’ll start this by saying pls don’t downvote me too much, but this sub has definitely changed its tone on the staying closed thing. Like I’m not picking a side as to whether we stay closed or we open or we partially open, I just see it as an interesting change I thought I’d point out.
Yep! Only a couple more weeks until everyone starts saying “we knew this from the beginning, stupid doomers!”
bro if this happens i will seriously lose my fucking shit
It’s almost as if, when presented with new evidence, people can change their perspective 🤔 I have changed my tone and why should that be shameful? Better than being stubborn.
Maybe Fauci will convince all those loony "if it saves one life" people that they're being ridiculous. He seems to be the guy they all still trust.
I thought he said recently lockdown ls were getting lifted to early. Im so confused.
These positions aren't mutually exclusive if you actually read what he said.
[removed]
Your comment has been removed because
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
I try to consider myself a moderate who can listen to both sides but things like your statement make me think I have little in common with your inability to see logic.
[deleted]
[deleted]
[deleted]
Yep, this is the issue. No one logical is saying we should be locked down forever or until a vaccine. But there’s a difference between reopening as a free for all when cases and hospitalizations are still on the rise like some states are versus a slow, phased opening when the numbers allow it.
Clearly you don't read this subreddit.
I said no one logical lol
Yeah I was mentioning how it was a good move to open restaurants but move them outdoors. And someone accused me of wanting to kill people so I can get a meal. A lot of scientists are saying it's not smart to hinge our hopes on a vaccine. Even if we do get a vaccine we can't keep businesses closed for another 6-18 months. Somethings gotta give.
But at the same time all these yokels packing bars and refusing masks aint it either.
r/murderedbywords
So no one in this sub then.
Absolutely. Was reading someone earlier say that they wouldn't see a problem with being locked up for another year because their job still works remotely. Like do people not realize the domino effect and collateral damage that will result from being shut down. Even remote jobs will lay people off of there is no economy to sustain it.
A significant amount of people on this sub do not realize those domino effects or they just don’t care .
I think this sub was one of THE WORST doom-surfing places to visit during the outset of the pandemic.
It was so just like catastrophically pessimistic or something, that my peanut brain was like "HEYYY, STOP" at some point.
You're only paying attention to half the comments. The other half comes here thinks we need to sacrifice bodies for the economy. Saw a commenter say he would be OK with his brother dieing if it meant the economy was functioning
Reddit is way to polarized to have a discussion on.
I know. It disgusts me how they spin good news to make it doom and gloom. News of a possible vaccine being ready? People say itll still take months of testing before it can be publicly used. Number of cases dropped below 20,000 new cases? People say its only because the numbers are typically lower an Sundays and Mondays, Mothers Day further reduced the results and say how sad the country is when were celebrating 20,000 new cases in a single day.
thinking this might be the root of many of your problems
I'm shocked you're getting upvotes. I've been downvoted to oblivion multiple times here over the past few weeks for suggesting that certain areas should try to start opening up. Reopening decisions should be adjustable and made locally based on local results.
Just imagine how much we could accomplish in slowing down the virus if everyone just did their part and truly social distanced, wore masks, and accepted this is life for a little while. No more protests. No more political BS and crazy motives. This too shall pass. So the masses best suck it up, get used to this weird new normal so we can get back to our old normal as soon as possible.
If you think we are going back to our "old normal" you haven't been paying attention. When has the government ever given back the power it has taken during times of panic or fear? We are still fighting illegals wars because of a terrorist attack our government literally let happen, we never went back to the pre 9/11 normal what makes you think this will be any different?
Oh, I have been paying very close attention since January. Very much so and very deeply.
Old normal as far as not having a virus to worry about, is what I was referring to. Sorry I was not specific.
Regarding 3000 other moving parts, political agendas, ruthless controls, widening gap between rich/poor, jobs, this, that, and everything else... yes. I know once we emerge we will be living in a very different world.
It will just be up to the individual how much they want to play and get tangled on that side. What that side will look like will depend on how much the average citizen can tolerate. And from what we have seen thus far, it’s sadly a lot, IMO.
Honestly it's because the post-9/11 changes didn't affect many people or have a huge impact on middle America's life. I've been thinking about this a lot as a healthcare worker who is disheartened daily at the lack of unity and shared sacrifice and the whiny crybabies posting Facebook live videos on how awful it is to wear a mask for 10 minutes inside a Home Depot.
After 9/11, Americans by and large supported stripping away civil liberties (Patriot Act), accepted torture and foreign CIA run "black sites," the suspension of legal rights for enemy combatants at Guantanamo Bay, getting dragged into a war with a country that had nothing to do with the attack, and weren't really all that bothered when the warrantless wiretapping/FISA court scandal broke. Because if you're doing nothing wrong you have nothing to worry about and we apparently can all rally behind foreign wars and Muslims are scary (I guess?)
Now these same people are acting as if shutting down Applebees and wearing a cloth mask when you leave your home is peak government tyranny despite the fact that this virus will kill more Americans than middle eastern terrorists could even dream of. And honestly I think it's because the vast majority of post 9/11 overreaches never affected them. There was no draft, no increase in taxes to pay for any of our BS foreign intervention, they didn't know anyone getting tortured or detained in Guantanamo Bay, and no terrorist wants to plot to blow up a strip mall in whatever obsolete, irrelevant town they live in so they weren't getting interrogated about what the FBI overheard on the phone calls they weren't legally supposed to be listening to.
So yes, pandemics happen and this too will eventually pass. And no, the government will not be able to continue forcing us inside or putting masks over our face after we develop an effective treatment or vaccine or the cases start to die down for whatever reason because it simply affects too many Americans who are unwilling to comply, which is in stark contrast to the changes we made after 9/11.
Not to mention that politicians are mostly motivated by money and our post-9/11 changes were a huge boon for the military industrial complex and made many politicians rich. They have the opposite incentive in Coronavirus and that's why Donald Trump is looking to reopen the country despite growing number of cases, because it's hurting the bottom line. So the entire incentive structure for the government "power grabs" are completely reversed in these scenarios.
I can easily see some people in the government benefiting from being able to pour money to their crony friends through illegal wars or spying the people en masse through terrorist laws, but I can't see what would be the benefit from anyone in government for being able to stop people from going to have a haircut or work in an office or forcing people to wear a masks.
The closest I can think of any of the terrorist laws would be some sort of contact tracing app whose data is then collected into a central server. But in order to make people to actually install that app on their phone, the government would have to convince them that it is not going to do that. When it's snooping people's internet use through NSA, it doesn't have to ask anyone to install anything on their computers.
And in any case, unlike terrorism, this would come to an end pretty soon. The terrorism laws have been in place soon for 20 years and there is no sign of them being taken down. You can credibly make the case that terrorists are going attack immediately if they are taken down. However, once there is a vaccine for covid-19, you can't make a case for any social distancing orders or anything limiting people's liberties based on a threat of a pandemic. So, at best the government would get some extra power for a limited amount of time.
Saying literally let happen is an extremely strong take on what was mass incompetence
I think that the social distancing is looks very different for different people. To expect some people to not socialize with another living being for months on end or others to be cooped up in a tiny apartment with many people compared with others that live with their family units in nice spacious homes isn't being very equitable. I think it's totally shelter in place for some families indefinitely, while for others it isn't so practical. It sounds like you are ready to take on not leaving your house for a few month and that is commendable.
Well thank you. It’s not easy, but as a single parent, I want this to end ASAP for my child.
That's why I think the conservative policy around reopening is a good idea. You have to account for the selfish people who will do what they want anyway. Give an inch take a mile.
uh I see this on every fucking thread on this sub
But I wouldn't argue that they are logical...
I've been accused if it several times when I've never said it.
From people arguing a straw man, yeah.
[deleted]
Yes, you are right. There are tons of such strawman arguments in this sub.
Pretty much every "I think we should be careful with the reopening" comment is met with "so, you want to stay locked down until there is a vaccine. Checkmate, doomer. LOL."
The downvotes are coming from both sides for this nuanced realistic take.
You may want to check out Gov Newsom's pronouncements (among many others). but your point stand, no one logical
Social distancing measures ARE NOT A LOCKDOWN.
Social distancing, hygiene, mask wearing, no huge gatherings etc. are going to stay in place until there's a vaccine or a miracle treatment.
Can hygiene include a proper diet and exercise so we don't have an obese population ripe for the picking? No one is throwing weight loss and discipline into the pot of things that need to be done. Easier to stay 30lbs overweight and wear a mask for that fuzzy achievement feeling.
Social distancing makes dating and normal human interaction impossible. That's why people especially young people are ignoring it.
Mayor Garcetti makes Newsom look reckless.
Which one you're talking about?
Every day he keeps giving announcements of this or that thing reopening.
This one is the latest:
Newsom: CA Days Away From Plan to Reopen Barbershops, Salons, Churches
“No one logical is saying we should be locked down forever or until a vaccine.”
You must have missed a few billion posts on this sub and other subs. Some American politicians even lean this direction.
Glad Fauci is speaking on this. There are a lot of people who don’t grasp the reality and think opening up means politicians they don’t like are trying to murder everyone.
A big problem is that we didn’t use the time we had once the shutdowns began to massively ramp up production of PPE, cleaning supplies and everything needed to help life go back to something resembling normal. Staying in a full shutdown until the vaccine was never an option and so the question becomes how do we reopen and when to minimize risk and right now we still aren’t producing enough of the things we need to truly minimize risk.
Great point. Not sure why we got down voted though? For not fear mongering and speaking rationally? lol
lmao. it's hilarious to watch this sub backpedal
I mean, only 40% of the economy is non-essential, we never completely closed, we just need to get the 40%, masks, cleaner and social distances.
To be fair we probably shut down too dramatically. Hospitals are starving and most are completely empty besides select hotspots. Most of the hospitals I speak to daily are laying off staff and are in dire economic situations. These are the people that are supposed to be ‘saving us’ Smh. The whole situation have been overly politicized on both sides and this is going to cause terrible economic and health consequences.
Thank you. I keep reading people say "Do YoU wAnT tO StAy LoCKdOwN fOrEveR?"
Uhhhh, nope. I just thought the unbelieveable sacrifice of locking down in order to reduce our case load was done so to reach contact tracing capacity across the nation. Going forward we would still wear masks, social distance, and limit gatherings... but begin reopening where we could! Plus we had to help those who couldn't/shouldn't return to work by strengthening unemployment and other safety nets with federal dollars.
Instead people seemed to view the lockdown as an end to itself. Hey, flatten that curve, we're down now! Well, idk. We didn't lock down enough to really get cases low enough. We didn't build up our contact tracing capacity enough. We didn't educate the public on what to expect. We didn't standardized what reopening looks like. Now we have states opening up with a range of asinine approaches. Looking at georgia in particular freaks me out. Their testing protocol backdates cases up to 2 weeks. How could people even see an outbreak coming? It's just so crazy.
People really seem to think this is a man-made problem that we can just imagine away, instead of a real practical problem we need to solve with wide spread and common sense approaches. Ohio is allowing gatherings up to 300 people. It's so irresponsible.
I want shit to re open. I'm so so so sick of being inside. But I also know this outbreak is still on going and we have to act intelligently. There's a wide array of options between fully open and fully locked down. We needed to strike an intelligent balance going forward. We're not.
Agreed wholeheartedly. It doesn’t give me confidence when tons of people are refusing to do simple things like social distance and wear a mask. If everyone could just get on board, we could open relatively safely. But some people want to just pretend the problem doesn’t exist and is fake. It feels very hopeless.
Are you seeing that in public were you are? I read about it happening online, but the few times I went in public the past 2 months I see everyone wearing their mask and respecting personal distance.
Grocery store on Tuesday, only about half the customers were wearing masks. All the employees were (though one would pull hers off to talk to a co-worker, which helps no one).
So where I’m at once the county opened on the 20th basically mask usage dropped dramatically. Before I would say people seemed to stay inside and wear masks, now I barely see people wearing masks and a lot more people just walking around so I don’t have high hopes for the future
I’m avoiding public places as much as possible. So far people are good about wearing masks in stores for the most part where they are required (I’ve only been to the pharmacy once to get a critical antibiotic that couldn’t be mailed to me in time and picked up a few other items while I was there, otherwise I’ve only done curbside pickup for all our other supplies) but terrible about wearing them while just out and about. That trip to the pharmacy, the people behind me in line ignored the little x on the ground and stood DIRECTLY behind me, it was so annoying. Even without social distancing I would have felt like they were invading my personal bubble. People seemed pretty casual about passing each other in the aisles too, or standing close to me if they were looking at products that were near the ones I was looking at, forcing me to walk away even though I was there first. I’m in California where we have as a whole taken things more seriously than some of the rest of the country
I am. Southern Utah, I'd say maybe 10% of people wear masks going into walmart etc. There's just a huge sense of entitlement here, or people who think they know more than health officials and it's "just the flu"
Work in S.GA. nobody is wearing masks or distancing there
I dont konw about you but as for me, my family and the overwhelming majority of my neighborhood, we have all been doing our part. We stayed inside most of the time. Everywhere I go to that has remained open be it, supermarkets, restaurants that were just doing pickup and delivery or mechanics have everyone working or shopping wearing a mask. Even barbershops that reopened have you check in by phone call and have you wait in your car until they are ready to see you and when you enter everyone barbers and customers are wearing masks too.
That’s good to hear. Hopefully the vast majority of people will get on board with needing to take safety measures seriously.
A lot of people on this sub wanted to stay in lockdown for years or more until there was a vaccine.
Youre being disingenuous when representing the anti-lockdown with your rhetoric.
Funny now I see people on r/coronavirus changing their tune. As if they forgot the extreme pro lockdown opinions they had just a month ago.
Yeah, I don't believe you.
Here's an example. You said, "Are you actually saying we should all just stay inside forever?"
You get people saying "So MaNy pEopLe sAy ThaT ANd tHeY'rE SO StUpId." Except no one actually suggests it! You do get some responses with common sense approaches to what they want.
If you want to find some examples of people suggesting indefinite lock down, go ahead. I haven't read it.
Keep down voting me. It's the only way to protect your silly strawman argument.
I have seen people saying we might have to lockdown until a vaccine. They are not the majority, but they exist.
https://www.reddit.com/r/Coronavirus/comments/fxkzy3/lockdowns_cant_end_until_covid19_vaccine_found/
[deleted]
No one is saying lockdown forever. They're saying indefinitely...which is about the same as forever in real world terms.
K. I guess you dont really understand nuance.
[deleted]
[deleted]
Facts.
[deleted]
what scares me too is when I was flipping channels and landed on QVC by accident and they were selling "BREATHABLE" masks which to me are masks that let MR. CORONA right into your lungs. my bosses want to open up the office to all staff June 1. And I'm not sure that my office is as safe as one would require before one makes the arrangements to travel as safely as possible but you have to pay the mortgage or you risk that you will get bounced out of your house. this situation is absolutely insane.
You understand that the main purpose of the mask wearing is to stop you from spreading the virus to others when you speak or cough by stopping the droplets flying into the air from your mouth. I'm not sure how the "breathable" mask works, but I can imagine that it could be effective at stopping the droplets.
By the way, that's the original purpose of surgeon masks as well. They protect the patient that has an open cut from any germ from surgeons mouth going in there. It's not supposed to protect the surgeon.
PPE is a different thing.
So why did the NP put a surgical mask on before she came into the room to tell me I had mycoplasma pneumonia? She said "your test came back positive, and I don't want to catch it."
Humans are gross, too. We spew a bunch of droplets by yawning and sighing too. When most people develop immunity to common illnesses and vaccinate for the deadly ones, you don’t really think about how much potentially infectious matter we leave everywhere.
I might actually get one! I don't care how many people screech at me when I say I find it hard to breath through masks that doesn't change the fact THAT IT IS HARD TO FREAKING BREATH which is more important than preventing a disease. I also notice that not one person has ever offered any suggestion or help, they just say I'm lying or name call, which proves I'm right. So at this point I'm just concerned with fulfilling whatever mandate
If your lungs can't even handle breathing through a cloth mask, you're going to have a much bigger problem breathing when you catch corona.
It's not fulfilling a mandate to wear a mask that lets corona through. You're basically wearing a fashion accessory. Have you considered asking a doctor why you find it harder to breathe with a mask? That doesn't seem normal.
You have much bigger issues than finding a breathable mask if you have trouble with a simple cloth mask.
My suggestion: stay at home.
Breathing through a mask is supposed to be difficult. It really is hard! For some people who have very bad lungs it's not possible for them to wear a mask and still get the air they need.
People with medical conditions that prevent them from wearing masks just need to accept that they can't go to the stores and spaces that require people to wear them. They'll have to get someone else to do their shopping or have it delivered to their door which is what I've been doing for months.
It's perfectly fine to have limitations, but it's not okay to use them as a justification for putting other people at risk.
Sometimes people get a psychological panic response to breathing warm, moist air. Air hunger can make it feel like you aren’t getting enough oxygen when, in fact, you are. It might be a good idea to follow up with a doctor (as long as the medical system where you are isn’t inundated) to check for asthma and see if your o2 stats are good. We on Reddit aren’t professionals so it’s hard to give advice on what will help you in particular. Sometimes it’s a matter of changing the fabric, or even just wearing it for small amounts of time to acclimate yourself to it. If you have asthma, you can potentially get a maintenance medication so your lungs don’t get irritated when you wear one.
People calling you names is awful. Most people find masks hard to breathe in at first and it’s a matter of figuring out what the problem is if it persists. I hate my mask, but it’s way easier to breathe in than the N95 I have to wear during fire season so I don’t spend 24 hours a day coughing.
Ummmm.... aren't all the masks breathable or you would die?
I had one mask of real thick cloth which did make breathing a bit more difficult.
Some places are not* and I'm sorry if you live in a place that isn't. I personally think here in MD we are doing a good job (at least my county is). I also have only observed one or two people in a WaWa not wearing a mask this whole time during lockdown (and for what it's worth for all those people that prejudge people based on their voting history I live in a very pro-trump part of town)
Which county do you reside in? I was at the local post office and the staff there were not wearing masks despite compulsory masks in this state lmao.
AA county. Haven't been to my local post office during the crisis though so they may be doing the same. I come to this sub and it's very doom and gloom but I'm usually seeing very reasonable people everywhere I go. (Which is obviously limited)
Wait, I thought you people said it was to "flatten the curve" and save the healthcare system... now it's for a contact tracing system?
The lockdown was to flatten the curve. Contact tracing is to prevent more lockdowns in the future. Logically if the country returns to business as usual, within a few months we would have to close once more to flatten the curve again. You cannot do the same thing twice and expect different results.
Flatten the curve was the first step. Sorta like how you preheat the oven before cooking dinner. Fauci et. al. were very clear on this the entire time.
Bullshit. Flatten the curve was the only stated goal at the time. You're moving the goalposts
"you people" smdh
well said
[removed]
Maybe using something like this: https://healthweather.us/?regionId=13121&mode=Atypical
On that you can see the covid-19 peak and then it coming down as the social distancing measures took effect. If that starts going up, you know that people are getting fevers, which means that they are getting sick. This will alert you even before people are that sick that they seek medical care and testing for covid.
Yes, you won't have the same kind of details as you have from mass testing and contact tracing, but you do see if an outbreak is happening.
Too bad most people aren't acting intelligently.
all it takes is a chance encounter with anyone who failed their chance encounter. I had a real bad flu this year. I thought that was COVID and was shocked with a negative antibody test result. IF that was just the FLU and I was coughing my lungs out and out of breath a couple of times during that 2 week hell I can only imagine having to get put on a ventilator. THAT IS the reality that most people who do not wear masks are not considering IF you get lucky and come across that one person in a million that has COVID you will end on a ventilator.
Come on, stop buying into the narrative that corona is ALWAYS worse. I don't even think doomers think that. I know 5 people who've had it (relatively healthy all early 40s) and only one said it kept dragging on. No one said it was super horrible, just the one girl who said it wouldn't go away...
[removed]
I like how you skip making any rational argument and just go straight to personal attacks. Very convincing, thank you.
[removed]
Opening was never in dispute. The red herring is the anti-mask movement. Hopefully people will see that even the President will wear a mask if it is asked of him whether he agrees with it or not.
[removed]
Examples of recent BLM violence:
Man stomped and stoned for trying to defend a bar from being looted
https://streamable.com/xkcvkk
Destroying store and beating unarmed woman and her husband
https://streamable.com/rvrwil
Beating and stomping guy on the ground Santa Monica
https://streamable.com/x6ue5x
Restaurant manager beaten and stomped for trying to defend his workplace
https://streamable.com/ila4dh
Stopping, beating and stomping a truck driver while protesters yell to kill him
https://streamable.com/8zk9dq
Protesters attack a media member and then pummel him
https://streamable.com/p4i3jb
Chasing guy and kicking him in the face for defending flag in Portland
https://streamable.com/ky6jyh
Police officer beaten on the streets
https://streamable.com/je4ki5
Car runs over a cop
https://streamable.com/q4nat7
Protesters set homeless man’s belongings on fire
https://streamable.com/sdjvfa
Throwing fireworks at the cops
https://streamable.com/7sv4a9
Looting a FedEx truck then looter gets dragged when truck tries to escape
https://streamable.com/n1azx3
Chasing and beating guy with red had
https://streamable.com/rcsmi0
Rioter sets himself on fire while trying to set a building on fire
https://streamable.com/w5wa8l
Fireworks thrown into CNN hq / Police officers
https://streamable.com/7dw6g7
Protester runs over the cops with an SUV
https://streamable.com/ttijvn
Destroying/looting/setting on fire Old Navy
https://streamable.com/oceqqg
Guardhouse in front of WH set on fire
https://streamable.com/vfopia
Dozens of cars destroyed/torched near CNN hq – Atlanta
https://streamable.com/ubjohz
St Louis neighborhood on fire
https://streamable.com/8lnd7v
Building on fire while self-proclaimed Mexicans say fuck white people
https://streamable.com/yvkek4
Destroying police SUV
https://streamable.com/2b7fic
Near a torched car audio speakers propaganda that all crime is legal
https://streamable.com/t76kdn
Destroying/looting bank in Montreal
https://streamable.com/3hwkx2
Pharmacy destroyed/looted in Dallas
https://streamable.com/fl7e5z
The remains of whole neighborhood destroyed
https://streamable.com/dtptr1
Destroying stores – Dallas
https://streamable.com/hn1qng
Destroying police SUV – Austin
https://streamable.com/v8zk1e
Police SUV torched LA
https://streamable.com/61mdlo
Looting target/beating disabled person in Minneapolis
https://streamable.com/oyjgbk
Future apartment building destroyed with fire in Minneapolis
https://streamable.com/dxmc0w
Looting pharmacy – Minneapolis
https://streamable.com/53nl1p
Destroying business in Minneapolis
https://streamable.com/5lm779
More businesses on fire in Minneapolis
https://streamable.com/f1zcmy
Ransacked Target Minneapolis
https://streamable.com/b3u92p
Building burning in neighborhood Minneapolis
https://streamable.com/vh5nyu
Boy drove car into a store
https://streamable.com/nrm2pn
Post office looted/destroyed
https://streamable.com/v4vflf
Minneapolis third police precinct set on fire
https://streamable.com/o27w75
More buildings on fire Minneapolis
https://streamable.com/8au2lf
Autoparts Store getting destroyed/looted
https://streamable.com/dum1r8
Autozone on fire
https://streamable.com/vq9hrp
Looting in Minneapolis
https://streamable.com/jfor5g
Adults loot with their children
https://streamable.com/m4cr5j
Cars torched – Minneapolis
https://streamable.com/mmk9gr
Looting an ATM in Minneapolis
https://streamable.com/ht2oxv
Remains of destroyed/looted Cub Foods
https://streamable.com/qhzlm7
Business and stores on fire in Minneapolis
https://streamable.com/jcpdvv
Brenda Lenton’s home and belongings destroyed by a fire – Minneapolis
https://streamable.com/3s9l17
Aftermath of whole neighborhood being set on fire in Minneapolis
https://streamable.com/eat2c0
Nashville city hall set on fire while rioters cheer
https://streamable.com/b3y0ep
Fox reporters chased out with projectiles thrown at them near White House
https://streamable.com/1qzyua
Attacking drivers Tulsa, Okla
https://streamable.com/ixpxh9
Setting St. John’s Church on fire
https://streamable.com/u3y4ch
Destroying/looting stores Montreal
https://streamable.com/92h4rr
Destroying/looting store in Downtown Oakland
https://streamable.com/y9s4x9
Bar destroyed/Trying to loot a safe
https://streamable.com/yzprm5
Stolen Bulldozer in Oakland
https://streamable.com/lhf5ze
Two police SUVs torched in Seattle
https://streamable.com/eketpr
Multiple cars torched in Philadelphia
https://streamable.com/13784m
Ohio Statehouse being destroyed
https://streamable.com/k13b3l
Trying to breach Justice Center/central police precinct Portland
https://streamable.com/avcfq0
Destroying/Looting Justice Center Portland
https://streamable.com/1j6fof
Looting small business in Portland
https://streamable.com/bfs08c
Destroying/looting small business Portland
https://streamable.com/adfxxt
Looting Louis Vuitton store
https://streamable.com/f4ysu9
Driving stolen cars into stores – Portland
https://streamable.com/o1w92j
Destroying Chase Bank – Portland
https://streamable.com/o1wtom
Setting Chase Bank on fire – Portland
https://streamable.com/nanakz
Destroying/Looting Apple Store – Portland
https://streamable.com/2wncgk
Looting in St. Paul
https://streamable.com/6fouwt
Looting Shoe Store
https://streamable.com/60v3xh
Looting apple store
https://streamable.com/1wzq39
Looting North Face store – NYC
https://streamable.com/ux7djn
Nike Store being looted – NYC
https://streamable.com/6sdcb3
Looting in Union Square – NYC
https://streamable.com/jiz3zd
Looting T-mobile store
https://streamable.com/ag5kwc
Shop owner saves store from looters with a firearm
https://streamable.com/5oj1jl
Business owner defends his store from looters with a firearm
https://streamable.com/pmdjkb
[deleted]
And should you be technically free to walk around in public naked? As long as you're consistent.
I agree 100%.
There are stores putting up signs that they will refuse service to people who wear masks. It's insane.
alot of people already had it, some areas of NYC have 43% positive antibody tests.
others have immune systems
the pro mask people seem like the "give them an inch they'll take a mile" crowd - they keep wanting to close things with no proof, for example, that going to be beach causes any illness, they just seem like control freaks. One does not concede anything to those types of people
It's going to get hot and humid soon. People will be passing out or having to change them multiple times a day as they get soaked/exhaled-condensation soaked. It's going to be a big deal everyday to wash/dry masks for some people and more of an imposition than basement dwellers on Reddit acknowledge
I was thinking it would be a good business opportunity for him -- The Trump Mask Company, manufacturing the one-and-only, World's greatest MAGA Mask! Shit, I'd buy one. He's missing a tremendous opportunity here.
There's also an opportunity for the luxury market too with the business collection, making the finest matching masks, ties, belts, and shoes.
... there could also be a lock-her-up addition for the right-wing masses.
[deleted]
That's some funny stuff... but how is he going to get them shipped in from China while there are restrictions on shipping and travel?
[removed]
This is the simplest most effective way we can reduce cases, not to mention the cheapest! The president needs to check is ego and wear a mask in public. He alone has made the mask an issue, not the dems. History will not be kind to him.
He did wear a mask when asked, but of course he isn't going to be wearing a mask during press conferences and speeches. Not only is he not close enough to other people for it to matter (or they've all been tested) but it makes it hard to understand speakers. I'm not aware of where he told people to not wear a mask?
[deleted]
Your post or comment has been removed because
If you believe we made a mistake, please message the moderators.
First they said masks don’t work, and Reddit was screaming you are a science denier if you disagree.
Then they said only n95s work, and Reddit was screaming you’re stupid if you think cloth does anything.
Then they said any mask helps and Reddit screams that they knew it all along.
These people, and Reddit, can F off. No credibility.
It's almost like it was an emerging, unprecedented situation
[deleted]
you act like Reddit is one voice. There was a lot of debate early on about masks and there still is some debate. Many people advocated for masks despite CDC and WHO recommendations. They were right. The anti-maskers were wrong. How is there one "reddit"? Why do you come to reddit if you think it is so useless? weird.
Eek. CDC.gov is sufficient for your purposes. I recommend you stay there. You can get led very far astray on reddit if you are less than vigilant about the information you are accepting.
Let's be honest though, there's a decent amount of people here and in other subreddits that seem to think we need to stay fully closed for months longer.
I do not know anyone, personally, of this view. I do know anti-maskers. It is very frustrating.
I’d say most people I know on social media, personally, argue we should be on total lockdown longer. I believe a phased reopening needs to happen. I think a solid, clear plan and some Hope needs to be given to people who are just living in fear still.
We could somewhat-safely open a lot of things if people would wear masks. I'd be shopping at Target this week if they had a mask policy.
A lot of the resistance to opening that I see is people wanting to steer clear of the anti-maskers.
This is so true. Whenever people bring up masks it goes to the “dO YoU wAnT To STaY loCKedoWN FoReVEr” stuff again. It’s like they have one setting
How is that a red-herring? Also what is this anti-mask movement? I keep seeing people wearing masks in situations you definitely don't need a mask in and am wondering the exact opposite. I'm one of those people who thinks masks are virtue signalling. Why? Because I finally asked a neighbor and some people online why they wore a mask when walking alone in an empty area, and they started with the "I'd rather be over-cautious" bit. But there isn't such a thing as over-cautious. It's just necessary at that point
I do not know how I can help you.
Why are you bringing up Kaitlyn Jenner.
Fauci is also on video saying that wearing a mask does nothing.
[deleted]
I mean, we could have spent the time ramping up testing as a national priority to ensure that we know exactly who is and isn't contagious, then loosening restrictions in such a way that the people who are contagious stay home and the people who aren't can go about their lives.
But the mean, mean reporters wrote articles saying we should do that, so now the feds refuse to do any of this out of spite.
I think masks mandatory (or at the very least socially pressured) is the only solution. 75 percent effective on stopping spread. Should keep us safe enough.
[deleted]
The problem is people are clinging to the idea that they don’t work. Or whatever excuse is in vogue because they are uncomfortable. Masks are mandatory where I am and when I went out today, maybe 60% were wearing one.
Minnesota is handling it fairly intelligently. All retail stores were allowed to open this week as long as they maintained 50% occupancy at all times. In June, restaurants and bars will be open provided that social distancing is enforced via table placement and number of people allowed at a table, no more than 50 people are allowed in at once, all staff wear masks, and seating is by reservation only.
Salons, tattoo parlors, and the like will be allowed to open in June so long as everyone wears a mask at all times (meaning beard/mustache trims and facials are not allowed), 25% occupancy is maintained, and appointments are required for all services.
People in general here are being pretty smart and following guidelines well though. I see a lot of people having driveway barbecues where everyone is staying 6 feet apart, and friends going on walks "together" but yelling their conversation across the street. Minnesota is mostly Scandinavian though, social distancing is in our blood.
A lot of restaurants are going to end up closing. You can not run a restaurant by limiting the number of people. A lot of waiters/waitress are going to make a lot less in tips.
Other than the fact that they’re literally putting covid patients in nursing homes leading to is having the highest percentage of deaths in long term care facilities of any state by far. But yeah they’re doing a really good job of locking down the low risk people
I found the source for you:
https://www.thecentersquare.com/minnesota/analysis-minnesota-has-highest-percent-of-covid-19-deaths-in-long-term-care-facilities-in/article_1acd0d9e-9608-11ea-8cd2-1f8278e4af2b.html
>State data reports 537 deaths out of a total of 663 deaths took place in long-term care facilities (LTCF).
...this just means that most of the deaths were in long term care facilities. Not that a higher percentage of nursing home residents are dying vs other states.
81% of the deaths here have been nursing homes. That is a higher percentage than any other state. The government here is doing a terrible job of protecting the most at risk people
[deleted]
Minnesota's model is asinine. Almost all the restaurants can not make money this way. That's besides the fact that Minnesota is filled with Thunderstorms off and on for much of June meaning any solution to eat outside only will turn into a shitshow.
How are people ever going to meet new people by being mandated to stay 6 feet apart from each other the foreseeable future?
And it’s patio service only to start out. 50 people on a patio, no indoor dining yet.
BC is doing the same.
Specific. Measurable. Accurate. Reliable. Time based.
Is this a reasonable and nuanced take on COVID-19 on Reddit? Holy, cow. (Pinches self to make sure it's not a dream).
[removed]
Your comment has been removed because
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
Basically.. It's up to local authorities to open up as much as their healthcare systems can allow.. Hopefully higher risk individuals won't expose themselves. Hopefully we've been doing a better job at electing better people than the mayor in JAWS. Different municipalities will perform differently
[deleted]
I think it also includes anyone who live with or regularly come into contact with people who have a history of respiratory issues or any of the other qualities that make one high risk.. I don't see how it's selfish to be averse to mass graves
[deleted]
Thank you for this. My partner and I both are in that "vulnerable" category and we don't advocate for forever lockdown, but what we do want is greater protections and safety nets for people who are vulnerable. When you say "well if you're vulnerable just stay home" that totally ignores that if your employer opens up you either have to go back to a potentially high risk job or if you choose not to do so to protect yourself, you don't qualify for unemployment.
Add to that the horrendous number of people who just do not care about other humans enough to bother wearing a mask, and now you've further marginalized people who were already vulnerable to begin with. We can't go anywhere and as soon as lockdown is lifted we end up with no safety nets either.
[deleted]
[deleted]
Can someone explain to me what the issue would be with just making masks a requirement in public while keeping places at 25% capacity? That's really all that needs to be done.
Can somebody explain to me why the comment with ~700 upvotes is listed beneath the comment with ~243? What are the mods up to here?
You can forget about a smart opening when people are acting unreasonable. I'm in Australia and people haven't been saying the insane stuff that's coming from the US. Our cases in our state have been between 0 to 1 in the last month or so. I'm sad to say that the US is doomed to suffer because of its political polarisation.
[deleted]
We could come up with a fool proof opening plan that both scientists and economists agree on, the issue will always be that people won’t follow it because, “they know better”.
That is the real stumbling block to any plan anyone comes up with.
It's a weird myth that there's a "stay closed indefinitely" camp. The people who are against loosening restrictions very rapidly are worried that acting carelessly will end up forcing us to stay closed longer. Everyone should be on the same side of driving down the level of infections and figuring out a way to get things working again while maintaining that progress.
That will never happen in America! States are already opening up right in the face of the still continuing first wave! There will be no safe opening in America at this time! LOL
Dr. Fauci has lost a lot of credibility. First he misleads the public in regard to mask usage and now this. He is a doctor in charge of the CDC. He shouldn't be advocating for the economy. This is contrary to what he said last week and seems to overstep his mandate. Surely he isn't dabbling in economic policy with all the free time he has while there is a virus killing people.
In charge of NIAID*
Fauci is the head of the NIAID, he is not in charge of the CDC
Mea culpa
I agree with your point about he shouldn't be speaking about opening the economy. Let an economist do that. I'll go to Fauci for info about medical things, because he is a doctor.
You should be going to both, that’s the entire point. Fauci for estimating the impact on hospitals and spread with reopening, and an economist for estimating economic impact. We have to reach a comprise between these two major problems to understand the best course of action. They can’t be done independently of each other.