Thoughts on Deep Space 9

I finished binging Deep Space 9, prior to this I finished TOS, TNG, and all the movies (this year was my introduction to Star Trek and safe to say, I'm hooked) That said, since I just started Trek a year ago, I don't think I have to nostalgia goggles for it yet so I have to say DS9 was easily the best of the 3 shows I've watched. By like, by a considerable margin. I'm suprised I don't hear more about this show while TNG is so iconic.

First of all the setting was amazing. The space station held several clashing and interesting factions of the Federation, Bajor, Cardassians, the Dominion, the Fergengi etc. There was so much tension and intrigue on. While I liked TNG, an issue I had with it was there was no real conflict on the Enterprise. TOS had McCoy and Spock at each other's throats, and Voyager has the Marcqui and Starfleet (sorta) at odds. Everyone on TNG got along perfectly fine 90% of the time minus maybe Doctor Pulasnki.

Next its easily the best cast I've seen in Trek. There's no real weak link. Sisko was great, tough as nails captain, Quark gave some color to the civilian section of DS9, Odo was great whenever he wasn't being emo af (sorry, he tested my patience a few times), Kira was a cool ex-terrorist the show (mostly) doesn't sugar coat. The secondary characters are amazing: Garak is my favorite character in maybe all of Trek and I really liked the Ferengi like Nog and Rom. Dukat, Weyoun, and Winn were great villains as well.

Also it managed to do more serious stuff while keeping to the core of the previous series: like we had the Dominion War, but we also got "Trials and Tribbulations", "Take me out to the Holosuite", that one Q episode, and "Visitor"

Naturally I had a few issues with it: sometimes it was so pre-9/11 it hurt (like the characters throwing a fit over taking a blood sample to check for changelings. I didn't love Sisko being half prophet either. Also the ending kinda ripped off the end of Lord of the Rings (I guess the end of the books since Return of the King movie hadn't come out yet I think...)

Otherwise great show and I dunno why its barely talked about.

Posted Jul 26, 2020, 8:15 PM UTC

6037
Mikhail_Mengsk•

DS9 is much praised by trekkers. It's not as famous as tos or tng among people, that's all.

25
osiset•

I literally just finished last night. It's the only series I didn't yet see.

I think it just didn't click with me years ago - I feel like the first couple episodes were not the best to capture me.

I gave it a shot a couple months ago and binged through it. What an amazing show, honestly the best series I believe. So many things going on that you wouldn't expect, lots of great episode spanning plots.

But what steals the show is the characters. Some of the best character development going on, you really grow with the characters, and their relationships with each other are so fine grained and interconnected.

25
Eurynom0s•

From all the conversations I've seen on here about this topic, the DS9 is probably mostly benefiting from working better as something you can binge than something you have to watch one week at a time, and is probably secondarily benefiting from getting a lot of new viewers who aren't caught up in the "but it's a space station, they can't even go anywhere!" hangups that a lot of viewers at the time got invested in.

5
kingdazy•

I absolutely love the series. It scratched an itch I'd always had, wanting to see more of the universe "at home," see what life is like for everyone not Boldly Going.

I also think it has the best theme song.

Be sure to give ENT a fair chance. It's surprisingly good.

14
PretenderNX01•

It's a darker show, so it's not as widely appealing as TOS and TNG are. I also think DS9 was ahead of it's time in how in depth they got with character development and serialized storytelling, which is more common in scifi now but in the 90s most shows hit reset at the end of the episode.

12
Eurynom0s•

DS9 is darker than TNG but it's not really grimdark for its own sake the way stuff like DIS can get ("yum yum"). It's more like, if TNG was showing us what a utopia might look like, DS9 was showing us how people have to actually fight to create and preserve TNG's utopia. I ultimately find it more hopeful than not given that it's fundamentally showing us that we CAN get to the utopia if we're willing to never stop fighting for it.

7
persistentInquiry•

I ultimately find it more hopeful than not given that it's fundamentally showing us that we CAN get to the utopia if we're willing to never stop fighting for it.

The Federation of DS9 is not a utopia. It's an imperialist military junta masquerading as a democracy, which uses genocide and ethnic cleansing as weapons of war while murdering and terrorizing dissidents and anyone else judged to be a "threat" via its secret Gestapo. There is nothing hopeful there.

1
Eurynom0s•

The Federation is still a utopia to most of the people living in it. We however got exposed to the fringes of it where the messy decisions got made. That's part of my point--the utopia doesn't just exist in and of itself.

You were also clearly never really supposed to be on board with Section 31 despite the portrayal of them being willing to get their hands dirty to keep everyone else's hands clean, unlike how they've been more explicitly built up as a necessary evil in DIS.

uses genocide and ethnic cleansing

If you're talking about trying to spread the genetically engineered plague to the shapeshifters, it's not like that was the FIRST thing they thought of. It was mostly a desperation move once they got backed into a corner where it looked like their options had been reduced to committing genocide or being genocided--FWIW, I've also always thought Picard was wrong to not transmit the geometric anomaly to the Borg, ESPECIALLY since his rationale was mostly about the Prime Directive...like, really? The Borg are the antithesis of the Prime Directive, and you can't get them to stop by smacking them in the face really hard like you can with the Romulans or the Cardassians. It was very clearly an all-or-nothing situation with them and I've never thought the Prime Directive was applicable given that there was clearly no middle ground truce with the Borg. Hence why Picard's characterization in First Contact has never super bothered me--it checks out that even the super-stoic Picard would finally snap over the absurd Borg situation he was being faced with given his PTSD over Locutus and probable guilt over having not stopped the Borg when he had the chance.

3
WoundedSacrifice•

I think the geometric anomaly would’ve had the same effect as Hugh’s individuality. It would’ve messed up 1 cube, but the cube would’ve been cut off from the collective to prevent the anomaly from spreading further.

1
Omegastar19•

Thats a rather extreme take. Its also very unfair - in order to reach those conclusions you would have to take a deliberately one-sided look at many aspects of Star Trek. For example: in order for the Federation to be a military junta, you would first have to show that Starfleet actually rules over the Federation. And no, one single example of a rogue admiral manipulating the Federation President is not enough, because incidents happen. Sure, when those incidents happen they damage the credibility of the Federation’s democratic credentials, but if these incidents are very rare, its clearly not a military junta.

3
The_Waltesefalcon•

DS9 is a solid show that I've always enjoyed. For some folks, like me, sticking all the action on the station and eliminating exploration for the most part kinda went against the grain of Trek. That's the only complaint I can come up with for the show.

10
birdlawexpert11•

That's why I hesitated to start in but I'm glad I did. I felt like they did a good job mixing in some stellar phenomenas though and the defiant was a nice touch but I get what you mean.

7
AnticitizenPrime•

DS9 is a solid show that I've always enjoyed. For some folks, like me, sticking all the action on the station and eliminating exploration for the most part kinda went against the grain of Trek. That's the only complaint I can come up with for the show.

But that simply isn't true. They explore the hell out of the Gamma Quadrant in the early seasons, which is what leads to the war.

People keep saying the show was 'stuck on a space station' but that's just wrong. There were plenty episodes about exploring via runabouts and that's what lead to the whole war arc.

DS9 was no less about exploration than any other show. The fact that it involved a stationary space station doesn't change that, it's merely the base where exploration begins.

3
Eurynom0s•

I agree with you, but I can kinda see why it thematically bothered the TOS and TNG diehards that DS9 was originally about letting the exploration come to them instead of going out and exploring themselves.

On the one hand, that sort of seems like splitting hairs, but on the other hand, the showrunners responded to those gripes by introducing the Defiant mostly just to give the crew an organic way to get off the station, so they clearly recognized that a LOT of people felt that way.

1
The_Waltesefalcon•

It seemed like more often than not the explorers were coming from the gamma quadrant and docking at DS9. I get what you're saying though, I guess I sometimes forget about those runabout episodes.

1

DS9 is the best Trek series. Best acting, stories, dialogue and characterisation.

The setting was poor imho though. I recall as a kid when it first came out - having a space station not based on exploration was weak. But it grew into itself, and by season four was a boss show.

9
RandothorOP•

I dunno I really liked the station. Seeing all the species clash was interesting. After watching two shows back-to-back on some version of the enterprise I was getting a little sick of the thing. And DS9 eventually got to have its cake and eat it too with getting the defiant

9

the setting to start off with was dull. that cost many viewers/

1
vagabond_•

a lot of die hard trekkers feel the same. To me DS9 is peak Trek. Almost literally- you have TOS where things were established but they were still getting their footing, then you have a bit of a dip with the animated series. Not really their fault, the budget was a major limitation on that. TNG started on shaky ground but famously 'grew the beard' and had a rise in quality in the second season onwards. To me, Star Trek as a franchise hit its best years right there when DS9 appeared. You had TNG on simultaneously and both series were very well written, and TNG passed the baton gracefully. DS9 already had 'the beard' in the sense of the early episodes being high quality, where the writers clearly had an idea of where they were going. Even some of the goofier, less necessary episodes (like "Move Along Home") still are deeply character focused and well written (at least, compared to some of the stinkers in other series) and serve the greater narrative being written. Voyager to me feels like a great setup with a poor follow through and while I'd argue the whole of Enterprise has some shaky footing, there's a sharp decline in quality in the series imo right about the time the 9/11 allegory takes over the narrative :/

Honestly Enterprise was the last series I watched all the way through, I don't have the money to dedicate to CBS' streaming service just so I can watch Star Trek. I'll catch up eventually. I've heard mixed reactions to Discovery and Picard, but generally they seem to be better regarded than ENT. I still have yet to hear anyone even disingenuously compare either to DS9 though.

8
RandothorOP•

Yeah I've heard mixed stuff on the newer stuff so I don't think I'll tune in unless I hear it gets better. I've watched a bit of voyager and I think it's decent.

1
WoundedSacrifice•

While I agree with most of what you wrote about the older series, I think that Enterprise is good. I believe that season 4 of Enterprise is 1 of the best seasons in all of Star Trek.

I wasn’t a fan of the 1st season of Discovery or Picard. Both shows tried to stuff too many plots into their 1st season. I liked most of Discovery’s 2nd season. Right now, I wouldn’t consider either show as good as Enterprise. On average, I’d say that the quality of Discovery‘s 1st 2 seasons was comparable to the quality of Voyager. Picard’s quality is worse than that. I hope that the average quality of each show improves. The improvement that occurred in Discovery’s 2nd season makes me optimistic that it’ll end up being a good show.

1
vagabond_•

Of course all of what I said is my personal opinion, but it is pretty common for members of the fandom to be very critical of Enterprise.

Personally I blame that godawful theme song.

1
WoundedSacrifice•

That theme song was definitely a major mistake and it’s probably the biggest reason for the criticism of Enterprise.

1
Skippy_the_Alien•

I started watching Star Trek too this past year! High-five! I'm nearing the end of Enterprise now. It's been a long road, getting from there to here. Haha sorry couldn't resist.

I totally agree with you. DS9 is MILES better than TNG. I liked TNG a lot when I watched it, but DS9 totally blew it out of the water. And my preference of DS9 was only further solidified when I saw the TNG movies which were all very underwhelming (maybe besides First Contact). I think the reason why fans love TNG so much was more to do with the on-screen chemistry of the acting ensemble, and the defining way characters like Picard, Data, and Worf were portrayed on screen. DS9 overall as a show was better, but the characters on TNG were a little bit more memorable

7
Eurynom0s•

I liked TNG a lot when I watched it, but DS9 totally blew it out of the water.

I feel the same way, and as I've said before, I feel like TNG has higher highs than DS9 (for example, can you readily cite what you feel like is the DS9 equivalent of Best of Both Worlds?) but that DS9 is way more rewatchaable...because a lot of TNG just honestly isn't that great if you already know what happens. And what DS9 lacks in singular BoBW-level high points, it more than makes up for on the fact that it's really hard to rewatch DS9 without suddenly finding yourself accidentally watching half a season because you got sucked into it, which I NEVER really experience when trying to rewatch TNG. ENT season 4, and to a lesser extent season 3, are the only other Trek seasons that really have that effect on me.

2
WoundedSacrifice•

can you readily cite what you feel like is the DS9 equivalent of Best of Both Worlds?

In what way? I’d say that “The Die is Cast”, “The Way of the Warrior” and the episodes with the major Dominion War battles had better action than “The Best of Both Worlds”. I’d say that there are some DS9 (and TNG) episodes that I’d consider better than “The Best of Both Worlds”.

1
Skyrious•

FOR CARDASSIA!!!!!!!

characters in this series were amazing.

4
basementvintage•

To me DS9 was more military sci-fi, STTNG more space operaish with Voyager more safari like.

4
Eurynom0s•

I've recently been watching some Voyager by just hopping around on whichever episode sounds interesting from the Netflix episode description and it really does work way better as the showrunners apparently intended--something you can just watch any random episode of without having seen any other particular episode--than something that you try to watch straight through. I quickly got REALLY frustrated with it trying to just go through it in order over how their intentionally thumbing their noses at continuity often made it feel like less than the sum of its parts, to the point where other than deciding to skip Shades of Grey, it's still the only series I haven't seen all of. But I'll begrudgingly admit that it DOES kind of work as something where you just hop around episodes without getting too worried about whether anything ever amounts to anything later on.

1
KevTravels•

DS9 is the best Trek. If you told me it inspired the creators of say 24 or Lost or even Game of Thrones, i would totally believe it. If it didn't have ST in the title, I bet it would have got serious emmy nominations.

4
choicemeats•

For me DS9 is both the character arcs I want and the light comedy I sometimes need. When I restarted it last week (I did a rewatch in late 2018 so it's sort of fresh) I thought about all the arcs throughout the show and how fleshed out everyone was, all the notes that show up along the way that become part of that journey, whether they planned it or not.

There's a lot of heavy drama in the show, especially exacerbated by the war, but also a lot of genuinely funny and clever moments and full episodes that were overall fun to watch.

Of all the shows its the most well-rounded, and to me has the least clunkers.

4
Caljuan•

What I love about DS9:

  • So many interesting fringe characters
  • The idea that Starfleet is ruthless when it needs to be (foreshadowing the Starfleet of PIC that was ruthless when it DIDN'T need to be)
  • The station setting allowing exploration of several cultures
  • Great experimental episodes like "The Visitor," "Far Beyond the Stars," and "Trials and Tribble-ations"

What I don't love:

  • Seasons 1 and 2 are real boring with neither a war to fight nor any boldly going
  • The emissary stuff (it was a crutch the show should've left behind)
  • Avery Brooks does a LOT of acting
  • Episodes between major Dominion War developments feel really inessential
3
Olthadir•

I quite like the emissary stuff. It was really interesting to have a rave that was heavily religious then to throw the Starfleet main characters their “pope”. The dichotomy of the position was really fascinating, especially because for the most part Sisko didn’t like being the emissary.

6
Eurynom0s•

especially because for the most part Sisko didn’t like being the emissary

And Sisko was all-in on Starfleet being borderline bigoted toward the Bajorans over their wormhole alien beliefs at the start of the show.

The first couple of seasons may not be PEW PEW EXCITING but it's also hard to imagine the show working without spending all that time laying the groundwork setting everything up.

5
MarcMercury•

I am just finishing my first sequential viewing of DS9 and I definitely like it more than I did previously. I still prefer TOS, but it might have passed TNG after watching both recently. Their hit/miss ratio with episodes is really strong, maybe the strongest trek show. After the nextgen movies were always a bit of a let down (even though I've come to like the first three to varying degrees) I always thought a series that followed the aftermath of the dominion war a bit more in depth than nemesis would have worked better.

3
violinha•

DS9 is my favorite Star Trek show. I like it darker tone. I watched it when it first aired and what again last year. I like it even more the second time around.

3
DoctorPaulGregory•

DS9 was always my favorite.

2