r/fragrance•
DStrng

I've been finding myself more and more wearing Clubman, by Edouard Pinaud, fragrances around the house. Anyone familiar with them and who else here is fond of the brand?

Discussion

I purchased both Pinaud and Pinaud Special Reserve off their website about 2-3 weeks ago and am really liking them. I'm even considering giving both a spin outside, once (if???) things return back to normal. This brand is the original fresh-out-the-chair, barbershop, fragrance and i find them quite nostalgic and relaxing to wear once i get out the shower. What do you guys think?

Posted May 26, 2020, 9:59 PM UTC

1729
turbobeans•

I haven't tried Clubman, but I have been using the red Proraso shave cream and aftershave. it has that throwback smell, very barbershop like, sandalwood, reminds me of my Grandpa in a good way. It seems to compliment most of my fragrances. One day I had just the aftershave on and my girlfriend smelled my neck and said I smelled good and asked what I was wearing - I said, it's just old man aftershave.

5
gojiragojira•

Same. My wife loves it. I discovered it by accident. Sandalwood out the yingyang.

1
bobbyup•

I’ve only got the Bay Rum but it’s awesome stuff! Smells great and lingers more than typical aftershave splash. I find it a bit of a wonder product to be honest. I have found it great on my scalp, when used like a hair tonic it has great (scent) longevity too. So cheap and huge bottle, you can splash it liberally and lasts forever.

I’ve been rambling... always meant to pick up the full line but never did. Which do you prefer of the two? Especially fancied trying the Lime Sec.... don’t feel like I can resist getting an order in soon now!

3
DStrngOP•

I may grab BR next. I like the both equally. Just like you're saying, it's a wonder it's so cheap to get so much! Truly good stuff man..

3
bobbyup•

Truth!

1
flottadreen•

I don’t use aftershaves since their performance usually isn’t very good for me. Clubman and other Pinaud products gets love of love at the Badger & Blade site, so you might give that a try: https://www.badgerandblade.com/forum/

3
DStrngOP•

Ok, thanks! 👍

2
ryanxcore•

The old school Clubman is great. Proraso too. However the Pinaud Bay Rum is horrendous IMO.

3
landis33•

I have to agree on the Bay Rum, it smells like feet to me lol. The others I have bought are awesome in an old school barbershop sort of way, comfortable and confident .

3
bobbyup•

Just to throw some love for the Bay Rum, I get navy rum and a huge blast of spicy cloves mainly!

1
bobbyup•

What’s your pick for Bay Rum? I’ve not actually tried other brands. Desperately wanted Cat O’ Nine Tails but had no luck getting it.

2
VVHYY•

Superior 70!

2
bobbyup•

Awesome shall check out, thanks.

2
bmc1129•

I grew up with this because my dad wore it day in, day out. He's even give me (his daughter) a splash on the cheeks as a young kid every so often. That's my childhood, and even in the assisted living facility, my dad has a bottle of it. It's a classic, indeed! That and the OG Old Spice after shave.

3
heretoforthwith•

They are great, but they might last like an hour. For an old school clean barbershop scent I wear Maison Margiela- At the Barber’s. More expensive? Yes, but you get what you pay for.

https://www.sephora.com/product/at-barber-shop-P394151

2
DStrngOP•

Yeah, i like this. I've always had in my heart to grab a bottle. Nice taste tho..

3
gman4757Cheapie collector•

Canoe, by Dana. It's practically a cologne strength dupe of Clubman, if you don't find the AS lasts long enough.

2
bobbyup•

I like Canoe, pretty much clean linear talcum powder to my nose, would you say original Clubman is pretty much that?

Do you (or anyone) know of a cologne or edt similar to the Bay Rum? I read a recommendation once but can’t recall it, a Geo F Trumper or Aramis flanker possibly?

1
gman4757Cheapie collector•

Yep, to my nose, they're practically indistinguishable. The AS might be a little more citrus forward in the opening, but that doesn't last

I don't, unfortunately. Something strong with clove and cinnamon, but to be honest, I'm on the hunt for something like that myself

2
bobbyup•

Thanks for the reply.

I really do love cloves especially, happy hunting something that fits the bill!

1
bobbyup•

Just received a Tobacco Vanille decant today, it truly is sublime. Definitely get a good dose of cinnamon from it, blended within the cocoa and tobacco/vanilla notes.

1
DStrngOP•

I haven't smelled canoe in years! My grandfather owned a bottle. I remember it smelling more soapy sweetish..

1
maintaining_frame•

I do occasionally wear Pinaud Clubman, Virgin Island Bay Rum, and Citrus Musk, mainly after weekend morning shaves when I'm not planning on going out. Classics for a reason. And let's not forget more classics in my rotation: Proraso, Old Spice (formula from India), Tabac, and Brut.

2
ColeWhiskeyWorld•

Special Reserve.

It's the nicest resin leather I've ever smelt and not as caustic as the Birch ("Russian") leather of Bogart (Black bottle).

I put special reserve on for fun around the house, it does sit close to the skin but for a long while I feel.

I really want to try Whiskey Woods but that's roughly $30 outside the US.

2
NanashiSaito•

I have a soft spot for these barber-shop fragrances. The smell of Brylcreem and Clubman together brings back a very strong wave of nostalgia.

2
Darkside0127•

Clubman is wonderful. They also make (made?) a very good pump deodorant. Ah Csnoe ... the first fragrance i ever bought. I will always have a soft spot.

2
-Blixx-•

I always think of pinged as the free locker room fragrances. The always have 2 at the club at the sinks outside the showers.

1
TheSecretAnus•

I have tried 4 of them so far: the Clubman, Classic Vanilla, Lilac Vegetal, and Bay Rum. I think they are great aftershaves, and I will be rebuying some of them and buying some new ones that I haven't tried before. I had to order them online since I have never seen any Pinaud Clubman aftershaves available in any stores or pharmacies here in Canada, except the one time I seen a barber shop selling some.

The "Clubman" is my day-to-day aftershave for cooler weather. I think it might be a little too overpowering for the summer months. I will purchase this again when I run out.

Classic Vanilla is great for hotter weather. I think it is perfectly suitable for use in hot weather when the original "Clubman" would be a little too strong. It's very much like a toned-down version of the original Clubman with some added woody notes and a hint of vanilla. I will re-purchase this too if I run out.

Lilac Vegetal is a very unique smelling aftershave and something you don't want to over-apply. It does not smell good if you over apply it, but it is pretty nice if used in small amounts. I can't say I love it, but I am happy that I bought a bottle.

Bay Rum has some serious burn; that stuff will definitely wake you up if you aren't awake when you apply it to your freshly shaved skin. The scent is alright, I guess it's kinda nice to have a Bay Rum scent option available as an aftershave.

By any chance have you tried YSL Kouros? I think anyone that likes the original "Clubman" aftershave will probably also like Kouros.

1
DStrngOP•

I luv Kouros. Probably one of the first fragrances that really made me wanting to keep smelling it, back in the 80's. A friend of mine father had a mini and it was fantastic. Altho i haven't smelled it since regrettably. I'll eventually grab a bottle...

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1