r/handtools•
Shworn

Are the new Stanley planes actually as bad as people say?

I was going to buy a no. 4 smoothing plane after I get some Bunnings gift cards and noticed people talking lowly of modern Stanley’s, what are they really like?

Posted Jun 17, 2020, 9:29 AM UTC

832
Jp1381027•

I recently bought a new Stanley shoulder plane, stupidly, before reading the reviews. The blade was surprisingly good, but that’s it.

The casting of the body was so bad that it was unusable. The sole was nowhere near square to the sides, there were sharp edges all over (crap fit and finish), the screws were chowdered up right out of the box, and worst of all, due to the shit casting, the adjustment mechanism wouldn’t work.

So yeah. They’re pretty bad.

5
woodprefect•

Quality control isn't that great, so make sure you inspect the plane you get and be prepared to take it back. Even on a good one, you'll probably need to do some prep work. The blade will probably be dull, the chip breaker will probably not mate to the blade and you'll have to fix that too.

4
ShwornOP•

What are some red flags too look out and check for if I do get one?

1
how_gauche•

For me the red flag is "it's made after 1970 and has 'Stanley' written on it". If you want a Chinese-made new plane, Woodriver/Quangsheng is significantly better at the same price point IMO. The Sweetheart line is an attempt to rebuild their reputation, but everyone says QA is poor --- other manufacturers apparently have figured out how to machine a metal part square/flat, which is apparently still a problem for Stanley.

3
Booola•

I reckon post ww2 is when they started going downhill. Basically they started off with something good and kept taking away all the good features. I reckon once you go type 16+ the hollowed frog will not perform as well as the old skool beefy frogs

2
woodprefect•

obvious fit and finish stuff, check the sole flatness, the blade should be flatish, etc.

You'll have to work on the plane to finish it, its really all about minimizing your work.

I'm answering your question, but as others have suggested .. perhaps go with woodriver. The same advise applies.

​

I have two record plans from the 60's, and there are pretty good.

2
bacterialove•

I got a new sweetheart 62 low angle jack and I've been happy with it. Not as good as my vintage Stanley's by any stretch, but it didn't require as much initialization as a vintage beater would.

4
StoicWalnut•

I have the same plane and it drives me nuts. The handle is wobbly no matter how much I tighten it. Adjusting the depth a pain because the iron slides back and forth a bit until it’s tightened down. My Lee Valley low angle block plane has none of these issues and takes almost no time to set the correct depth. I’m considering selling the Stanley and buying the Lee Valley low angle jack, which is what I should have bought in the first place.

2
Flerpinator•

I sprang for a Lee Valley low angle jack a couple of months ago, oh my word what a nice toy!

2
oldtoolfoolTool Monger•

Stanley is heavily into the mass market, not the specialized hand tool market. Just for chits and giggles, look for some parts for it, they are unavailable. QA/QC, as noted is poor. They look nice in the pictures, but there are many better alternatives out there. I had hopes for a "new Stanley" renaissance, when these first came out, but it just did not pan out. I'd only buy vintage Stanleys; however, in the UK they made Stanley planes for much longer than in the US, and up to the '80s they were still quite servicable. You may also have access to vintage Record planes, take a close look at those.

3
laidlow•

Yes. The only new planes I'll touch these days are Woodriver, Veritas and Lie Nielsen. Learned this the hard way. Bunnings I only use for power tools.

3
Booola•

I normally pop by total tools for power tools. Bunnings are known to get manufacturers to make same tools with less power and other features to satisfy their price match policy. And they only stock tools that are geared towards home owners and diy on a shoe string budget. Aka ozito, Ryobi... And like a lot of tools they don’t stock, I was looking for a orbital sander and Bunnings didn’t have it. Ended up going to total tools. I got the gex 150 turbo with geared mode haha. Basically a belt sander with 99% dust extraction. But I digress

1
hs429q•

Here are my 2 cents. In my country is not easy to get premium planes, their price + shipping is prohibiting, so Stanley is the way to go, that is brand new, in a cardboard box and all that.

Now comparing with a used, vintage Stanley that you get on a flea market, at least in my opinion, they require the same amount of work to get them in shape and working condition, that is check the sole for flatness, check the frog, prepare the chipbreaker, grind and hone the iron, ant remove all other sharp edges in contact with your hands, that last one is probably not needed with older planes and that's a maybe.

So depending on the amount of rust for old/level of flatness-smoothness finish on new, we are talking about 4 hours or so of elbow grease before you can take your first shavings on wood if not more, now keep in mind you'll only need to do this once.

I have 2 #4, a #5 and a #6 that are brand new, they perform ridiculously well, all of them, I love them, they are a pleasure to use, cause I took the time to set them properly and I don't mind that at all. They perform at the same level than my vintage planes, no difference, as a matter of fact I often find myself reaching out for the new ones instead of the vintage.

There is just one thing to avoid in my opinion, plastic handles. Just don't do it, your blisters will have blisters and is just not worth it, so just check that out and make sure you are getting Bailey pattern.

Happy planning.

3
ShwornOP•

Thank you very much for your insight. The only models at Bunnings are the 12-204 no. 4 ($99) and the 12-004 ($150). What are your thoughts on these and is the 12-004 worth half as much money?

1
hs429q•

I am not familiar to Bunnings or why they are so expensive, both of these are in the order or 55-60 USD, so that may be right I don't know, but the only reason I can think for the price difference is the more expensive being the Bailey pattern, if you could ask them before buying it, that will be the deal breaker. The difference between both is the frog adjustment mechanism, Bailey's are less of a headache to set up right, the other one (which I assume is the 204) does not have the advance screw for the frog, so it's a trial and error process that you do half a dozen times or more, once it's right, you'll never want to touch that thing again. Also Bailey = some brass nuts and brass adjustment wheel, non Bailey = no brass.

2
ShwornOP•

Thanks heaps. The price is in aud, so they’re only a bit more than the us price, which is usual for literally anything here, I’ll definatly go for the 12-004

1
hs429q•

Hey, tell me all about it and DM me if you need any help with it, I'd be glad to help

2
laidlow•

$150 for that plane is a huge waste of money. You can get an old Stanley Bailey #4 & #5 for that price and they'll give you substantially less problems.

The last Stanley plane I bought the bed for the blade wasn't even co-planar to the sole. That isn't something you can fix and certainly isn't something that should make it past QA.

1
B3ntr0d•

The 12-204 makes a good door stop. And honestly, the 12-004 is a sh!t box too. I have the 004 and it kind-of works after retuning it a few times. It work for bulk removal, but I am not going to try for fine shavings again.

I have the #3 of the same line, and it took half a day to get working well. The key was to take the frog out and flatten it as well, and the belly of the chip breaker, and the cap iron. Also file the burrs out of the back of the mouth, and when you set the frog in again, set it a little forward, so the the mouth closes up a bit. You only need about 2-3 mm opening between the blade and the front of the mouth.

You might look at making your own wooden plane. Less work.

2
handtoolwoodworker•

It’s been like two years since I purchased some of them. They all had to be returned.

2
howdy71475•

I was given a new shoulder plans and a 78 a couple years ago. They are both serviceable, but I spent several hours working on each of them. The shoulder plane took a complete reshape of the blade. Then an adjustment of the connection where the tow comes off.

Other than a lot of sharpening and squaring the corner on the 78 it wasn’t bad. But I have quite the time keeping the fence square. But again with a lot of time they are both serviceable

2
oldtoolfoolTool Monger•

Good point, you reminded me; I'd make an exception for the new Stanley production of the #78, they are still pretty good, its hard to screw up that design

2
carpetplant•

I picked up the bailey no4 about 5 years ago from bunnings, it took me a couple of years to realise how poor it is. After sanding and using diamond plates as I accrued them, it is still not completely flat and the frog is a bitch to get aligned so I ended up turning it into scrub plane after getting a decent no4.

2
tomrob1138•

I would look into wood river or rider planes. Both are affordable options that seem to have good builds and a lot of people recommend them as good cheaper options. I don't own one of either so, grain of salt I guess.

2
SaltyDot4659•

I had the sweetheart low angle jack, and I got rid of it because the bed for the blade was milled at and angle, so in order to take an even shaving across the width of the blade, I had to have it cocked as far to the left as it would go. The smoother was decent enough, but kinda finicky and difficult to set up. The shoulder plane had a lot of issues too. I sold them all and went with wood river till I could upgrade to LN or Veritas. Still have a lot of the wood river though, as they are really nice tools.

2
BerkyMc•

They’re not great.

Honestly, I think you’d be better off saving the Bunnings cards for other tools and see if you can find an old Stanley #4 or 5 on Gumtree or eBay.

2
Booola•

Mate, I've picked up so many #4s around Melbourne for around $30 each. As the other people have said, you'll spend roughly the same time working on the new plane compared to the vintage one. Also briefly looking at the two different planes you've linked. I think one of them in the 'handyman' series which I would assume would just be cost cutting to the max and it's just a tad better than Craftright

1
joelav•

No. Generally the people who say that have no first hand experience. I have a Stanley No62 low angle jack and a Stanley No 92 shoulder plane. The rest of my planes are from Lie Nielsen and Veritas - with a few extremely clean examples of vintage millers falls planes (brand new in box).

The Stanley planes I got required no fiddling out of the box and perform every bit as well as the "premium" planes I have. I'm not sure I would buy that No4, but that's not because of the brand it's because I hate that adjustment mechanism on bevel down planes

0
laidlow•

Generally the people who say that have no first hand experience.

Except a bunch of posters here have bought them and had to return them. Just because yours worked doesn't mean everyone else is wrong.

2