Chain length and gearing ratios question

Question first. What's the largest difference in gear ratios you're running on the same chain, without anything wonky, like the rear wheel bolt hanging halfway off the track ends?

Background: I have 14 & 16 cogs and 46 & 49 chainrings, so 76, 80, 87, and 92 gear inches. I recently bought a 52t chainring, wanting the option to get closer to 100". I tried to put it on yesterday, on the 14t cog, and my chain is too short. This is a KMC KC710SL, and it's been quite a few years since I fit it to the original build, but if my counting is right, it has 97 links, so getting a new chain would remedy this. Online calculators seem to agree that I should be able to run 52x14 and 46x16 with the same chain, moved to either end of the track ends.

I'm just thinking about gearing and what I want on the bike, and also trying not to spend all my money on a stable of cogs and chainrings. In retrospect a 12" or 13" cog with existing chainrings would have been cheaper and I wouldn't need a new chain :/

Posted Jul 9, 2020, 9:53 PM UTC

59
Datante•

Nice to see you experimenting, but that's waaay to much math for me :D

I just ride my 48/17 all year long.

2
RaspberryInkOP•

Ha! :)

I have a road bike with gears for normal riding--I use my fixie for sprints. I mean, I still cruise around on it for fun, but the main purpose is to go as fast as possible, so gearing having multiple gears matters.

48x17 seems like a pretty good general purpose road gear, though. I can see riding that all the time.

2
Luther_Lake•

You’ve got a point. I live in a small town with a lot of stop signs. I used to run... wait for it... a 46-19 and it topped out pretty easy but was super nice for stopping. I rock the good ol 46-16 for anything else. Just one mechs two cents.

1
Datante•

I am thinking about going 48/19 to give my knees a little relief :D

2
Convergentshave•

Isn’t there some rule like the least common fraction of the ratio of front and back gives you the amount of skid patches? I run 50/17. Although I will admit I just switched from the usual 48/16, which after nearly a decade of use I still hadn’t figured out... anyways I did have to extend the chain...

1
RaspberryInkOP•

Maybe...?

I used this:

http://www.machinehead-software.co.uk/bike/chain_length/chainlengthcalc.html

If you know your exact chainstay length and length of the track ends, it should give you chain length. I've run the numbers on it, and 52x16 and 46x14 (biggest and smallest chain) will probably work with the same number of links, but it's hard to be sure. My new chain is in the mail--I'll report back once I've tested. I guess worst case is I'll have two different chains for extreme changes in gear ratio.

1
Grindfather901•

a KMC S1 chain is $13 on Amazon.. why not pick up an extra chain and have one set up for each ring/cog extreme?

1
RaspberryInkOP•

That's exactly what I ended up doing. Each chain works for most of my ratios, but I couldn't find one length that would cover the extremes. I also picked up a 13t cog, which gives me pretty close to the 52x14 ratio on a smaller chainring/smaller chain.

2
Grindfather901•

Ahh cool. I didn't realize this post was a month old. LOL

1