Tracker with standardized Mp3 tags.
Are there any trackers that enforce standardized tagging on songs? I'd love to not have to retag files after downloading.
Posted May 13, 2011, 4:20 AM UTC
Are there any trackers that enforce standardized tagging on songs? I'd love to not have to retag files after downloading.
Posted May 13, 2011, 4:20 AM UTC
What and Waffles, although, I have really learned to love Waffles. I like the format and layout alot better than What, and I love what they did with donating to japan and get freeleech for it. Both have great and outstanding communitties.
The mp3 tagging architecture is sort of a mess. Between the various incarnations of ID3 and APE, it's entirely possible for one client to read tags properly and for them to be completely absent from another. It's difficult if not impossible to get 100% accuracy when the format itself has failings in this regard. I'm not sure about other lossy codec container formats but FLAC has a much better metadata system.
On What.cd if you do get a release with "bad tags" it's usually a new torrent and if you report for bad tagging someone will re-upload pretty soon with a correct version.
On the other hand maybe you also need a good MP3 tagger. I've been using Mp3tag for years, by far my most favorite program for tagging.
What and Waffles are usually pretty good about this, but they both have so many torrents it's near impossible to have it perfect.
Every single album I've downloaded from what has had perfect tags, waffles on the other hand leaves a lot to be desired.
This is true for the most part. Sometimes I get really horribly tagged things from What, but that's a rarity.
I think you can report that now. Or at least fix up the tags and trump it.
On What there is no standard tagging format - just that they have to be clearly tagged. For me this means loading them all in mp3tag, running a couple macros on them, and out comes a thousand freshly baked songs. Also my tagging requirements are incredibly stringent.
Scope out the rules in the upload category, specifically 2.3.13 and 2.3.15. There are rules regarding tag standardization, just that they have to be tagged.
There is no strict tagging standard just because the music is very diverse, and often hard or impossible to properly tag. The rule is, tag the required parts, and the rest to the best of your ability. Obviously there will be people who think this isn't enough, but it's impossible to enforce it because of how large and diverse their collection is.