Volume 9 Question

SpoilerQuestion

Can you guys explain the conversation between Hikigaya and Hiratsuka-sensei about emotions and calculating answers. Also what did Hiratsuka mean when she said Psychology is not always equivelent with feelings, can someone give me an example of this? Thank you in advance! Last of all, someone please marry her already!

Posted Jul 31, 2020, 3:15 AM UTC

86
DiaSolky•

Human emotions are not something you can calculate. People say things that are not rational. Even if you say something, it doesn't mean I'll understand what you meant.

3
DestroJordanOP•

If you can, can you give me an example of when you can't calculate human emotion?

1
AI0002•

There are moments in a conversation I can say something that would mean a nice thing, but to the other person I am talking to, it could mean a totally different thing and I shouldn’t expect a certain response. (This just made me realize that being nice can be irresponsible.)

1
AGN30•

Example, the easiest one would be "love". You know how it is, love is an illogical thing, that's why it can't be communicated through JUST words, this is only an example, Hiratsuka sensei wasn't neccesarily talking about love, and was only talking about basic human emotion.

1
YearofSilence201•

Here’s one way to look at it:

8man has been using “logic” and “reasoning” to explain other characters actions as well as his way to take action.

For example: 8man uses Komachi as his reason to stop Yukino from becoming president. Logically it makes sense. Komachi want to go to the same high school and wants to join the club and have Yukino and Yui as friends. So 8man decided to save the club for his sister.

Yui is a “nice girl”, therefore Yui interacts with 8man, talks to him, hangs out with him, etc because she is good natured. Logic.

These are the “calculated” conclusions 8man reaches.

However, he disregarded emotions for both these scenarios.

Yukinoshita WANTED to be student council president. And 8man did not want to lose his connection with the club and by extension, Yukino.

Yui is genuinely in love with 8man.

So the real conclusion would be:

8man used his sister as an excuse to take action and to make sure Yukino did not become president so that their club would not be affected. As a result he tramples over Yukino’s desire to achieve something, hurting her.

Yui isn’t just a nice girl, she can be selfish at times and decides to make the first moves romantically. She isn’t nice to him just to be nice. She is nice to him because she likes him.

Hope this helps!

2
DestroJordanOP•

Thank you very much!

1