BKE then. Physical not ice.
Btw, they're both highly gear dependant.
Stigmata wise, you need their full set.
As for the weapon, they need both their signature ones, but SN can do fine (not exceptional, but fine) with Undine's Tale and some other scythes.
Icy lancer? If you mean BKE she's not Ice related whatsoever, if you mean any ice valk she doesn't have a lance.
The one in the shop rotation atm.
BKE then. Physical not ice. Btw, they're both highly gear dependant. Stigmata wise, you need their full set. As for the weapon, they need both their signature ones, but SN can do fine (not exceptional, but fine) with Undine's Tale and some other scythes.