Dropping chain under hard sprints (details in comment)
reddit.com/gallery/hu9tobPosted Jul 19, 2020, 10:44 PM UTC
Posted Jul 19, 2020, 10:44 PM UTC
Some of the teeth on your large front sprocket are shark finning and some aren’t. Not sure what’s going there. The small sprocket looks hardly used in comparison. Oh, Di2 is amazing!
Not sure what's up with the chainring teeth. I don't know how much I use each, but I wouldn't think it's particularly unbalaced. I do sprint exclusively in the big ring, but I wouldn't think that would be enough to grind the teeth. Easy enough to buy new ones anyway, and I'd rather be running 52/36 so maybe it's time.
Completely unrelated to this question/post, but I'm actually leaning towards eTap. I've always loved Shimano, but the option of having separate batteries is appealing. My current bike is a steel frame Masi, with no internal cable routing, which means I'd still have cables running all over my bike. Nothing wrong with that aesthetically, but I like the clean simplicity of no cables. I've also heard really good things about the SRAM app, and if I did drop the $$$$ for eTap, I'd probably get Quark so I can stop swapping pedals between bikes.
Or, I could just get an entirely new frame with internal routing and Di2 housing...
Ah... to dream :)
If you are sticking with your current frame, then totally agree that eTap is the way too go. If you are getting a new frame that is electronics ready then I would go with Shimano.
As the title describes, I've been dropping my chain under hard sprints. This would happen occasionally before, and I'd sometimes skip a gear under hard efforts, but yesterday it happened twice, back-to-back in the big chainring and smallest cog. It seems find under normal bursts of speed, climbing, or even short, hard accelerations, but when I gave it my all the chain dropped... twice :/
It's only been a few months since I had a shop do a professional tuneup including new chain and reindexing the gears. It was incredibly smooth after that, for a while. I had a slight problem with some shifting around the smaller cogs a month or so ago, watched some tutorials, and tweaked the indexing myself, and cleared it right up. Shifting has since gone a little bit off around the smallest cogs, i.e. sometimes there's a delay of shifting into the smallest couple of cogs, or I have to double shift and then it pops over. I do know how to fix this, but haven't really been all that concerned so far, and if rear derailleur pressure was causing this, you'd think it would be the other way around, e.g. pushing the chain a little too much towards the small cog, instead of away from it.
Chain line seems fine and chain appears undamaged (at least at quick inspection). The front derailleur is making no contact with the chain in this position. As the pictures indicate, the teeth are fairly worn down on one side of the big chainring. Not sure if that would be enough to cause this.
Thoughts?
[edit] Thanks for your feedback everyone--I think I found the problem. Rear derailleur seems to be bent outward causing the chain to be pulled off center on the front chainring. So much for my theory that "chainline looks okay." It looks okay with a slight pressure on the pedals, but not pedaling backwards or apparently under hard, sudden pressure. Going to try to straighten my derailleur hanger and/or adjust the rear derailleur to fix this.
The wear doesn't look bad. That shaping of the teeth is normal and not the result of wear.
From your description, it is unclear whether the chain is dropping from the chainring or the cassette. If it is dropping from the cassette, check your derailleur hanger for bending and check the limit screws on the rear derailleur.
It seems to be dropping from the chainring.
I think you're right. I was fiddling around with it a minute ago and the derailleur seems to be angled slightly, causing the chain to hit on the outside of the chainring. If I wind it around backwards really slowly, every few revolutions it misses and clicks as the chain drops back down onto a tooth. Not the same place every time, but just now and then.
Do you know if 105 derailleurs are adjustable to compensate for a slightly bent hanger. The hanger is part of the frame, so it doesn't appear to be replaceable. It's a steel frame so could probably be bent back, but I remember the bike shop telling me six months ago or so that it was bent and they already bent it back once. I don't want to weaken it and make it worse.
Also, any idea what causes a bent hanger? I haven't dropped the bike or banged it against anything (that I know of). Could this be a result of hard efforts straining the drivetrain?
Bending the hanger back or replacing it is the only fix that I know. Maybe you could install a claw adapter like this one parallel to the existing hanger, and use that instead?
Regarding the cause, I don't know either. The derailleur is normally not where the strain on the chain is located; pedaling hard should not put much strain on it.
How many miles on this chain?
Probably about 1000.
Rotate your crank backwards several revoluitions and see if your chainrings are true. If they're bent, then you have a possible culprit.
I am assuming you are dropping your chain from your chainrings. And not on the rear cogs.
It would help if you clear up what you mean by the chain dropping. Is it dropping from the big ring and to the outside and falling off your crankset? Is it dropping from your big ring onto your small ring? Is is dropping from the small ring and to the left onto the bottom bracket shell?
Yes--from the chainring. It's dropping from the big ring off the outside onto the BB shell.
I did what you suggested and I think I found the problem. The chainring seems straight, but the rear derailleur seems to be angled a little out, causing the chain to lang on the very edge of the big chainring teeth. If I wind it around backwards a bit, it skips every few resolutions as the chain catches on a tooth. It doesn't really do this forward, under pressure, but I'm assuming it's the same problem and under enough sudden pressure it pops off.
So, it looks like I either need to adjust the rear derailleur or try to bend the hanger back.
I have a theory, which I'll get to later.
But first, when you pedal forward, the chainring pulls the upper loop of the chain, which pulls the cogs themselves. So the derailleur being off a bit won't directly cause a problem with the chain engaging on the chainrings.
But if the casssette is worn or you have rear derailleur issues, it could cause the chain to skip, which gets much more prominent when you're sprinting hand. If this happens, it can be violent, causing you to drop the chain in front.
I say change out the cassette. If you're still having the same problem, you can still keep the cassette, which does need to be replaced every 2 or 3 times you change your chain.
I'm looking for an excuse to strip the 105 and go eTap or Di2. Don't tempt me ;)