Slavery was a blessing for today's african americans
[removed]
Posted Jun 13, 2020, 1:23 PM UTC
[removed]
Posted Jun 13, 2020, 1:23 PM UTC
[deleted]
Yea, it’s like saying it’s a blessing your parents died young because you get their stuff sooner. It’s inappropriate and wrong.
I think the point is that it was a blessing for the enslaved's descendants. In all his quotes, i found nothing suggesting that life as a slave of an american was better than life as a free man in Africa, unpleasant as that too was. But, for modern african americans... he does have a point. They lucked out among "africans".
[deleted]
Well, again, it doesn't seem to me that is what he is saying. The core of it, imho, was that the descendants of the enslaved are lucky that their ancestor got enslaved. If the spiritual and material benefits that comes with being an american supersedes the hit to the personal pride of knowing that your great grandparents were slaves.... well, that is not for me to say. It would be quite personal anyway.
[deleted]
Yea, but their descendants might be even happier if Europe hasn’t of raped Africa in the first place, right?
And their descendent would also have been even happier if they weren’t discriminated against by law and custom in America after their emancipation, right?
You could play this game for ever.
You know there are still people enslaved today? I wouldn’t consider that as a blessing.
I fail to see how the terrible situation of those still enslaved is relevant for the point raised by Richburg.
Write it yourself if you believe it. I’m not giving that article that is justifying slavery views.
If you don’t think you should back up the statement yourself, then why make the statement at all?
I mean I guess you could probably say the Irish famine was a blessing for people who’s ancestors who lived in Ireland because it freed up more land at home and other people’s ancestors now lived in America, the UK and Australia.
So, the Irish famine was a blessing?
Or your parents dieing early would be a blessing because you get their assets in your thirties instead of your 50s?
I mean, I get it conceptually, but it is a shitty way to think of things. The next time someone’s parents die young, I should congratulate them?
I am, quite intentionally, saying nothing. What do you dislike or find it unreasonable in mr. Richburg's thought?
Could you contact him and get him to answer my questions then?
A person with absolutely no opinion on the opinion they posted isn’t super helpful to me.
The best you could argue is that colonization was a blessing for today's africans since it bringued them civilization but slavery is just a plain no
I encourage you to look into population ethics, especially the non identity problem to see why this is wrong.
Alright. So the author bases his premise essentially on the fact that if you had to choose where you were born you should pick America over Africa. Sure, that's fine with me.
Except that doesn't work with his thought exercise. If African slaves weren't brought to America, no black Americans that are alive today would have ever existed.
Technically yes, true. Maybe a different, and more realistic way, to propose his arguments would be "i think today's africans would be better placed if, instead of being africans, they had all the perks of being african americans even if those come with an eslaved ancestor"
"i think today's africans would be better placed if, instead of being africans, they had all the perks of being african americans even if those come with an eslaved ancestor"
I recognize that's the argument. It's a true statement but about as meaningful as saying "I would be better off if I won the lottery". It's true I would be, but I have gained nothing from knowing that fact.
I guess one has to read his book to get the end point of his reasoning. It could be a desperate complaint in how much Africa sucks, or a revelation that African americans should appreciate america and its qualities with the same, deserved, scorn they have for its faults, past and current. Maybe both.
I think the biggest issue I take is the "othering" of that line of thought. It kind of implies that black people weren't part of building this nation up and are just along for the ride. I would think the author would get more traction arguing that black americans should be proud of the nation they helped build.
I read it but like you dumb and person who wrote is dumb.
Like let's say the slave trade didn't happen then the world would be different and Africa would also be different.
Dum op.
No I'm not going to read that, if you want to make a case for an opinion then express it yourself.
I am white. And not naive enough to think that wouldn't be considered a factor. So, no, i'll leave all the talking to the african american journalist, from a clearly non-right newspaper, that had this opinion after experiencing Africa and its inhabitants lives.