r/wownoob•
Tridaron

Wondering if I'm a bad healer or dealing with poor tanks

Retail

So I'm a healer who has returned after quitting directly after MoP's launch, so I'm not used to seeing Vengeance Demon Hunters, Brewmasters, and Guardian spec'd Druids. I understand that they're much more reactive in damage taking than traditional plate wearing tanks, but 60-70 percent of the time that I play with a leather based tank, it ends up that their health is so spiky and scary that they'll die horribly, along with pulling the entire area in places like that one Kul'Tiras dungeon with the talking parrot and the pig catching contest. (forgot the name, sorry) I understand if I'm not healing correctly, but I never face this problem with someone like a warrior, no 20 second 70% health loss, or me spamming cooldowns. I wonder if the issue is they're not using their own damage cooldowns or just poor tanking, but I really hope I'm not the only one. Its getting so bad that I get mild anxiety with a dungeon just based on the tank's class. I main Mistweaver Monk and Restoration Druid by the way. Thank you for any advice :)

Posted Jun 21, 2020, 5:55 PM UTC

1518
kp83kp•

I main a resto Druid and have never had any issues. I can share what my general “rotation” is for healing dungeons and hope that either A, you share a similar style or B, you don’t and maybe can pick up a tip or two.

Regardless of what class the tank is, I try to have a few hots running on the tank as he’s moving into a pack of mobs or the boss. Rejuvenation, and Germination if you’re spec’ed, and start casting Regrowth when the tank is about 90%. That’s three hots rolling already. Swiftmend as health starts to decline: my recommendation is to Swiftmend earlier than later due to 1, cool down and 2, as a resto Druid, huge dips in health can be stressful to recover from.

Wild Growth and Efflorescence will be your go to AOE heals. WG should hit everyone in the dungeon provided they’re within range, and if placing Efflorescence, be mindful of mob/boss movement. It’s a long duration and you want to make the most of its healing.

If you find yourself in a bad spot (25% health or lower) and don’t feel like you can recover or are stressing out, Ironbarking the tank will buy you a little room to breathe and catch your breath. At that point, Swiftmend (whenever it’s up) and spam Regrowth. Use any trinkets, potions, etc. to increase your haste. If you’re completely desperate, you can also inefficiently use your AOE heals to keep the tank up as well.

You also have Tranquility. Use unless you think you’ll get interrupted or know if you have to move around.

A few other things that can be helpful - you have a few CC’s that can take some pressure off the tank if you’re not too overwhelmed otherwise. I’m thinking a mob or add that heals, etc. Typhoon/Cyclone are useful here. And lastly, be mindful of any rebuffs that you can cleanse on the tank. It’ll save you healing in the long run.

Hope this was in some way or part helpful. Feel free to message me if there’s anything else I can explain or help with. Good luck!!

9
sneakymonstersnake•

Can’t really tell based on the info provided.

It could be you, it could be them or both. If you are not doing 30k+ hps consistently tho - you are most likely the cause. That means without using cds, just basic rotation.

DHs are spiky in terms of hp, but they got good self heal and mobility, so it doesn’t really matter as much.

Bears are fat and have a lot of armor, so only spikes you should be seeing is early on on pull.

7
[deleted]•

[removed]

6
DZ_tank•

Brewmasters, due to how stagger works, should always have the least spikey health bar. What type of content are you doing? If it’s lower leveled dungeons, it’s probably non-tanks offspecing for quick queues or groups but don’t really know what they’re doing.

5
drozcompany•

Yeah I was thinking the same thing. BM pairs well with a resto druid. HOT healing combined with DOT type damage intake of stagger makes their health the least spiky of all the tanks I've played.

3
Ak12389•

It could be your talents. They are confusing for a Druid at first but knowing which ones go together helps. Druids are very strong in 5 mans . I rolled a Druid like 2 months ago and started healing m0 through +3s at like 415 ilvl , some pugs some not . Questionablyepic.com is an awesome resource for resto Druids .

5
Khaosfury•

Having tanked and healed on every spec available, at varying levels:

Leather tanking is generally based more around having some sort of other defence, rather than straight up damage mitigation. For instance, Guardian Druids rely on armor, but they also have one of the highest HP totals in the game and %max hp self-healing. They will take lots of punishment, but they're also built for it. Brewmaster Monks have less HP, but take 30% of their damage intake over time. They're also able to straight up remove a portion of this damage intake, if they play correctly. Vengeance Demon Hunters also have mid-range HP totals for the tank role, but have insane self-healing (particularly with Soulbomb spec) and armor to make up the rest. They also come in with arguably the best movement abilities of any tank spec, which is spectacular for kiting.

One thing that ties all of these specs together is that they all lack in cooldowns compared to other tank specs. Both Brewmaster and Vengeance have precisely one cooldown, both on relatively long timers (although this changes with talent setups), and Guardian has 2, one of which has a 4 minute cd (so must be used very carefully). It might be worth investing in an addon which tracks your tank's cd usage, so that you can know when they're most vulnerable and maybe give your cooldowns some extra thought. It might also just come down to your tank's skill. Brewmaster and Vengeance specs both pack stupid amounts of mobility. There should be no reason tanks in those specs are dying to trash damage when they could be kiting them between cooldowns.

4
moussescientist•

I think the likely answer to this question depends on what content you are doing. Are you doing basic heroic/normal dungeons, or is this for Mythic+? In heroic/normals, you are more likely to get people alting tanks for fast queues that don't really know what they are doing so its most likely them. If you are talking about Mythic+, its most likely you. Brewmaster monks should actually be the least spikey tanks in the game, so if you are having issues with healing them it may be you or bad brewmasters. Hard to say.

3
hama0n•

in my experience there have been a lot of tanks who don't use their mitigation skills at all - they level up in dungeons, and in low levels they get used to only spending their resource on DPS skills... I think this kind of teaches them to neglect mitigation when they get higher :(

2
Sapje321•

I ran a fairly high M+ with a brewmaster once and I swear his ironskin uptime was like 50%... That dude was getting trucked. I feel like if you can't even maintain such a fundamental part of your tanking, you really ought not to tank.

2

As a tank, I heavily adjust my pulls based on how the healer is doing. I always start off dungeon by being conservative-ish on pulls and making sure that my defensiveness is at 100%. Meaning I’m not popping CD’s but for sure I can basically handle things even if the healer is asleep.

Over next 3-4 pulls I either slowly or quickly ramp up speed and size of pulls based on how DPS is doing and how healer is doing. I continually get faster and more aggressive until I realize group has reached the fastest reasonable pull rate/size of packs and then keep that pace steady. If at any time I see DPS not doing mechanics or healer struggling, I slow down.

I generally find that as a tank my “healing done” is about half of healing some of an “average” healer. If healer is below average, my self healing is much higher - 75% of healer. If healer is above average, then I might only be doing 30-40% of their healing done. These percentages seem to be rather true on my Prot Warrior and my VDH.

But honestly on my VDH can self-heal just fine. For instance, I was in +15 underrot with a shit group who wiped 2x on the spore boss. They wiped third time when boss was at 10-15% hp. I literally just stayed up and soloed rest of boss self healing just fine. My VDH can handle a lot of pain. Yeah it’s spiky, but it’s solid.

I would recommend you make sure your tanks are running rank 3 essences of defensive variety, those account for a huge portion of my self-healing. Same for azerite traits. There’s a couple azerite traits that help tanks a ton. Beyond that I would compare your healing to theirs to see where things are at. If their healing is only 20% of yours they are absolutely the problem. If their healing is 80% of yours, you are absolutely the problem.

For sure getting your own azerite traits and rank 3 essences sorted out and I think someone above gave you some targets on HPS to track.

Some dungeons will be impossible if folks are interrupting and dodging mechanics (my underrot group is a great example of a group who didn’t know how to interrupt or dodge mechanics). You can’t out-heal stupid.

My last recommendation is to /add tank friends that know what they’re doing to your friends list and/or to try and only join groups where tank has a good IO and has done +10 in that dungeon before and so on. I do the same with healers. I’m not running with a 700 IO healer in a +13. I can afford to wait an extra 5 minutes for a 1200 IO healer who at least has done that dungeon at +10. I also check essences. If you can’t be bothered to get your shit to all rank 2 with at least one or two rank 3s, I really have no desire to try you out in a +15. I used to be less picky, but I got tired of getting burned.

2

Can’t really provide an answer since there is not really enough data to go on, so it could be both. But I’ll do my best to give some kind of answer. I’m not sure how the healing meta looked like in MoP, but these days in dungeons especially as a resto druid for example pre-emptive healing and putting hots on people before the damage starts coming in is key.

Besides that, tanks should know how much they can pull and a lot of tanks - like dh and dk - will do most of the healing by themselves. It’s not uncommon that when I’m playing with my blood DK friend he will be higher than me on healing done, since I can mostly focus on DPSing. That’s in an environment with players that know each other and are communicating though, in pugs random things will happen randomly...resulting usually in huge amounts of extra damage taken.

Lastly, if you see your tank going I AM PULLING EVERYTHIIIIIIING it’s probably time to give them a barkskin or get the cocoon ready and start planting a big tree / env mists.

Small disclaimer: Both those healers are not my main healing class (hpala), but this advice works for all.

1
meshlines•

Aside from the tips and advice given by other players, maybe it's the mindset that you have when you're going into the dungeon. You mentioned on your post that you're having a hard time with leather tanks but I think druid and brewmaster are the easier tanks to heal due to their massive healthpool (druid) and stagger (brewmaster). I last played tank in Legion and I'm not sure if the gameplay is still the same but a Blood DK tank would have a spikier health gameplay.

Maybe you're more relaxed when you see a plate tank so you're more comfortable and when you see a leather tank, you get stressed out which affects your focus and performance.

As a tank, I completely trust whoever's healing me and I'm more than happy to adjust my pulls if my healer is having a hardtime keeping the party healthy.

I hope you continue being a healer and enjoy playing as well regardless of what tank you will be paired with. :)

1
drozcompany•

BM should be easy to heal, with their crit % chance to do extra healing, plus stagger postpones a lot of their incoming physical damage.

Your tanks may not be using active mitigation (ironskin brew, etc) or other cooldowns to help reduce the healing load. Some tanks have gotten lazy and relying too much on the healer to save them. In the same way DPS will stand in shit and expect to be healed thru instead of stepping out of it.

1
method8024•

A bad tank can usually crush my confidence when playing healer. I start second guessing myself and thinking i suck. I also notice it’s very rare to get a good monk at lower levels.

1
IDDQD_•

A friendly reminder to give the tank if he's getting smacked is to tell him that he doesn't need to take every single hit to the face and can back off a bit when he notices that you struggle to keep him up.

1
donaldbino•

Could be a little of both. As a main tank player if I’m playing with a random healer I never depend on them tbh, I have plenty of self heals and damage mitigation and generally almost out heal the healer everytime I’m in a dungeon. Most tanks rely too much on healers and they get lazy and complacent.

1
Granny_knows_best•

I stopped healing two expansions ago,I have always loved it, and I have been doing it since pre-BC......but it just went from fun to hard work. I think in my case I just got too old and my brain is not working as fast, because others make it look so easy. I do miss it.....I just gave up dungeons altogether now....raids I still like.

0†
Irbanan•

I can relate. I used to heal aswell, but both healing and tanking in mythics has become so toxic. If the dungeon fails people blaim either the healer or tank and not the dpser for lacking dps. I can't count how often ive seen a decent tank and healer get blamed. But honestly i dont find that with guild runs. People behave better and are more tolerant aswell. And i think they tend to use their whole toolkit better, like cc dispel etc. I honestly miss dungeoning with 1 pack heavy dmg and rhat you had to use your cc to survive it. Sap sheep etc.

1