r/MensRights•
Genre

My university is changing the standard of evidence for convicting students of sexual misconduct to "preponderance of evidence"

There is currently a commenting period for a proposed sexual misconduct policy change at the University of Virginia. Among these changes are the following:

Evidentiary Standard Changed. Pursuant to the "Dear Colleague" letter, the evidentiary standard in adjudication of sexual misconduct cases has been changed from "clear and convincing evidence" to a "preponderance of the evidence."

and

No Time Limit on Invoking Procedures. Under the existing policy, complaints must be brought within one year of the alleged misconduct. There is no time limit to invoking jurisdiction under the proposed new Policy, as long as the accused student is a University student at the time the complaint is made.

The funny thing is that the executive summary includes in its introduction the line:

In addition to inviting comments from students and the community, the University is seeking input from national experts. Revisions to the current Policy and Procedures are aimed at providing the utmost in care and support for victims while at the same time being mindful of the due process and privacy rights of accused students.

The full executive summary can be found at http://www.virginia.edu/sexualviolence/policy/execsummary.html

That's right, they are making it possible to convict students of sexual misconduct that happened 4 years prior solely on the grounds that the probability that it happened is greater than 50%. But hey, at least they were being mindful of due process.

I am currently in the process of writing a criticism of the new policy, especially these two changes. I would greatly appreciate any suggestions or comments that might help make my criticism more effective.

Thoughts?

Posted May 5, 2011, 5:39 AM UTC

610
cuteman•

In cases of sexual assault claims, I would suggest anyone accused assert the university's inability to investigate a complaint of that magnitude and to leave investigation and punishment to professional authorities. Universities seem to be playing the role of liberal activist pandering to federal stipulations and money while suggesting their authority supercedes legal judical authority. It does not and cannot. Too many stories have I heard of novice conduct committees deliberating without due process based on personal feeling and emotion.

I feel sorry for any males going through the system nowadays. You must be careful what you do because a lie can become the truth.

3
sky33dive•
3
halholbrook•

oh i'd definitely sue the school if i got kicked out following an accusation.

2
kloo2yoo•

Dear male students, in order to execute most faithfully the directives of the Dear Colleague letter from our most beloved leaders; in order to expedite rape persecutions and because we're certain that you're probably going to try it anyway, we've chosen to adopt the 'guilty until proven innocent' standard, as devise below:

At the end of every semester, each female student will be given a questionnaire with the names of each male on it.

Beside each male name, the female students will check one of six possible answers:

Definitely did not rape or sexually harass or or attempt to rape or sexually harass me or any of my friends

Probably did not rape or sexually harass or or attempt to rape or sexually harass me or any of my friends

May not have raped or sexually harassed or attempted to rape or sexually harass me or any of my friends

May have raped or sexually harassed or attempted to rape or sexually harass me or any one or more of my friends

Probably did rape or sexually harass or attempt to rape or sexually harass me or any one or more of my friends

Definitely did rape or sexually harass or attempt to rape or sexually harass me or any one or more of my friends

Please note that a male graduation candidate may be considered for graduation only after each female on campus has checked "definitely did not rape me or any one or more of my friends" for that candidate.

Female students must note that they are not required to provide evidence when responding to this questionnaire.

2
Sarcasticus•

The law should not be enforced by probability.

1
AnnArchist•

You could either try suing them, but you likely would have no standing at the moment. . . or you should protest. I'd start by talking to some people in the law school.

You should write letters to the editor to you school paper.

1
catwithtenheads•

I have a simpler suggestion to the school:

Sue the Department of Education and obtain an injunction.

OP should cite cases where due process has been required in school conduct procedures, such as Dixon v. Alabama.

1