khedOP•

To help figure out the U.S. citizenship status of every adult living in the country, the Trump administration has been accumulating driver's license information from states including South Dakota

9
PaulPara•

Sounds good, why not figure out citizenship? Would be sad if they matched to voting records and non-citizens were caught voting.

-13
[deleted]•

[deleted]

20
khedOP•

I think people worry about government overreach and privacy issues. Maine turned down a similar request:

Maine's Secretary of State's Office received several requests for the information in September but Secretary of State Matt Dunlap says giving the information to the federal government would be a violation of privacy.

"We sort of believe that the information that's in our databases belongs to the citizens to whom it refers. So we're the custodians of that information - it's not ours to give away," Dunlap says.

6
clone822•

I would trust good people with good intentions to give that a shot.

But we're talking about the likes of Stephen Miller.

2
Jazzspasm•

The whole part about saying you trust government A with this data, or that power, means you automatically trust government B with this data or that power.

The point being, you may trust the government today, so you five them extraordinary information and powers. Unfortunately, you don’t know who’s coming next, and although you might not trust them, you’ve already given them that information and power.

For example, the Dutch ran a census which collected an incredible amount of information - What religion people were, sure, but also their political views, along with their associations.

The Dutch people had a relatively benign government, by any measure, but what they hadn’t foresaw was that the Germans were about to invade.

So the Nazi’s are now in charge of the Dutch, and the Gestapo know if someone is Jewish, or a communist, or radical of some kind, and who their friends and neighbours are.

So they went and arrested them all and sent them to the death camps where they duly perished in horrendous circumstances.

That’s why you should only trust your government with the minimal information about you, with the most limited powers in order to do their job, and protect your privacy - because one day, the government might decide they want to kill you.

2
fjmj1980•

I thought hardcore MAGA patriots freak if the government tries to mine their data. Isn’t that deep state??

9
khedOP•

It's a conundrum easily solved through cognitive dissonance.

15
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
hamlets_uncle•

Beautifully phrased

2
PTC36•

It doesn’t require any cognitive dissonance. Citizens should have rights. Non-citizens should not have rights.

-8
khedOP•

How are you going to mine the data of non-citizens without mining the data of citizens at the same time?

5
Vickrin•

Isn't that against the US consitution?

2
the-wanky-wizard•

Golly gosh fuck trump.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1†
Gustav_Montalbo•

If you don't think that not knowing who is and isn't a citizen is a real issue I'm not quite sure you understand how countries work.

-12
[deleted]•

[deleted]

9
archamedeznutz•

So are you saying that it isn't a legitimate function of government to know who is or is not a citizen? It doesn't matter that there are things you think more important; I think lots of things are more important than car registrations yet my state dutifully tracks those. The status of dreamers or the relative contributions of illegal residents don't change that answer either. You're saying the only reason the government has for wanting to know who is or isn't a citizen is racism and that strikes me as more than a little histrionic.

-5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
FaiIsOfren•

the caravans!!!

2