How do civil wars work?

A few times now, I've tried seeing if I could engineer how a civil war plays out by managing the loyalty of specific generals and governors, ensuring loyal family heads have holdings in fort territories, stranding disloyal generals on islands and withdrawing my transport fleets, smearing the reputations of high powerbase disloyal characters, befriending important generals, etc. etc. etc.

I find that these machinations don't seem to matter. Immaculately loyal characters will happily flip sides on me come a rebellion. I guess I have no clue how civil wars work, because I sure can't predict how they play out at all. Is it really just random? It's especially obnoxious when friendless, 0 popularity characters that I put on trial trigger a civil war that pulls in otherwise loyal generals and admirals.

Does anyone know his the civil war mechanic works? Would love to hear if so. I like the idea of sometimes allowing a civil war to happen, but only after severely rigging the deck against the revolters. It seems fun on rp grounds and as an opportunity to wipe out and destroy the disloyal opposition, rather than keep them forever just barely bribed into loyalty. But it doesn't work practically or for rp if the final battle lines drawn are arbitrary.

Posted Jun 9, 2020, 3:01 PM UTC

92
GotNoMicSry•

You ever get the sense of deja vu....

(Just kidding I asked this exact same question a few weeks back and the answer was that no one apparently really knows for certain. There's some factors that affect who defects probably but like the entire process as a whole is so disconnected from how the player perceives the state of their country that no one really knows the exact factors behind defections)

Edit: If you want a rigged civil war just put all your troops on your current leader and the rest mercenaries. Even the great civil war chain stands no chance against that because once the armies are all wiped you insta win

4
GotNoMicSry•

After purposefully triggering a civil war thinking "I finally understand all the mechanics of the game, I'm sure I can handle it now and I've looked at all the potential factors" I can clarify they are literally just designed terribly. If smaller than regional power consider it a possible rng dice roll because it will insta win or lose. If regional power consider it an annoying fight if you have more troops and a game over if you don't. And if greater than regional power consider it a game over because your probably better off just restarting rather than going through the tedium of stackwiping every magic spawned armies that retreat behind their forts across an entire country and then remaking all your trade nodes. Im guessing this was a feature ported over from eu:rome because I can't imagine paradox intentionally made such a terribly designed mechanic.

1