The difference in organic reaction chains between British A-level chemistry and Russian EGE, both of which are studied at age of 18

The difference in organic reaction chains between British A-level chemistry and Russian EGE, both of which are studied at age of 18

Posted Jul 4, 2020, 6:37 PM UTC

55
nodderguyOP•

I studied both programs and I found it interesting that the Russian Chemistry was much harder than the British in terms of the amount of chemical reactions that are needed for the exam. Both presentations were done by me using PowerPoint. To be fair, I felt lazy to convert the Russian names of the groups (For reference, the alkane group is right in the middle of the russian diagram).

Btw, the British version does not include the benzene reactions, so the lower part of the Russian diagram can be discarded for comparison. The arrows are colored to show approx rarity (the chance of the reaction occurring on the exam, red/yellow being the rarest).

5
-TheWiseSalmon-Organic•

Interesting, because the British A-level system is already pretty good in terms of the amount of organic chemistry you have to learn. I know that the Irish Leaving Cert has basically no organic chemistry at all, and as far as I'm aware they don't do much organic chemistry at all in high schools in the US. And from speaking to Germans, they didn't do much either (though I think the education system varies significantly from state-to-state in Germany).

In the Russian system is it all just rote-memorisation or do you delve into some basic mechanistic chemistry too?

1
nodderguyOP•

Yep, it’s mostly memorisation. We also learn many inorganic reactions as well. In fact, I think there is more inorganic stuff there than in a-level. We don’t have to know any mechanisms for reactions for the exam, but we are expected to know the names of the mechanisms (electrophilic substitution, etc). We also don’t need to know how to identify the compound using the IR etc.

1
walkingmelways•

This is fascinating; thank you for posting it.
I read “toluol”, “cumol” and “benzol” in Cyrillic, which makes me wonder if those names are the current convention in Russia (as distinct from -ene names like toluene).
Also “caoutchouc” which I suspect is synthetic rubber given that it comes from a diene.

3
nodderguyOP•

Yep, the trivial and IUPAC names of organic compounds in Russian are similar in pronunciation compared to English ones. To be fair, this made it much easier for me to switch from English to Russian chemistry.

You are right, “Cauchuk” is synthetic latex where the monomer is isoprene. I’m pleased that my diagrams can be readable :)

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1