Will The Bazaar address the problems current turn-based/card/strategy games have?
Since the game seems to be in a big overhaul anyway, why not use it to additionally address problems that other games of similar genres have?
- The worst part about turn-based games - waiting for your opponent's turn while nothing happens.
60-90 seconds is the worst kind of inactivity time, too short to do something meaningful, yet long enough to get bored. And you can't make the standard turn time too short, you'll either have to dumb down the game a lot, or make it absolutely inaccessible for newer players.
- Chess tried to solve it with a chess clock, but it's still debatable if it solved the problem.
- Magic tried responses like Instant cards (which added a lot of other problems along the way).
- HS tried "toys" on the board (which, I know, The Bazaar is planned to have).
- Artifact and Runeterra tried back-and-forth plays.
- If anything, Autochess seems to nail this problem the best by allowing the players to take turns at the same time. It was still kind of bad at times (too short or too long), but it works most of the time.
Will The Bazaar have something meaningful to do while waiting for your opponent to "drool all over the keyboard on an obvious turn"? Maybe the "toys" could be a part of gameplay somehow, or you will still be able to interact with your "cards"? Like having an item like treasure chest that can be opened only after you press the "end turn"?
- The 1v1 strategy games problem - if you lose, you feel bad.
And, of course, you should - that's what losing the game is all about. But losing in a 1v1 strategy game feels especially bad. Especially if you lose 3 times in a row (which happens to anyone eventually).
- Can't blame your team or say that "at least I was not the bottom fragger". In 1v1 you are always the bottom fragger.
- Strategy games require intellect. Losing a lot in a strategy game could feel like the universe is trying to tell you that you are just dumb.
- If those 3 games took an hour to play, you feel bad thinking that you could have just conceded all those games at the start and save yourself an hour of life.
- And you feel even worse thinking that you could have just not played today and saved your ranked points. Which leads to the "ladder anxiety", seen in all competitive 1v1 games, from Chess to Starcraft.
I honestly don't think this problem could be solved for a 1v1 game, the best example of solving it is, again, Autochess with 8-player lobbies.
Will The Bazaar have 8-player lobbies? Or maybe something like "you were 1 damage off lethal, so you lose less points"? And opponent gains less, so it's not exploitable. Or something else that justifies spending an hour on losing games?
Or even a single-player mode, like Slay the Spire, where it's ok if the player wins most of the battles.
I know it is probably too early to share the specifics of the game, but it would be interesting to know if these things are considered.
Maybe there are some other common strategy game problems I missed that also deserve a closer look. Feel free to add them in the comments.
Posted Jun 28, 2020, 2:31 AM UTC