[Sun Care] The waterless sunscreen company - Skinnies

Sun Care

Hello! So recently I've come across this New Zealand sunscreen company called Skinnies after seeing Cyrille Laurent denounce them on his Instagram story. They claim that a little goes a long way (which is the complete opposite of how sunscreens work) and you only need to use a pea sized amount of their product to get adequate sun protection on your face, neck and ears. They say that this is because their sungel is more of a "sunscreen concentrate" because they don't use any water therefore, you don't need to use the same amount as other sunscreens.

Now this all sounds too good to be true right? How come big companies like L'oreal who spend millions of dollars on research and development aren't able to develop a "sunscreen concentrate" in which you only require a fraction of what we know to use currently? Well they've also posted some test reports on their Instagram page as well as their website which looks pretty legit but I'm no scientist so I have no idea! They've tested 1.3mg/cm2 as well as 2.0mg/cm2 and the reports show that the SPF exceeds that of the labelled SPF on the product. I have no idea how much 1.3mg/cm2 is but surely that wouldn't be a pea size amount for your face, neck and ears?

I've seen people commenting on their posts, criticizing them for marketing their product like this and they respond back rather condescendingly. This includes calling someone "sweetheart", asking for their credentials other than throwing tantrums and telling Cyrille to go back to his reviews of skincare products if that is all he is capable of. Extremely unprofessional and uncalled for. Even if their sunscreen is all they make it out to be, I wouldn't support this company because their responses are gross.

Anyway I'm keen to see what you guys think!

Posted Jul 4, 2020, 6:14 AM UTC

517
green_pea_nut•

That's strange. New Zealanders are usually sensible and polite.

Jacinda Ardern for President of Earth!

8
Valuable_Meringue•

So I’d never heard of this brand until this post and looked them up because it really did sound too good to be true. Looking solely at the information they provide it does seem interesting and appears to have a lot of really good ingredients. The unfortunate thing is that doesn’t give any real idea about the efficacy of the sunscreen or if you can only apply a pea sized amount like they suggest.

However, I did come across an article that said an independent consumer protection group, Consumer NZ, had tested one of their kid’s sunscreens and found it only provided an spf of 25 instead of 50. They also accused Skinnies of not going through the proper testing procedure by only testing on one subject instead of the required ten in NZ. That just makes me wonder how good the rest of their products are. Adding in the fact that they treat customers the way you described, I wouldn’t feel inclined to try their sunscreen.

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
xhaltsalute•

I just got an IG ad for this sunscreen and immediately came here to see if anyone here had tried it it has any opinions either way. Agreed that it seems too good to be true... Had anyone here tried it?

5
keiher•

I had the very same reservations on it's efficacy.

I looked up reviews and Dr. Dray on YouTube tried it and had a positive review, so I decided to try a bottle (she talks about the NZ version, but her summary also includes the US version). It is incredibly comfortable to wear. I haven't given it a solid try in the sun yet though.

My main issue with SPF is that it get greasy, white marks on my clothes that are so hard to remove, so if this stuff works, I'll be so happy.

2
ThatFlowerOP•

Oh I didn't realize she had reviewed it! Was kind of hoping she would go into more detail about their pea sized amount claim though.

2
keiher•

I've been using their SPF 30 on my body this month. While I haven't used it on my face (chemical SPFs typically cause acne for me), just in seeing how it spreads on the rest of my body, their suggested "pea-sized blob" might work for the face and ears, but I doubt it would also fully cover the entire neck, mostly just because it's too thick to allow it to spread that thin. (Dr. Dray definitely used more than a pea sized blob in her video too.)

I use a blob the size of two peas probably for each arm/shoulder, neck/chest, and slightly more for each leg. That said, it's less product than a typical SPF lotion, so a 3.4 oz bottle will probably last as long as a 5-6 oz bottle of lotion like LRP's Anthelios Melt-In Milk Sunscreen SPF 60.

It's definitely one of the most cosmetically elegant formulations that I've tried. It doesn't feel dry, but it's also not gooey. My skin feels lightly moisturized, not sticky. No cast or smell. It also doesn't rub off onto my clothes and create white marks.

I actually might try it on my face just to see if it'll work there without causing acne, because of how nice it feels on the rest of me.

2
tym05•

so i just did the math both with 1.3mg per cm2 and 2mg per cm2 using my face. keep in mind this is not a lab experiment with precise measurements. i used the simple method of measuring my face with a piece of paper. (just face, i didnt do my neck)

forehead: 15.5cm x 6.2cm: 96.1 cm2

rest of my face: 23.5cm x 15.5cm: 364.25 cm2

(i kept the shapes rectangular to account for curvature and the total is larger than my actual face but it works to be over than under)

total area: 460.35 cm2

460.35cm2 at 1.3mg: 598.455mg rounded to 599 mg .6gr

460.35cm2 at 2mg: 920.7mg rounded to 921mg .92gr

so, at 1.3 a pea size should be enough for my face, not for face neck and ears.

i think the "pea size" is the problem, peas are tiny. a "bean size" seems more accurate, im aware beans come in different sizes so for the sake of my experiment i would say "edamame bean size".

Texture wise tho, i have to say this is one of the better sunscreens out there. spreadability is pretty great, it feels smooth on the skin, it kinda glides on. it does feel greasy to the touch but only if you touch it, i dont really feel it on my skin as i do with other sunscreens.

Works great with makeup on top if i do the sunscreen/setting powder/setting spray/foundation method.

All in all i am happy with it, i have 2 bottles so ill use them all and see how it goes.

In regards to their social media, i have to agree that they have come off a little aggressive sometimes but i have also interacted with them on DM and they have been nothing but nice and accommodating and helpful to me. i cant speak for others experiences.

2
ThatFlowerOP•

It's nice to hear that it's working out for you! Yes I agree, peas are tiny. I'm sure the sunscreen is great but it's just the fact that they're encouraging people to use as little as possible that seems to be the main problem imo.

1
tym05•

Totally!! Maybe they mean chick peas? lol. But in all seriousness I don't see how "pea size" makes sense from a financial point of view. The less product they use, the longer it takes for them to finish a tub... Less sales. I understand that less product is needed in comparison with regular sunscreen but yeah the "pea" is problematic, even in their own videos the amount shown looks much larger than a pea. Oh well, it is a gorgeous formulation tho.

2
AutoModeratorMOD•

Hi everyone! SkincareAddiction is a friendly community of skincare enthusiasts.

In search of your own skincare advice?

See something that breaks our rules? Please report it!

Everyone is welcome in this community; remember to be kind and assume good faith :)

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
tym05•

Cyrille should go back to his reviews. I have nothing against the guy but sometimes I don't like that he attacks something without going into detail and then drops it. I'm yet to see a video of him actually explaining in detail (like he does about other products) the why this product isn't good or their claims etc.

1
CutepengwingDry|Acne-prone|Fragrance-free 🍓•

I think he did a video roughly a week ago actually explaining why they were wrong. Essentially the results they showed were from a European testing method which only uses 1.3 mg per cm2 and then the result is converted into the 2mg cm2 version, so basically the brand was totally lying! I wish he had posted that explanation earlier so we could have understood exactly what was going on.

2
tym05•

Thanks for the heads up. I just checked and yeah he posted a video about it 5 days a go. I also wish he had done it closer to his ig story. I'll be honest, I can't stand the guy... I just can't but I respect his knowledge and credentials.

2
CutepengwingDry|Acne-prone|Fragrance-free 🍓•

I know where you’re coming from when it comes to not being able to stand someone- I have the same thing with Dr Dray and Dr Vanita Rattan. I can’t really put my finger on it but I just don’t like the vibes.

2
tym05•

i wonder if the european testing is more appropriate for their formulation then? im gonna do the math and re measure my face and figure out exactly how much i would need using the 1.3mg per cm2.

i also found a video where Cyrille talks about this (not specifically about skinnies, its an older video) i think its the one where he measures his face with a piece of paper. Anyway, he then talks about volume and how depending on the formulation some will need more or less than the 1/4 teaspoon than others. This made me think that maybe i should do the actual math and figure out how much smaller the amount would be with skinnies. but to be honest, i think they should stop with the "pea size" peas are super small and even on their videos the blob they use looks more like 3 peas or an edamame bean, maybe they should do "bean size" lol

2
m0lr4t•

Do you have any idea what the UVA protection of this is?

1
ThatFlowerOP•

No idea. Sorry!

1