I'm new to GMing and my players have never played before, what are some good tips for writing a game and GMing?

I'm trying to make a game for my players set in a town where they are all college students and there is a cultist going around trying to bring about all the Cthulhu like stuff and murdering people who find out about him while there are fish people in a river near them who are slowly trying to take over the whole town. I'm not entirely sure where to start and how to write the mysteries and hooks and I'd really appreciate it if I got some tips for how to go about this.

Posted Jun 25, 2020, 12:27 AM UTC

88
laancelot•
  1. Everybody is here to have fun (you included). Try to remember that at all time.
  2. Tip #1 again. It's that important. If a player is making it hard for the others to have fun, nip that shit in the bud by speaking with him right away about it. Most people will adapt, but there are some cases where a single player may ruin everybody's fun (and have to be kicked out). Every DM seems to have an horror story about those. I didn't for ~20 years, but at some point it happened anyway. Trust me on this one: you're here to have fun. Every player is, too. Make sure that that's possible.
  3. 5 rooms donjon is a solid, easy way to write scenes.
  4. The world isn't the game. Your NPCs have lives of their own. Most people won't "die for the cause", and have loved one to go back to. They have their own motives and private though. Even of you don't plan every single person in detail (I sure don't), make sure that you know that they are independent individuals. You world will be much more alive that way.
  5. The DM is always right. Try to apply it this way: when you call something, it's an absolute truth. Any player can try to make you reconsider, but they can't insist if you don't see it the way they see it. Make this a "house rule" so the players know about it and it will make things easier to wing when the time comes.
  6. The players are both dumb as rocks about things you'll script and evil genius when it comes to derailing your scenario. Plan with a part of chaos in mind: assume that the players can and will make mistakes and must be able to somehow continue the quest anyway.
  7. Let them make decisions. Railroading is an honest way to deliver a story, but if you put the players in a metaphorical cage story-wise they will try to escape and this will ruin your story anyway. With experience you will be better at guessing what the players will instinctively do, but for a start plan the outlines and have backup plans ready for winging the details, like small mobs and second-grade characters ready to intervene either against the players or to help/point them in the right direction.
  8. Be as meta as you need. Sometimes, it's better to just straight up tell the players what they need to know. There' few things worse than a team who have no idea what they are supposed to be doing.
  9. Start with a very obvious hook, which either tells the players what to do or gives them many clear directions where to investigate. Then, even if they look the wrong way, you can start giving them those more subtle clues that will pile on until they become obvious.
  10. Adjust on the fly. If the players are too strong for your challenges, just crank it up a little. Vary: sometimes the players will have a great time just owning the situation, and it's fine. But for this to mean something, they must also have other times where they struggle. The best struggle is the one where the players think that they might just lose, but somehow overcome the challenge themselves. They don't have to know that you cut out or added a couple bad guys or problems. All that's memorable makes for a good game.
  11. The players are supposed to be the underdogs. Make sure that they know it by showing it to them before it's too late. If you have a Big Bad Evil Guy which is too lethal for the players, make sure that they witness how bad it is before they have an opportunity to be obliterated by him.
7
walrusscumboot•

Read a few of the published adventures and perhaps listen to a podcast or two (The Old Ways podcast is quite good). This will give you a better understanding of the framework to work in. The other piece of advice is emulate and improvise. Emulate stories you like, improvise the the details.

6
TheOriginalSunomis•

It seems that you already have a lot of ideas, that's great.

Usually when I make my own stories I start with a few key scenes and locations. It gives a nice sandbox style to the games, but you can also railroad your players by making your clues more obvious if that makes you more comfortable.

Speaking of clues, there's a great blog called three clue rule which I advise you always follow. Basically, for every piece of information you'd like your players to obtain, you have to give them three different clues.

4
grmblflx•

Thanks for linking the three clue rule! I didn't know that.

1
TheOriginalSunomis•

It's a great trick. It makes writing, preparation and gaming much smoother. And using my "conclusions sheet" (featuring a list of conclusions with the relevant clues under them) I hardly ever forget to give players the clues.

1
grmblflx•

My players usually don't miss many clues, but they oftentimes come to the wrong conclusions. Having more clues to give to point in the right direction is a good thing, I guess.

1
WulfderSturm•

Check out the free Camp Sunny scenario. The Investigators are a bunch of college students.

2
my_darkest_fear•

A good thing to do is setup expectations for the sessions with your players. Things such as table etiquette, and any topics that people arent comfortable with so that you avoid problematic and awkward moments at the table.

Make sure you do this before sitting down the first session, so there is time for any discussion and clarification before the session.

1