This is my second or third time the roast came out uneven; although coffee tasted excellent in the previous roasts, the color is somewhat disappointing (at least to me). Am I doing something wrong? Yirga, Behmor 1600, end of first crack. Any help is appreciated!

This is my second or third time the roast came out uneven; although coffee tasted excellent in the previous roasts, the color is somewhat disappointing (at least to me). Am I doing something wrong? Yirga, Behmor 1600, end of first crack. Any help is appreciated!

Posted Jul 5, 2020, 1:01 AM UTC

314
DavidBeegle•

That really is not too bad so I think you are being too hard on yourself. Evenness really comes from the agitation. Is there a way for you to configure that roaster to agitate more?

2
oneworld279OPFull City•

Nope, Behmor got only two drum speeds, 8rpm and 16rpm. Can’t wait to ditch this and get an Aillio. I’ve noticed some folks get even roasts with Behmor; but maybe I need to wait till the begin of second crack. With Yirga being a natural and all, don’t want to roast it too which will ruin the fruitiness.

1
mike-pennacchiaHuky 500t•

By any chance is it a natural yirg?

Edit: literally in the comment above.. My b. But this roast looks damn good and even considering its a natural. Naturals will always produce more uneven roasts because of the sugars left from the processing method when comparing to wet process.

Also, what are you preheating to before you load the drum in?

5
oneworld279OPFull City•

Close too 220 B temp, without the drum that is. My very first roast few weeks ago roast I heated with the drum but man, that genuinely F’d up the whole batch with inconsistent roast. Not even close to what I got now.

1
mike-pennacchiaHuky 500t•

Yeah my yirfacheffe natural roast didn't come out this even. Roasted a couple days ago. I've been sticking with my HGBM but have been struggling to get any good flavors to come out despite having pretty good roast curves. So, I pulled the behmor back out.

My b temp was about 275, sounds like I need to lower it. With that said though, the batches of the same bean on my HGBM were far more even, I think it's just because it has significantly more agitation.

I think the HGBM just gets some meh flavors because it's almost all air roasting the chaff burns up, and there's no way to control air flow. I've been looking into new roasters.

2
DavidBeegle•

So, this might sound crazy, but I do wonder if adding something into the drum with the beans might help. As funny as it sounds, some large brass (steel, whatever) balls to help agitate. Perhaps even those smoothy whisk ball thingies but those may be too flimsy? I still think it looks pretty good and I would enjoy drinking some of it.

2
oneworld279OPFull City•

Thanks for the suggestion! Interesting and never thought of something like that; I will experiment for sure!

1
Bongoots•

Search for ceramic baking beans, they're used for making pastry/pie crusts.

I haven't used baking beans myself as I do large enough batches of 250g for my roasts using an aluminium Dutch oven over a gas hob with a silicone whisk and don't have any troubles at all.

1
mikethingsup•

Do you run in manually or automatic? I preheat with my drum, you have to be quick and careful.

I run it manual P5 until FC, I increase drum speed when the exhaust kicks in (5 min into roast on 1/2 lb) then drop to P3 at the start of FC through the end. Did a Yirga with solid uniformity, but still not completely consistent.

2
oneworld279OPFull City•

Manual; the first few times I did preheat the drum but ended up with even more inconsistent roast (burn actually). I saw some beans getting burnt due to the heat and rest were okay. Didn’t do that mistake again lol. Yeah I use P5 until 320ish B temp and when fan kicks in; I bring it down to P4 and try to maintain B at 280ish. When beans start cracking the temps go up anyway, so I try to be in between 270-280; kinda extend the roast times and faster speed drum ofc.

1
fantastic-mr-boxProbat•

This could be in large part normal color variance depending on the sorting of the coffee. Some Ethiopian coffees can have quite a lot of color variance. Not inherently bad.

2
oneworld279OPFull City•

I always thought Sumatra and low altitude beans have that kinda of character. Uneven coloration and bottled appearance. Good to know tho, thanks!

1
fantastic-mr-boxProbat•

Yep, it can definitely be inherent variation in the coffee and not a product of roasting. (Whether an underpowered roasting system exacerbates that, I do not know.) Anyway can be an issue in some situations, but doesn't have to be. If you're happy with the flavor, assume you're doing nothing wrong.

2
oneworld279OPFull City•

Behmor 1600 Plus*

1