r/pokemongo•
StormHH

MMR and match making issues at higher ranks - the struggle to make Rank 10.

Discussion

Background:

I am an ex rank 10 player trying to push on to rank 10 again this season. After great league I was around 2650 MMR (top 50 on the leaderboard). Progressed to 2906 in ultra (took time off as rank 10 was unobtainable for a while). Since master league began, I have twice got into the 2960s before falling away again. Although this happens to everyone, there has been a common issue, I have been winning over half my matches (around 60%) and actually gone down.

The problem:

The threshold of 3000 MMR is getting tougher and tougher each season (particularly as the player base is split into several leagues). As players drop out, the nature of a finite amount of points means that the top players are at a lower MMR on average and that 3000 becomes harder and harder each season. In addition with less rewards/incentives, players reach rank 10 and stop. So those points are "locked away". As a result a player trying to reach rank 10 has to have a great win % to move up:

Take today as an example (the values in brackets are the change in my MMR) (7 sets as one carried over):

Started at 2894:

2/5 (-26), 4/5 (+30), 4/5 (+30), 4/5 (+35), 3/5 (-4), 1/5 (-67), 3/5 (+1) - finishing at 2893 (dropped 1 point)

So today I went 21/35 which is 60%. Generally that's a great day but I've actually gone down, albeit only a point.

The lack of players at the top echelons means I'm probably playing more players below my level (I can be waiting minutes for a game sometimes). Odds are I'm playing players below me most the time - I hardly saw any rank 10s today. Hence I need to be averaging 60% to stay put which is very difficult with the blind nature of GBL is very very hard. The 1/5 I had a disastereous run of 5 terrible leads and actually flipped one and lost another 2 by a whisker. Sets like that aren't rare for anyone at any level!

What does this mean and how can it be addressed:

As mentioned before, the MMR system runs off a zero sum game. I.e. if we all start at 2000, for someone to get to 3000 then someone else must have lost 1000 points.

With the rewards for pvp being universally recognised as being a bit rubbish, in addition to just general fatigue and other reasons, the number of players doing pvp will generally drop away. In addition to this, it's more likely to be the lower level players (people that are finding the entry costs prohibitive and not worth it). So now we have less points and the average caliber of player has increased. Consequently its harder to get to harder MMR at ALL LEVELS. And this pattern will only get worse each season.

SO HOW COULD THIS BE FIXED?

The obvious solution is after a certain point of the season, you take a certain percentile of players to be each rank (i.e. the top 10% of players form the top rank). You keep the MMR system which is doing its job well. If you're at the top you should be able to win more than 50% of matches to stay put. But you should be at the top rank if this is the case. You would need to try and keep people playing, so you need better rewards and different cups/formats.

Bottom line:

As GBL numbers drop, the zero sum nature of the rankings means that point thresholds for players to rank up will naturally become harder and harder to make. If this is not addressed more and more people will become disillusioned and stop playing!

Posted Jul 11, 2020, 8:08 PM UTC

22
aadiitLVL 40 TX, USA•

My vote for percentile cutoffs rather than some fixed threshold. Also need league based ranks rather than some universal rank

3
StormHHOP•

Totally agree about the individual leagues as well! Would make a lot of sense and would mean you can achieve the top rank in every league.

At the moment if you want to make rank 10 there is no real requirement to play until players start to approach 3000 (late ultra league). If you then get seeded low then you should if you are a rank 10 level player be able to climb quickly to the right level. Individual league ranks would remove this!

1