Anyone else think the new Discovery UI could use some improvements?
I really enjoyed the Exoplanets Discovery game, enough that in the span of about 6-7 months of daily playing I got to about lvl 550 with max accuracy for most of the time. The rewards were good, but also was the sense that you're contributing in some small way to real life scientific progress appeals to me personally and professionally.
As a clinical laboratory technician myself, the news that a new Discovery was coming online to address the biotech industry in regards to the COVID pandemic struck me as a grand opportunity to merge my career with my gaming experience. Scattergrams like those seen in the Flow Cytometry iteration are basically the bread-and-butter of any lab tech working in hematology, so it's no exaggeration to say I was motivated to play once I realized I had a particular set of skills to handle this. In fact, on the first day I managed to reach the solution limit before I'd finished my other activities in the game, so I literally couldn't do any more. I'd gotten to about lvl 14, with an accuracy over 90%.
That having been said, I think I've played enough of it to say that the interface by which the game is handled is sub-par compared to the Exoplanets interface. There are problems that didn't exist before, and the overall window seems too big and busy, with some visual information missing. While there have been posts with issues regarding the scattergrams, I feel like those will be addressed in due course. My issue, from a player convenience standpoint, is more about the window itself, and given input from others, I decided to make this post to log my opinions regarding issues I see in this UI that weren't a problem in Exoplanets
I'm told CCP reads these posts, so may this post serve as some constructive criticism so that this great and helpful game can be made better and easier to use so that more players are willing to play it. I'd like this post to be about the interface itself, and not necessarily the analysis; though feel free to log any items you think should be brought to CCP's attention.
In summation: I think the game is great, and I plan to play it a lot, but there's several quality of life tweaks that need to happen to make it more convenient to use. In order of what I consider to be most important to least:
-
The white noise is unnecessary, and distracts you from solving. You can also hear it when it's minimized.
-
Much of the interface is too big and doesn't really serve any meaningful fashion; as a result, it takes up so much of the screen you can't minimize it enough to see the screen properly. Overall it's too visually busy while not conveying as much overall information at a glance as Exoplanets did. Also, at the smallest you can make the window, it easily takes up 4/5ths of the screen, which makes playing it in the background while passing the time mining an issue.
-
The cell images and the 'next reward' images down the middle are just visual filler. They can be removed without losing any necessary or even desired information, so that the window can be snapped smaller.
-
The line of milestones has no progress bar on it showing how far along you've come. That line running through all the Exoplanets rewards was much better.
-
It doesn't tell new players why they get x2 xp once a day for the first 10 solves. They might be confused why sometimes they get it and sometimes they don't. Exoplanets told you that the first 10 a day get 2x xp.
-
I have no clue by what standard the 'golden standard' zones are derived. Since your accuracy is based on your solution's similarity to them, it'd be nice to know if they're based on consensus, or determined by the game's creators.
-
The points you mark to define the zones are very finicky at times, and you can't right click to delete the mark you're on like you could with exoplanets if you made an error.
I suppose some of these are nit-picks, but collectively it makes the game a lot less fun than exoplanets was. A handful of convenience tweaks could clear most of this up, but does anyone else agree?
Edit: there was a recent stream on CCP's channel on Twitch that was about 90 minutes devoted entirely to Discovery, and answers many questions regarding the project and the game in EVE. Link to the VOD is here: https://www.twitch.tv/videos/654622399
If for some reason the VOD doesn't answer all your questions, the head researcher links his email in the stream, and he encourages anyone to email him about anything related to the Discovery. If he himself can't address it, he has no problem forwarding it to someone who does.
Posted Jun 16, 2020, 7:24 PM UTC · edited