r/MagicArena•
j4ro

Why Wilderness Reclamation wasn't banned at June 1?

Discussion

Every time I look what is happening in the Standard and Historic I'm trying to find logical argument that justified this decision.

At June 1, all companion was nerfed and 2 cards was banned: [[Agent of Treachery]] and [[Fires of Invention]].

It affected all top tier decks (Winota, Lukka, Fires, Obosh etc.) leaves 2 archetypes untouched: Temur Reclamation and Jund/Rakdos Sacrifice.

  • Why Wizards favor some decks and decide that they are not deserve ban?
  • Everyone was sick of Nexus in Historic for a very long time. Why they didn't just ban Wilderness Reclamation everywhere and fix that problem as well?
  • How Wilderness Reclamation is worse then Fires? I tried to compare them but the enchantments are very much alike, it doubles your mana in the turn you've played it.
    • while Fires has advantage that allows you with 1 permanent on the board, to cast double spell next turn and still have mana to activate ability, Wilderness Reclamation has its own advantage - multiple instance stacks and fires does not. It also gives you some dead draws when play fires.
    • both Instant and Sorcery speed spells that enchantments allows can be an advantage and a disadvantage. Sure, you need to build your deck differently but it hard to tell that one of them is worse.
    • even CMC is the same
    • finally, Reclamation is uncommon, they does not even gives any wildcard for it

To make it fair, even if I love RB sac, some cards eg. [[Cauldron Familiar]] should be banned then as well.

Is this bans are chosen not based on facts but by feeling and believes? How they expect that rest of the top tier decks will not completely dominate the meta?

Posted Jul 28, 2020, 7:19 AM UTC

124
Loading comments…