In quantum mechanics, is the measurement more like finding the outcome of a dice about to be rolled or finding the outcome of an already rolled dice in a black box?

I am a quantum physics noob. Just learning about it from books of Sean Caroll. If its one of the above mentioned cases, why is it not the other? ELI5 answer is appreciated. Thanks.

Posted Jul 7, 2020, 3:33 PM UTC

116
Quizznor•

It's the former.

Assuming you knew everything there is to know about the dice and black box, you could in theory calculate which side the dice will show when the box is opened.

This is not the case for quantum systems. Their exact state remains undetermined until it is measured (i.e. the dice is rolled).

10
zebediah49•

Their exact state remains undetermined until it is measured (i.e. the dice is rolled).

I'm going to disagree a bit with this wording: the exact state is completely specified previously -- it is a composite state. The measurement changes that state to being a single one.

I think an electron spin illustrates this pretty well. Let's say you have an electron, and its spin is in the +x direction. If you measure it in the +z direction, it's 50/50 that it will be up vs. down.

However, that doesn't mean that it's not determined if it was up or down previously. It was well determined... that it was pointing right (which is equivalent to a complex combination of up and down, because QM).

The measurement forces the system into one of the basis states of that measurement; it could have been in a combination of multiple of those states previously.

9
cake3•

The only aspect of quantum mechanics where anyone will suggest true randomness coming into play is measurement. Before the measurement is made, everyone agrees that quantum mechanics is purely deterministic, so any "dice roll" that happens must happen at the moment the measurement is made.

Note that Sean Carol is a believer in the many words interpretation, so he is someone who would actually tell you that there are no dice rolls at all. In many worlds, it is more like every outcome of the dice roll happens in a parallel universe. So the probability of any particular outcome is 100%, because they all happen, and when you make the measurement you are really just finding out which of the parallel universes you happen to live in.

5
avidblinker•

The distinction here is random probablistic versus chaotic.

1
HapankaaliCondensed matter physics•

So it's definitely not the latter because that would be a hidden variable theory. Bell test experiments exclude such theories.

3
kromem•

That's not true.

Superdeterminism is a perfectly acceptable answer to Bell's paradox. As are non-local hidden variable theories.

These aren't popular interpretations, but they are perfectly valid.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1