What is the general attitude towards Georgism on this sub?

Given the name and the background image (monopoly was created by a Georgist) I assumed this sub would have a fair amount of Georgists in it, but I'm not seeing much discussion of it.

A tax on the unimproved value of land, which is then given out to people as UBI, would be one of the most pro-renter policies physically possible.

I hope people don't shit on me for this, but policies like rent control don't really work as intended, they decrease affordability and actually increase gentrification in the long run.

Posted Jun 14, 2020, 10:02 PM UTC

1728
closetotheglass•

Seems like a good idea until you read Marx. Best of luck to you, young man!

12
Amphi66•

this marks (Marx?) the first time I have ever heard someone use the "just read theory bro" argument unironically

2
closetotheglass•

The joke here is that georgism is such a fringe and crank ideology that you'd only ever arrive at it by having extremely narrow and specific concerns that come from reading too many books and complete disengagement with politics or the struggles of living/working people. Same thing I'd say to a mutualist or "post-left anarchist"

13
Amphi66•

oh i see! considering this is my first time hearing of the concept i can certainly see that it's at least fringe

5
closetotheglass•

It was somewhat popular among classical liberals in the late 1800s and up until the 30s or so, but faded from any popular consciousness with the rise of Social Democracy and Fascism (which were both movements designed to do the same things Georgism did: bail out or preserve a rapidly collapsing capitalist system), and the decline of classical liberalism as a movement distinct from what we now call "conservatism"

3
EvidenceBasedOnlyOP•

fringe and crank ideology

You realize that it is a far better fit for the orthodox economic consensus than most other ideologies right?

Economists from Krugman to Stiglitz to Friedman are in favor of a large land value tax.

Empirical research on inequality from Piketty and Rognlie indicate that land is the sole explanatory factor of the rising capital share of the national income.

1
closetotheglass•

Your proof that it isn't a fringe ideology for cranks is that absolute pedants like Friedman and Piketty say that it has theoretically made a number go up over time. Nobody cares about this.

6

Honestly this trying to go back to obscure theorists common on reddit is incredibly larpy

Revolution isn't a dinner-party

Focus upon objective theory and practice, don't revel in having your own unique communist identity, that's just purely straight-up reactionary. If you want a revolution then you must put the revolution and the masses first. Not your ego.

Read Combat Liberalism.

https://youtu.be/UUmxc_hVGQs

Edit: this sounds agressive upon re-reading, my intention was just to concisely address a few very common mistakes I see on leftist reddit

4
closetotheglass•

He's a georgism, even more obscure than libertarianism or boutique socialism. This guy is trying to bring back the Whigs lol

3
RIPNightman🏴Ⓐ🤝🏼☭🚩•

don't revel in having your own unique communist identity

Well put -- this is one of the most annoying obstacles I've noticed about leftists. Too many have a focus on individualism and will pigeonhole themselves into extremely specific ideologies. They then act super obtuse when discussing all other left ideologies.

3
EvidenceBasedOnlyOP•

But I don’t want communism, I just want georgism.

1

Yeah I'd wager absolute monarchy is more likely to return than that

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Feliks_Dzierzinski•

Comrade Mao's methods of dealing with parasite infestations are much better, thanks

3
centrarch•

did pretty well with the sparrows too

2
cat_respecter•

To be fair, landlords don't kill pests, most of them don't even call the exterminator.

3
AutoModeratorMOD•

Do you despise your landlord? Are you sick of the current system of Landlording which views human life as less valuable than property? Perhaps you're looking to organize or get more involved with both digital and on-the-ground activism?

If any of these are true, please join our partnered discord, Organize Against Eviction (Link was broken--fixed now). Only through organizing can we ever hope to achieve real structural change.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
EvidenceBasedOnlyOP•

Replacing property taxes with a higher tax solely on the land itself would incentivize more productive usage of land and increased housing construction.

1
CapableCarpet•

Georgism is cool except for the fact that it is still capitalism. Rent seeking is bad, but there are countless other problems that are not addressed. I would certainly prefer a land value tax over what we have, but why not go all the way?

1
EvidenceBasedOnlyOP•

I still want to incentive the creation of new capital and entrepreneurship. No returns to capital = underproduction of capital and all that.

1

Not necessarily.

0

It would be an improvement and I welcome any of that.

However, I don't think it's ideal.

1