ohrightthatswhyWestbury •

Yeah solid. Avon and Somerset have generally been very good in balancing the line between not pissing everyone off, and going through the motions of prosecuting what is technically a crime. I think this shows the value of community policing: if the community doesn't think a crime has been committed, no need to go through the rigmarole.

84
hangfrogOP•

Pretty much my thoughts.. Taking this charge to Crown Court seems like a massive waste of time and money but would apparently be a technical necessity. It then runs more danger of becoming a political issue. Police have nicely dispensed with all the fuss and effectively fined the guy and made him do some worthwhile (for him) community service, without being dicks about it..

19
GarrySpacepope•

I mean the person in question could've refused the caution and then everyone would've had no choice but to take it to the courts.

But generally this seems fair and even handed for everyone involved.

3
TheOnlyNemesis•

Tell that to the idiots planning a protest against them

0
Crowcorrector•

if the community doesn't think a crime has been committed, no need to go through the rigmarole.

So mob rule is ok then?

-20
sastarbucks•

“To recognise always that the power of the police to fulfil their functions and duties is dependent on public approval of their existence, actions and behaviour and on their ability to secure and maintain public respect.”

13
finfinfin•

-- karl marx, probably

-5
sastarbucks•

Actually the person who formed the metropolitan police.

8
clodiusmetellus•

When you have to make extraordinary leaps to try to work out who's the victim in a case, it's probably OK.

8
akaadam•

Only if it fits with the current meta

0
ForestTechno•

Tbf what is the state and capital if not mob rule?

0
Crowcorrector•

A parlamentary democracy. The difference between that and mob rule is that the rights of minorities are protected.

2
ForestTechno•

Haha you reckon? They haven't been very well protected by Paralementary Democracy to be honest. I assume you've not watched the news much recently, and ignored the deaths of 1000's of homeless, disabled people. Paralementary Democracy has continually let us down it's a facade where you give your power to someone else.

1
FluffyCloud5•

I think it's a good solution. Technically it was against the law, but all in all probably doesn't warrant a harsh sentence, considering the consensus for years is that we should probably get rid of the statue anyways. A donation to a related charity, and a mandatory meeting that allows the person to channel their energy into a constructive change for the future, this seems like a really sensible approach.

46
gertusa•

Good move from the police there. However this wasnt one of the 15 people whose pictures were released the other day. Have to see if they get the same treatment aswell.

31
DefunctPunk•

Agreed, this seems to be fair treatment given the circumstances. No doubt an example will need to be made somewhere but hopefully we see a similar outcome for the other exposed parties.

Context matters and it's a good thing that this is being recognised.

11
GarrySpacepope•

Isn't there something in the law that states all people at the same crime scene, committing the same crime have to be treated equally?

When Prince Harry got caught smoking weed out the back of a pub near where I grew up a friends older brother got off without a caution because they didn't caution Harry.

0†
tomtomgg•

That doesn't sound right...

4
gertusa•

The peoples whose pictures were released were in connection to the tearing down of the statue. This guy was involved in putting the statue in the river. Different crimes I assume.

3
Pigrescuer•

Littering?

2
richhcirrich•

Whilst I would like to see them with no charges I appreciate I'm in the outlier, and the council have pressed charges. This seems to be a fair compromise, as in particular this caution would still hang over them for 6 years. The rest of the incident was peaceful and this was a political act. I do worry that those on the other end of the spectrum will see it as not being harsh enough, however.

15
AfroskiRay•

If you worry too much how the far right feel you find yourself goose-stepping with them while the rest of us meet the boot

4†
richhcirrich•

You misconstrue me, I am not saying that we should pander to such view points. I very much subscribe to the Popper idea of the "Paradox of tolerance", and that by allowing hateful and harmful views to be accepted we risk society being seized by the intolerant.

I worry in the sense that the DFLA and associates will return to tarnish our centre with violence, drinking and apologism for fascism.

4
nakedfish85Seagull_Policeman•

Goddamn it, using Outline for Bristol Post needs to be made a rule in this sub. My poor eyes.

11
SubstantialMaize0•

AmazIng how many Bristolians are up in arms about this statue coming down when this city is meant to be a progressive place full of love and understanding. Sometimes that looks like a statue being pulled down! It’s not ‘mob rule’ it’s bloody progress.

Managed to talk my dad round. Hes an old Bristolian and was angry about Colston coming down, but when I asked him his feelings on the Berlin Wall coming down he managed to see the parallels and admitted maybe it wasn’t necessarily a bad thing haha

11
shaolinoli•

Good on you for engaging and arguing your corner successfully bud.

5

That title made it sound like the caution was punishment for donating and attending.

5
pickapstix•

The most Bristol thing that Bristol can do. Turn a slightly naughty act into a learning opportunity. The kid clearly has passion for the subject area and now he can funnel it for good :)

3
_xDEADBEEF•

I said this'd happen. Where do i get my chufty badge from?

​

The A+S police fb page is going to be seething in the comments.

[edit] yep. a few prized plonkers in there.

2†
bull0x🚀•

Gert lush’d

0
voiceofgromit•

The hallmark of a good compromise is one where nobody is entirely happy. So this is a good compromise.

2
gashead31•

I'm fine with this, as long as it's pursued and they have to face some level of consequence then I'm happy.

I don't think they should get locked up or anything but we can't set the precedent that you can break the law if you unilaterally decide your cause is moral enough.

1†
spawnADmusic•

I don't think the rightness of the statue coming down was a fringe opinion at least.

0
IRRJ•

The caution is expected, but the donation to an anti-slavery charity and the meeting to discuss the future of all statues in the city is a bit random. Especially as Bristol City Council has not been consulted about any meeting.

1
Waninglite•

Very pragmatic.

1
HimitsuUK•

Good good.

0†
jl6•

I’m fine with the outcome but the process seems a bit arbitrary. Are the police allowed to set any old conditions in exchange for letting someone off with a caution? Feels like a power that could easily be abused, especially where the conditions involve money.

-1
staticman1•

This individual's involvement was very minor. He helped push the statue into the water but was not involved in the planning or the actual toppling as far as I can tell. For criminal damage as a first offense, no-premeditation, spur of the moment with minimal involvement a formal caution is fairly standard.

I will hold judgement the main ringleaders are charged

-2
sub2pewdiepieONyt•

So if you break the law you get to have more sway and power to get other things changed, more than both the people who campaigned legally to have it removed and those who wanted it to stay.

Seems like more of a reward than a punishment.

-2†
LuvNotH8x•

Not at all. It's completely unfair for him to be given a caution. They should not face any punishment.

-3†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-6
The54thCylon•

Or, the police knew who he was without releasing his image.

8
MettySwinge•

Surprise surprise. Gutless Avon & Somerset at it again.

If it was anything else it would be much harder punishment than this.

Fine and community service, not a fucking circle jerking meeting.

-34
joshjevans94•

Why all the anger?

Think its important to remember that Bristol is (for me) the most compassionate and loving city i’ve ever been to and that boils down to business owners and police. The action taken in this article screams volumes to that fact

18
MettySwinge•

It's not anger. It's disgust with the lack of consistency. If the vandals had vandalized a police building, or something not "Woke" it would've been dealt with signifcantly harsher than it has been. That's what got under my nose.

-22
joshjevans94•

Banksy continuously vandalises things around the city but that’s considered art? The point is that there is and always will be an inconsistency but it depends on the purpose and who’s doing it. If our black neighbours are saying something is offensive (and as a result cause a movement and history to be made throughout the world) then we should listen

15
MettySwinge•

Oh I agree. If something is genuinely offensive then I agree it should be reviewed and if possible removed. However in the photos of the statue being pulled down, I barely saw any BAME, and the people jumping on it weren't either. That, combined with the BAME people I've spoken with about the cancellation of programs referring to blackface and the like are all annoyed by it, opposed to empowered.

-15
richhcirrich•

Why do you only have selective outrage for the toppling of the Colston statue, and nothing for the desecration to the monument of Alfred Fagon or the grave of Scipio Africanus?

5
[deleted]•

[removed]

-2
lebski88MOD•

Please can you stop posting this to r/bristol.

5
Shanghijack•

I disagree. Have a nice day.

8