LiamFVJMarket Socialist•

You know what, I kind of agree with this. A lot of black American organizations and public figures are super reductive about Africa. They'll talk about it as if its one country, one culture, as if theres some shared experience of what it means to be African. In reality there are 54 different countries in Africa, and over 3000 languages and dialects. If you asked a person from Africa where they are from they wouldnt say they were African, they would tell you the country they came from, or the cultural group they belong to. Just like how a person from Europe wouldnt call themselves European, they would specify which country or culture they came from.

There is no single shared experience among people who live on the African continent.

Edit: Plenty of white people do this too, but its not scrutinized when black people do it.

141
ILoveCavorting•

Look, sometimes Americans just want to reduce their “heritage” to easily marketable things.

Now as an American with Irish heritage I’m gonna go wear green and drink some Guinness

50
Last_Supper_Two•

I dont think you realize how much most of us irish hate "irish americans". Id assume the hate is similar to how africans might see hoteps.

28
ILoveCavorting•

Sometimes I want to read and learn more about the places my ancestors emigrated from, other times I want to bash my head into the wall when I see a “God invented Whiskey so the Irish wouldn’t conquer the world” shirt

22
Last_Supper_Two•

The classic

Yes my last name is Johnson

Yes I grew up protestant

My great great great great great etc grandad was irish, so im irish.

Aye. Feck off to those cunts

The "plastic paddy" is probably why the irish american identity is either thoroughly trashed by people with obviously miniscule irish ancestry, or is just completely non-existent anymore. Although its probably a good thing, there are upsides to complete assimilation.

12
depressedleftist•

Ireland is a singular, specific place with a specific culture (yes I know it has regional differences, but there's a more or less identifiably 'Irish' substrate, and they all speak the same language (well, two languages). Well, except Kerry, I guess: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jsUvcjk8J5c).

​

Whereas Africa is an entire fucking continent. They aren't just reducing to stereotypes, they're basically mashing a bunch of unrelated things together and laying claim to them. It'd be like an Asian American eating curry while wearing a chapan and holding a katana and claiming all of it is their heritage.

25
FistfullOfCrows•

It's like being White/European. There's a whole bunch of countries in Europe and people there mainly identify themselves as belonging to a nation and/or an ethnic group, not "being European".

2
VladithAssad's Butt Boy :cake:•

Irish people do be loving their Guinness though

16
Lasers_Pew_Pew_Pew•

Can confirm.

3
FistfullOfCrows•

Guinness is pretty good.

3
JohannesClimacoradical centrist•

Guinness is the third best stout in Ireland. I studied abroad in Cork so I prefer Beamish.

3
VladithAssad's Butt Boy :cake:•

What's #2?

1
[deleted]•

Akshually, not really! Most people in Ireland don't really drink Guinness, it's usually the older generation who used to. I remember hearing that Guinness was more popular in certain countries (can't remember which in Africa and in the Pacific) than in Ireland. In my experience, most young people don't drink Guinness and if they do, they stand out.

3
[deleted]•

There really is an element to ideas that you have to think about how they will play out on the lowest common denominator

Like I don't understand how t-shirt shops in beach towns with the absolute trashiest and lamest shirts stay open because I don't really have a handle on how many unintelligent people are out there

12
GepardenK•

Pretty much this. It's not more complicated than that.

This liberal cultural gatekeeping is conservative to the bone.

7
ironicshitpostr•

Don't forget to pick up an Armalite

2
[deleted]•

Just like how a person from Europe wouldnt call themselves European

I don't exactly agree with this. It's all about context. I call myself european all the time when it's relevant, when what I'm saying is general enough that it includes several fellow european nation or when I'm talking to people of other continents and don't need to be more specific.

So, I think it really depends. I see a lot of americans freak out about someone saying "european" at times where it's really not a problem. Some people love getting offended on others behalves.

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
Lasers_Pew_Pew_Pew•

Exactly, nearly all slaves taken to the Americas were taken from around the Nigerian and Gambian areas. The Arab slave trade was more North East Africa apparently.

1
TheSourGrapesIndependent Labour Party•

Arab Slave trade extended into the Congo.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congo–Arab_War

Yes, Leopold waged a war to end slavery while he raped the country.

3
TheIdeologyItBurnsUphold Saira Rao Thought•

That is why I am starting the white hotep movement. Join us

5
Low-Let-3806Other Left- posadist JOO•

nordicism is already a thing

7
TheIdeologyItBurnsUphold Saira Rao Thought•

Just me you varg and his autistic child riding around in a van in France. What a life

11
Low-Let-3806Other Left- posadist JOO•

being a jew who loves viking mythology and aesthetics is rough

8
AdmiralAkbar1Neo-proto-neocon•
3
cingan•

We don't have a unified depiction of Asians and Asian culture. Japanese, Koreans and Chinese are very different, let alone Indonesians, Filippino, Mongolian, Burmese etc. Same should apply to Africa.

3
Actual_JusticePronoun: "Many-Angled one"•

Wakanda forever!

2
SlayCapitalAnti-Socialist•

If you asked a person from Africa what they are they wouldnt say they were African, they would tell you the country they came from, or the cultural group they belong to. Just like how a person from Europe wouldnt call themselves European, they would specify which country or culture they came from.

There is no single shared experience among people who live on the African continent.

Id say that's reductive. Many people in both Africa and Europe (maybe also in South América and some parts of Asia) not only identify themselves with their country but also their region. In Europe there's EU for example, in Africa African Union, although I cannot say if they are comparable. But in any case even if each country is different from another, and can vary quite a lot, most if not all have a shared opposition to colonialism for example, and find shared struggles. You can see this in foreign policy for example such as their views on China vs the West.

-2†
LiamFVJMarket Socialist•

But thats on a political and diplomatic level, when speaking about individual identity people identify themselves on a national or cultural basis, not a continental or regional basis. Have you ever met someone who, when asked, identifies themselves as South American? No, they'll say they're from Brazil, or Venezuela, or Peru, etc. Same goes for people from countries in Africa, they'll say they're from Nigeria, or The Congo, or Somalia etc.

The only people who are identified and identify themselves on a continental basis are people from the USA.

16
[deleted]•

when someone asks me if I'm American I smirk and say "North American."

2
anti-anti-climacussquire of doubt•

you know, criticisms of aesthetic pan-africanism don't necessarily seem inherently id-pol to me. the language of "appropriation" certainly frames it that way, but the notion that a. africa is an incredibly diverse continent and b. the black experience in the US is quite different than in any location on that diverse continent... well, that's an anti-essentialist sentiment. this is itself the stupidpol critique of beyonce.

103
[deleted]•

The article also mentions that Disney isn't allowing streaming of this album IN AFRICA lmao

36
AorticAnnulusSocial Democrat•

And that Beyonce won't tour in Africa

23
lifesabeach13•

She's too tired playing paid gigs for warmongers and wmd manufacturers

13
Lasers_Pew_Pew_Pew•

oh yeah like who? I hate her, haha, I'm enjoying all of this.

3
Lasers_Pew_Pew_Pew•

Really why not? This is sooo funny.

1
[deleted]•

Some of the criticisms were very clearly about black capitalism in particular, and how it benefits wealthy celebrities and woke culture to homogenize the cultural image of africa in order to facilitate profiteering off its commoditized reimagination (as presented through "wakanda"-type shit).

I can certainly get behind that.

14
blouppOP•

That's fair, I just think it's weird because she's obviously not displaying it in an offensive way, she's trying to show its beauty. Carries the same energy as white people being cancelled for wearing a Native American dress or whatever. If they're fetishizing it, sure, that's bad. But I don't think propping up culture can be construed as bad in any way. This might be different because she's making mad bank from this but that just goes back to capitalism, lol

7
anti-anti-climacussquire of doubt•

oh absolutely. I'm not at all interested in moralizing beyonce, I don't think she's done anything wrong. I only mean that her aesthetic pan-africanism is revealing of an underlying essentialism. and I can sympathize with, say, nigerians, who don't want to be a mythologized prop for us racial politics.

the energy of cancellation is always weird. the letter of the critique seems right to me, but the spirit of it (let's moralize this american musician to death on twitter) is stupid and unproductive. it's always frustrating to see good ideas get lost in twitter hysteria.

27
AorticAnnulusSocial Democrat•

Beyonce has done plenty wrong. She's out there promoting feminism and a revolutionary aesthetic while her brand uses sweatshops in impoverished countries that are primarily staffed by women. Like all woke capitalists she is a massive hypocrite.

22

"Cult of Personality" - We can go with the song ( "I exploit you, still you love me"), or a strict definition.

​

I mean her followers are really called the "B-hive".

5
anti-anti-climacussquire of doubt•

Right of course. I just mean that the music/video isn't evil in itself.

1
depressedleftist•

Showing what's beauty? Africa? Like, all of it? A continent five times the size of the US?

​

I think the point of the criticism is that what she's trying to do is inherently fetishizing, even if she's not intending it to be. There is no singular African culture (there's also no singular US black culture; blacks in rural Mississippi are very different from cool cats in Harlem, which is also different from 'urban' culture in Baltimore).

​

Beyonce is what, eight, ten generations removed from Africa? Probably more? Chances are she doesn't even know specifically which culture or region the first Africans in her line to arrive in the US came from. Most black Americans can't trace that either. At some point the connection becomes so diluted that the attempts to identify with Africa can't really be called anything but cultural appropriation. On top of that, what they're identifying with is some fictitious 'generic Africa' that doesn't actually exist.

​

I remember when Black Panther came out and I read a review of it by an actual African, and his verdict was basically 'this movie clearly isn't meant for us'. What people like Beyonce are doing is offering up some stereotyped version of Africa for the consumption of American blacks.

11
MadeUAcctButIEatedItI will always reblog posts that call out kitten pic sharers.•

she's obviously not displaying it in an offensive way, she's trying to show its beauty.

This is what every white person says as they're getting cancelled for wearing a kimono or a bindi, or East Asians who have extreme tans and cornrows or dreadlocks, etc.

3
TheSourGrapesIndependent Labour Party•

"Ownstories"

By Beyonce telling someone else's story she has taken a job and success away from them.

Or something like that.

Also I personally do think African Americans fetishise actual African culture.

1
BakerNowitzkiBernard Brother•

Honestly after reading it kinda makes sense. It's like woke black nationalism where people worship the idea of Africa and being African. It's like the alt right fantasizing about the idea of "Europe".

20
MacV_writesReactionary :soy: Shitlord•

Thank fucking God. This is the uprising I wanted to see.

17
Lasers_Pew_Pew_Pew•

The African continent has entered the chat...

Africans joining in identity politics could be great for nipping this narc prick in the bud.

I love to see it.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

13
geoff-•

More accurately: A wealthy western business exploiting Africa for $$$

9
Lasers_Pew_Pew_Pew•

This is it right here. She does not care about Africans or her African heritage whatsoever.

3
OG_Sama•

This isn't idpol. This is rejection of a simplified colonialist attitude to race amongst the people practicing idpol.

Fuck man, thinking Africans and African Americans are the same thing and that this constitutes infighting is as idpol as you can get. There is no singular black culture.

6
Weltbraunder•

You can’t reduce us (Africans) to an ancestral land that you only evoke or tap into when you want to make art or make an argument or for whatever that essentialises and keeps us frozen. We are not your spiritual journey. Because some then go back to looking down on us. *ad break* —withPaballo

Shades of Barthes in 1957, writing about a magazine cover image of a saluting black soldier in French uniform:

The meaning will be for the form like an instantaneous reserve of history, a tamed richness, which it is possible to call and dismiss in a sort of rapid alternation: the form must constantly be able to be rooted again in the meaning and to get there what nature it needs for its nutriment; above all, it must be able to hide there. It is this constant game of hide-and-seek between the meaning and the form which defines myth. The form of myth is not a symbol: the Negro who salutes is not the symbol of the French Empire: he has too much presence, he appears as a rich, fully experienced, spontaneous, innocent, indisputable image. But at the same time this presence is tamed, put at a distance, made almost transparent; it recedes a little, it becomes the accomplice of a concept which comes to it fully armed, French imperiality: once made use of, it becomes artificial.

5
JohnnyElRedNaive European hoping for a socialist EU•

" Most comes from Black individuals, many of them of African heritage, "

I will translate that for you: Americans that no longer hold any familiar ties with their countries of origing, or even speak the language.

5
modelshopworld•

....and thats a good thing

3
toxicur1•

they're actually sorta right lmfao

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0