Replacing a Hedge?

Help/Advice

Cross posted from gardening, since I know you guys will understand why I want to get rid of my privet hedge....

Hi fellow gardeners! I need some advice with a hedge situation and would love your opinions.

So I'm in a typical suburban neighborhood (zone 6, Michigan, clay, alkaline, mostly sunny) and I have a narrow (like 24") privet hedge between me and one of my neighbors. The rest of my yard has privacy fencing, but the hedge portion has chain link.

I love the look of the formal hedge, so I want to replace it with something native, but I don't want to see my neighbor's yard while I wait for whatever to grow.

Two questions:

  1. Could I plant a native hedge a few feet in front of the privet, wait for it to grow up a bit, then cut down the privet and hit it with Roundup? Or, some other method I can't think of?

  2. Any suggestions for hedge plants? I was looking at arrowwood viburnums and I'm also open to planting more than one type of plant.

Thank you in advance for any help. Happy gardening!

Posted May 28, 2020, 5:48 PM UTC

12
rockerBOONE•

My hedge list currently:

Elderberry, Serviceberry, Chokecherry, Hazelnut, Nannyberry, Ninebark, American Plum, Dogwood (Red Osier/Silky ) Pussy Willow

Arrowwood Viburnums around here turn to dust from the invasive beetle. Even Nannyberry (a Viburnum) but I currently still plant it.

3
MerulaBlueOP•

I've got some of these already, so thank you for the suggestions. And the warning about viburnums. :(

1
UntakenUsername48753Mid-Atlantic•

I don't know if this is true in Michigan, but for me, privets are almost evergreen. So something like an American holly might be a good replacement, if you don't want something like an arborvitae or eastern redcedar.

If a viburnum works, though, then a native rose bush, silky dogwood, witchhazel, ninebark, buttonbush, or winterberry holly might work too. I don't know if these are native to your area though, so you should double check.

If you cut the privet at the stump, and then brush on something with a high concentration of glyphosate (like 30%), it should kill the privet without affecting the nearby plant. Glyphosate is rendered inactive when it contacts soil, which makes this a safer approach. Some other herbicides are not and drips can end up affecting nearby plants (though brushing is pretty controllable).

If you only need it to be 24" wide, couldn't you just buy a larger plant as a replacement? If you could weed-wrench the privet out then you could put the replacement in the same spot vs moving in forward a bit.

1