How can society in TNG function with no currency or money?
Living with no currency/money is impossible imo even with automation and replicators in abundance because most people in a society work to earn money to acquire things and improve their life. It’s not just about philanthropy or desire to add value to society. I think essentially humans would need to be “reprogrammed” to remove, jealousy, greed, envy at the same time leave or instill drive, philanthropy, enlightenment, initiative and ability to enjoy every tiny thing etc.
The way that TNG shows this paradigm just doesn’t make any sense whatsoever. If you look at working on a starship, what are the motivations of an ensign other than prestige and career progression and if their desire is gone what stops a lot of them from quitting when they see no progression and no enjoyment? (We’ve seen a fair amount of 30-40 yr old ensigns) What gains do a starship engineer on dry dock have when they spend 2 days scrubbing exhaust manifolds or hours repairing a series of plasma conduits?. What joy does Guinan have serving people drinks for free all day everyday? What makes Sisko’s father slave away in the kitchen everyday? For people to eat for free? What about all the tedious, boring, terrible jobs in the world that robots replicators don’t do there? how is that sustainable? How are incentives to work to keep the structure of society in tact, generated? There has to be some form of medium of exchange to incentivise everyone to work in unison for the betterment of society and not rely on people’s flakey moments of enjoyment and philanthropic/ideological whims.
Even if you were to automate everything, who repairs the machine? and if they are even repaired automatically what would be the purpose of humans? who governs those human for free at the same time living in a flat the same size as someone who does nothing or works for free in a cafe.
Posted May 30, 2020, 12:36 PM UTC · locked
Believe it or not, if you take away need, people tend to act civilized. It's when people need stuff, even just fresh air, people start to do stupid shit.
In ST, people do things because they want to. I'm sure Jean Luc's brother didn't have to keep making the family wine, but he did anyway. People are able to pursue things for their own betterment and enrichment. People would and have done a bunch of shitty jobs for the opportunity to travel the earth.
Think of it like this, the world is pretty much a hipster living off a trust fund and practically everywhere is gentrified. Also, keep in mind for this to happen there was a huge war. So it just didn't happen over night.
I suppose if everyone is opting in to such a society it’s someone easier to follow but is slaving away in the kitchen or serving drinks and making boring conversion a form of betterment and enrichment? What about the hours painfully fixing a machine when your are ordered to do that in one hour by your commanding officer and you have a million and one other things waiting to be repaired at the same time? what a job that must be and that’s LeForge’s job on the enterprise. Imagine some mining complex on the moon.
How is this undercurrent of pressure in many many jobs we see on TNG, DS9, VOY good for ones mental health if the only upside is personal enrichment and betterment? I can’t reconcile the fact that at some point the negatives will very quickly and easily outweigh the positives.
What is there to stop you from quitting this stressful boring tedious job and going home to your free house and eating your free food after all everything is free?
This doesn't have to be done; in Star Trek anyone who works in a kitchen does so because they enjoy cooking.
This doesn't have to be done; in Star Trek anyone who works as a bartender does so because they enjoy interacting with lots of random people.
Duty. Honour. Obligation. Wanting to give back to society.
Nothing is stopping you from quitting that job and going back to your house, living a stress-free life forever. You may find yourself enjoying it. Some people end up unfulfilled and start doing things out of their nature.
In the world we live in it’s not possible to do that for 99% of the population. There aren’t better jobs available to most citizens and not available on the spot. Everyone would also be competing for those jobs too. In the trek universe you can quit today and go home and not worry about anything.
I like my job and I am doing good for society but I wouldn’t do that job for free even if I had a free house car etc as there are, like most jobs a lot of pressure that comes with it so if the option is to quit and still have a free home and food like in TNG then I would have done so a long time ago.
I am not be able to support myself just by staying at home not earning money and if I was living in Africa or South Asia then I would be screwed.
I emphasise again, you are projecting problems of our 21st century society on to a fictional one a couple hundred years in the future. These things do not overlap. They face a set of vastly different problems.
Like I said in my other comment, you’re arguing from a perspective that is exclusively your own. I thrive in high pressure environments and take great pleasure in overcoming complex problems. I need adversity for a sense of purpose. As a demonstration of how no one is the same, let me say that I have Aspergers and I am completely deviant from the norm of someone on the spectrum.
Life is a long struggle. In western society many enjoy the luxury of choosing our struggles personally. I do not intend to invalidate the disgusting problems of racial oppression and privilege. Those are real things and I can not ever imagine to understand the struggles of a black person trying to emancipate. What I can do is be compassionate and understanding. I can stand up and face troubles in support of groups less privileged and free. Fuck moderates and political centrists.