CMV: I shouldn't have to be willing to die for my kids.

A father sacrificing his life for his children is a common theme in stories. The act is praised by both the virtuous and the egoists. The virtuous just consider sacrificial behavior good, period. The egoists take into account the genetic and cultural lineage that is left behind my the dead father and say the father benefited from his own sacrifice.

I disagree with both schools of thought. The dead can't be virtuous. That one act is virtuous, but that's it. The father's virtuous actions stop from then on. I only see this as capping the total virtue. The alternative to live on and keep being virtuous will result in a higher total virtue. I am the source of virtue.

The dead also can't be egoist. How can I be egoist if my ego is gone? My consciousness is gone so what benefit is there to me to sacrifice my consciousness for someone else? I am not my genes or religion, I am my consciousness. If I am dead, then I cannot care or celebrate at the success of my ethnicity or religion resultant of my sacrifice. Posthumous rewards don't cause me to justify my actions, because the dead cannot justify anything. I am the end of benefits.

I know this will get a lot of hate, but all you need to do is show me how I can't gain more virtue and benefit by choosing to stay alive, rather than choosing to sacrifice. I can always make more kids if I'm alive. I can't always make more virtue/benefits if I'm not alive.

xd!

Posted Jul 23, 2020, 12:00 AM UTC

050
Loading comments…