Who in Seven Hells is Ragwyle? (Spoilers ASOS)
tl;dr there’s a woman who was stolen from south of the wall right in front of us as a living, breathing wildling.
Alright folks, unbox and unroll your foil because something’s bothering me. In the ACOK chapter where Qhorin and Jon are finally cornered by Rattleshirt and his gang, most of the 14 wildlings are unnamed. However, one plays a major role in the events that unfold- instigating the fight that leads to Qhorin’s death. But it gets a little weirder than this. This character’s manner of speech is extremely unusual compared to the other wildlings except maybe Mance and his beautiful court women Dalla and Val- in a way that makes me very suspicious she may have been raised south of the wall.
Of Rattleshirt’s gang, very few are named or described in detail, let alone have important or recurring roles in the action of such a dramatic scene. Besides Rattleshirt and Ygritte only Longspear Ryk and the random and completely exchangeable Lenyl are named while we do get some descriptions like “a skinny youth” and “another spearwife”, as well as “a short homely man” (who is actually Longspear, making Ragwyle more notable). So who is Ragwyle, why does she get so much attention, why does she seem to care about NW men/a Stark bastard, and why is her speech so unusual?!
Here are her sections in ACOK:
The wildling hissed in anger, and his mount reared. He did rattle, Jon could hear it; the bones were strung together loosely, so they clacked and clattered when he moved. "It's your bones I'll be rattling soon, Halfhand. I'll boil the flesh off you and make a byrnie from your ribs. I'll carve your teeth to cast me runes, and eat me oaten porridge from your skull."
"If you want my bones, come get them."
That, Rattleshirt seemed reluctant to do. His numbers meant little in the close confines of the rocks where the black brothers had taken their stand; to winkle them out of the cave the wildlings would need to come up two at a time. But another of his company edged a horse up beside him, one of the fighting women called spearwives. "We are four-and-ten to two, crows, and eight dogs to your wolf," she called. "Fight or run, you are ours."
"Show them," commanded Rattleshirt.
The woman reached into a bloodstained sack and drew out a trophy. Ebben had been bald as an egg, so she dangled the head by an ear. "He died brave," she said.
Ragwyle appears as a character as part of a gang led by a brutal wildling- who tend to despise the Night’s Watchmen- but she compliments Ebben in his bravery at death to his friends.
This is the Bastard o' Winterfell, who spared me. Let him live."
Jon met Ygritte's eyes, and had no words.
"Let him die," insisted the Lord of Bones. "The black crow is a tricksy bird. I trust him not." ... ”You told me Mance would take me."
"And he will," Ygritte said.
"Mance is not here," said Rattleshirt. "Ragwyle, gut him."
The big spearwife narrowed her eyes and said, "If the crow would join the free folk, let him show us his prowess and prove the truth of him."
"I'll do whatever you ask." The words came hard, but Jon said them.
Rattleshirt's bone armor clattered loudly as he laughed. "Then kill the Halfhand, bastard."
Is she narrowing her eyes at the order from her leader, ostensibly to kill a boy with a sharp sword guarded by a wolf- which is how I’ve always interpreted it? Because when Rattleshirt does give out other orders the wildlings obey, including Ragwyle just a second ago to hold a severed head. Or are we being misled and she’s narrowing her eyes when she realizes he’s from Winterfell? Either way Ragwyle wants to give a NW man a chance at life with the Free Folk- why?
Not only does Ragwyle end up inspiring the order for Jon to kill Qhorin, a notably major event, but then look at the language she uses. It’s distinctly more cultured and proper, similar to what we hear to the south more than to the north of the Wall.
As a physical description, she’s repeatedly described as “big”, but this is from Jon’s POV and he has also just repeatedly referred to the Halfhand as “the big ranger”. Is this a clue that she may be a fairly large-framed woman?
Ygritte answered for him. "His name is Jon Snow. He is Eddard Stark's blood, of Winterfell."
Ragwyle laughed. "Who would have thought it? Qhorin Halfhand slain by some lordling's byblow."
"Gut him."...
Lordling’s byblow? She’s getting this from Eddard Stark and Snow, but why would a wildling have so much disdain for a bastard when Tormund explicitly states that wildlings don’t feel this way? But also- why would she call Ned Stark a lordling? He’s been Lord Stark for ~17 years by this point: is there any chance that Ragwyle knew of or met or saw Ned when he was in fact still a younger brother of the heir to House Stark? All of the other wildlings speak of Starks as formidable enemies, or fearsome leaders, or tell Bael’s story- but here we get a Westerosi-sounding “insult”.
Now ASOS changes gears slightly. GRRM names one more of remaining 10 wildlings (Lenyl, who then fades into obscurity), and gives us a little more Ragwyle before she too disappears from the narrative:
Ygritte wore the cloak of Qhorin Halfhand. Lenyl had his hauberk, the big spearwife Ragwyle his gloves, one of the bowmen his boots. Qhorin’s helm had been won by the short homely man called Longspear Ryk, but it fit poorly on his narrow head, so he’d given that to Ygritte as well.
Big men tend to have big hands, and Big Spearwife Ragwyle is wearing his gloves which suggests she also has large hands. Since poorly fitting objects tend to be passed around, it’s likely she does and really is that large- I’m starting to envision someone closer to Brienne in size than a smaller woman.
He slew Qhorin Halfhand,” said Longspear Ryk. “Him and that wolf o’ his.”
“And did for Orell too,” said Rattleshirt.
“The lad’s a warg, or close enough,” put in Ragwyle, the big spearwife. “His wolf took a piece o’ Halfhand’s leg.”
We get a very brief snippet of Ragwyle here and her speech is strangely now more characteristically “wildling” in style. Is it possible that amongst other bands and/or when she’s not stressed by a confrontation with non-wildlings (as many accents do flare with anxiety) she affects a more characteristic Free Folk accent?
And then, that’s it... No more Ragwyle.
So who is she? Did GRRM have a plan for her that he abandoned? Was she just there to serve as a female wildling acting belligerently toward their band’s leader, to establish this was standard so that Ygritte doesn’t stand out for her own behavior toward Rattleshirt? Was it just some world-building for our big reveal (post Osha and Craster) of wildlings in the wild? If so, why is her language so unusual compared to the others? Am I reading too much into it? Do I just want to procrastinate my upcoming final exam that badly? Is Ragwyle a stolen, large woman from south of the wall? What do you think?
Here’s my theory:
“The elder of the Greatjon’s uncles. Crow-food, they call him. A crow once took him for dead and pecked out his eye. He caught the bird in his fist and bit its head off. When Mors was young he was a fearsome fighter. His sons died on the Trident, his wife in childbed. His only daughter was carried off by wildlings thirty years ago.
I don’t think she had a majorly large plot role (beyond getting Qhorin killed and Jon to be a wildling, of course) but may have been slipped in as a nod by GRRM. Ragwyle might be the daughter of Mors Umber, taken by wildlings when fairly young. Her older brothers died during the Rebellion, but 15 years earlier she was kidnapped from her home at Last Hearth, which is pretty close to The Wall- thus having a fairly friendly attitude toward black brothers/maintaining affection for her former countrymen. She was familiar with the name Eddard Stark because he would’ve been born when she was young (they possibly may have even been considered for engagement despite the probably ~8 year age difference), and your Lord Paramount having a son is a big deal. Being gone 15 years before Robert’s Rebellion, she doesn’t know how Brandon Stark died- Ned is thus still “a lordling” in her mind, even if she’s heard general news about what really happened and who is in charge now. Being raised with wildlings but having a larger powerful physique (a trait of House Umber) which bestows a fighting ability like Maege or Brienne, perhaps the fairly minor change in environment (directly north vs south side of wall) but given the freer culture (like Arya, Brienne, or ~Lyanna wanted) is this something she embraced? Or maybe she loved whatever wildling stole her, and has stayed North since his death?
Posted Jul 7, 2020, 6:05 AM UTC · edited