Are Melting Remnants really good, or did I just get lucky?

I'm very new to the game so full disclosure I may be way off base. But I just unlocked them, and my first two runs with them were my first two consecutive wins--MR/Stygian, and MR/Awoken. All I did was throw my champion on the top floor with a tank, and then fill the floors with whatever units I had from top to bottom. By the time boss fights came around, my units were so heavily buffed that every fight went by with no problem. On my second run I got a little lucky--I wouldn't have won if I hadn't topdecked Engulfed in Smoke for that sweet sweet Stealth 2. But every boss and fight before Seraph I had literally zero issues with, on both runs. And I haven't even unlocked all their cards yet. Are they really good, or am I missing something?

Granted, I haven't even gotten into Covenant ranks yet--I'm still grinding for all the cards before I start climbing. But it seems like MR has some INSANELY strong cards. Engulfed in Smoke is amazing because stealth is broken for boss fights, Resin Removal is really good (the other half of my win against Seraph on run two was being able to remove all the Sap debuffs at the last second), Draff is INSANELY strong, especially when combined with Wicked Blaze (keep my unit alive while also adding 10 dmg per cast? Yes please.), and especially when Wicked Blaze has Holdover. Memento Mori does crazy damage and if you can get permafrost on it it's even better, since you can save it until you need a big hit. Formless Child seems absolutely broken to me (+40 damage is an insane buff, and if it happens to bring back a unit with multihit, you can basically put your feet up for the rest of the fight) and Fatal Melting is a really good AOE card.

What am I missing? I feel like I've seen a lot of people say that MR is one of the weaker options; do they start getting rocked once you start climbing Covenant ranks? Did I just get really good RNG? I would've written the first run off, but getting my first 2 win streak kind of made me wonder.

I'm curious because they are by far my favorite race to play out of the 5, so I'm kind of hoping they're as god as I think they are.

Posted Jun 24, 2020, 8:42 AM UTC

511
Smashing71•

MR requires a lot of time to setup, and relies on drawing cards in the right order. As you said, by the time the boss comes around you had super powerful units.

As you climb covenants and go to a deck with 10 starter cards and 2 deadweights, scaling becomes much slower, and you need to scale much faster to kill things. Therefore slow scaling becomes a lot more problematic. Also when you have 16 non-combo cards (4 train stewards, 5 basics of each type, 2 deadweights) then getting the right combo pieces is much harder than it is back when you have 10 - especially since once you remove 4 train stewards it becomes 6 vs 12.

It also has truly dreadful commons. It's very very easy to get 2 bricks with MR for your starter commons, which just makes the situation worse. Double Dripfall or double Molten Encasement is like... thanks.

7
atomic223OP•

Okay yeah I can see that. It definitely is slow to build strength--sometimes I had to sacrifice some pyre damage for unit growth because if I didn't I wouldn't have had enough damage output to survive future rounds. It is also very RNG dependent (similar to Umbra I suppose) where having the right card at the right time makes a MASSIVE difference. I just finished my 3rd run with them, another win...but I only won because my champ happened to reform both of my Draffs, one of which was at like 90x2 and 80 hp because I gave both of them Largestones.

I do feel like the Resolve/Reform upgrades to the champion almost completely cancels out the problems with Burnout. Like yeah my stronger units are dying constantly...but it doesn't really matter if I instadraw upgraded versions of them next turn.

Thanks for the breakdown--I think I actually talked to you in another thread about how trash the MR/Umbra combo is, so you've helped me out yet again.

1
PlacatedPlatypus•

Remnant has the Silent issue from STS where at high Cov their card quality is bad enough that you basically have to rely on a small number of strategies (for Silent, Wraith Form/Poison, for Remnant Stealth/Legion of Wax/Stalker).

At higher covenant I always try to use Burn Bright Flicker, as I find him most consistent early game (very important in high cov). I usually take Umbra secondary actually, morsels are good with remnant cards like Big Sludge, Memento Mori, Memories of the Melted, and Legion of Wax. Also if you draft Memories of the Melted with a powerful X-cost spell from Umbra it can be game-winning. I haven't played much with Stygian/Awoken/Hellhorned secondary but I imagine Awoken buffs work well with Remnant cards, and Stygian/Hellhorned units are quite good with stealth.

2
tyrico•

please tell me you are at least playing on covenant 1? that way you get the random starting cards?

honestly you're not even playing the real game until you play that way. if you're going to learn you'd be better served learning to deal with at least that very basic form of RNG plus it is just a lot more fun to see what you can scrape together with some initial conditions.

2
deathandtaxesftw•

Have you heard of the term gatekeeping? You probably meant to leave a positive comment, but in reality the way you've phrased this really results in your words being a negative thing. You are invaliding anyone who chooses to play on the default difficulty level for no real personal gain. You could have phrased the exact same thing different and ended up with a comment that engages with someone instead of alienating them. Food for thought.

5
deathandtaxesftw•

I did not find any noticeable difference in power levels until I had been playing for a long time and really started to understand the game and look for patterns at higher cov levels. For now, you'll probably think that Melting feels really strong because so many of their units are above-average size. This is balanced by the burnout factor and/or the hoops you need to jump through to make it work.

At higher cov levels, I feel like they end up being one of of the more "random" clans in terms of consistency. You'll lose runs due to not drawing your burnout enabler in the first 3 turns for your champion. You'll lose runs due to not being able to find a burnout enabler after gambling on a burn bright champion. That said, Melting also gets to be incredibly degenerate and get easy wins with Legion of Wax or Engulf in Smoke. The faction is still fun and interesting at higher cov levels, especially if you don't care about win streaks.

2
Fakesmiles1000•

Most of the complaints I've seen around MR are using it as an allied clan, not the primary. The main reason being that they often take a lot of investment in either reforming units or extending burnout.

2
Nic200•

Ooh man if you think it is strong now, wait until you unlock Legion of Wax. That paired with some decent upgrades and Intent on death is actually op. As for how strong MR is, I personally do very well with it, but I do see the shortcomings it has. It lacks a good tanky option that can last a while (Burn Bright Flicker, but burnout). Actually, just burnout. It really messes up your bossfights, and it will often get your tanks killed fast or wipe your back line. That is why Wickless recruitment is strong as hell.

1
usquam7•

I definitely agree with you that melting remnant is really good. However, the main drawback that I see with them is that they don’t do well in the early levels. In the early game, all of your units have low hp, burnout, or both (although the 60/60 burnout 3 rector flicker upgrade mitigates this somewhat). Plus, melting remnant doesn’t have much aoe (fatal melting is the only one I think, and it’s a rare card, so it’s unlikely to see it at all) Thus the first few battles you tend to take a lot of damage early before you become strong, but if you’re able to get past fel, you’re usually unbeatable.

1
Kelcak•

If you’re still playing low covenant then it’s possible that you just broke through a learning barrier and are experiencing a higher win rate as a result. After all, almost 100% of runs on Cov 1 are supposed to be winnable if you make the right choices.

I know personally my winrate jumped from below 30% to above 75% on Cov 2 once I zeroed in on a few key tactics. It dropped back down as I started climbing covenant ranks and needed to adjust strategies though.

1
Sokrydes•

Reform Melting Remnant are really strong imo. They ar by far my favourite clan aswell. They generate tons of gold, you can basically take all trials because units are expendable. All you need is some ways to reform and some good reform targets, then remove the rest.

1