Autotransformers, inrush current, and portable generators. (X-Post from /r/electricians.)
Hi! I have an oddball question about transformer inrush, generators, and creating split-phase power from single-phase. I'll try my best to keep it as straightforward as possible, but buckle in regardless because I need to set the scene first.
The Problem
My family's house is powered by a 4KW 48vdc to split-phase 120+120=240vac inverter. The house is wired for a single phase of 120vac so only the inverter's L1 and N are connected. Originally the house was powered by a single-phase inverter. The inverter has an integrated battery charger and transfer switch to simultaneously pass through an external AC source while charging batteries. The inverter allows user-defined current limits to avoid overloading smaller generators. No electrical grid is present.
We're very lucky to have such an expensive and powerful inverter, however, it will only accept split-phase 120+120=240vac input for charging and passthrough. Occasionally the weather is very poor for an extended period of time. During those periods we'd like to charge our batteries off a generator. We possess only a 2.5KW single-phase 120vac inverter generator and a 2.3KW single-phase 120vac alternator generator. Two companies manufacture autotransformers capable of, among other things, accepting 120vac on one end and outputting 120+120=240vac on the other end. Purchasing or building a new split-phase generator costs as much as a car and we wish to avoid this option, using an existing generator, as an autotransformer is much less expensive and adds versatility.
The Actual Question
I am concerned about the inrush current the generators would experience when energizing the autotransformer. Before the initial magnetic field develops, the transformer will potentially draw an absurd amount of inrush current depending on when in the AC cycle the connection is made. I'm concerned that this could have a number of undesirable effects:
- Inverter in Inverter Generator too sensitive and trips out due to perceived short
- Breaker in Inverter Generator electromagnetically trips
- Breaker in Alternator Generator electromagnetically trips
How valid is this concern? Neither company states inrush current for their autotransformers in their manuals or datasheets. I lack the experience with transformers to make an educated guess at how well one of these units and a generator would get along. Obviously we can't really afford to lay out the money and time pursuing this solution blind if it could easily not work and leave us back where we started.
Thank you so much for taking the time to read my novel. Me and my family would really appreciate any insight into this.
Posted Jul 29, 2020, 5:05 AM UTC · edited
Only the load consumes power. I don't know where you got that "Windings saturated" shit but it isn't a swamp cooler. Load shedding is the way around that. Don't run your dryer when you are on your genny.
Most breakers are inverse time delay, which is the pedantic way of saying "yeah that 20 amp breaker can hold 30 amps but only for a few minutes then it will nope out." or, more to your question. they can handle moderate spikes just fine. The "electromagnetically trips" portion of your question comes from the second fine feature of most breakers. If a significant current flow occurs usually from a direct short to ground (10,000 amps) the magnetic coil in the breaker will trip the lever and break the circuit.
Thank you for responding to my question! I'm not sure what you mean by "it isn't a swamp cooler." I'm aware of what one is, since people often construct them here, but I'm not sure what they have to do with transformers. We don't own a dryer. I don't know much about electric dryers but I believe they are all very large 240v machines due to the power required to generate a meaningful amount of heat in that situation.
Please correct me if I'm wrong, but as far as I'm aware, the primary of a transformer is more or less akin to a short circuit at the moment of circuit closure, then becomes progressively less like that as the magnetic field builds up. Don't some transformer systems have NTC thermistors or relay systems for "soft starting" them in order to avoid disruption to the circuit they're attached to? I've been previously informed by a few folks who possess autotransformers in the form of variacs that they will sometimes trip 20-amp breakers due to the inrush.
I've changed the wording to from "windings are saturated" to "initial magnetic field develops," as that phrase was poorly constructed.