Help debunking this vox article
While I was looking for the book, The End of Policing, I came across this vox article and at first I was going to just scroll past it and save myself the liberal brain rot, but I decided to check what they had to say about it.
Needless to say, the title was an immediate facepalm and the entire article is an exercise in enlightened centrism. But I find myself a little annoyed by the claim that increases in police funding are beneficial to society, I guess because I don't have the wherewithal to competently dispute it on its own terms. Help?
I get that policing is an inherently racist, classist institution—I just finished reading Are Prisons Obsolete? and I've listened to various anarchist audiobooks and essays— but I guess I'm still a little fuzzy on the details of abolitionist argumentation. Do we have statistical evidence that supports our solutions?
Posted Jul 31, 2020, 10:10 AM UTC
Eliminate material inequality, eliminate “crime” (the crimes the police “solve”)
I understand that logical formulation, but how does it bear out, statistically?
And certainly it's a little reductive to attribute all "criminal" behavior to wealth disparity? I guess part of my question is: do we have data that supports the effectiveness of restorative and rehabilitative justice?
[deleted]
No, it’s not reductive to attribute the criminal activity a capitalist society, that I live in, sets it’s policing after is all due to material inequality.
I think it’d be possible to eliminate most crime but also keep a few forensic scientists around to investigate whenever a violent crime happens. I seriously doubt that eliminating poverty would completely prevent every serial killer and every domestic abuse murder, but just because we’ll still need people to investigate those things doesn’t mean that those people have to be cops. The system of policing is an inherently broken one, but it is possible to build a better system where people who investigate murders have backgrounds in forensic pathology and false confession identification instead of backgrounds in murdering random Black people.
Greed is the cause of most criminal behavior.
I get that inequality is the cause for most of the crime nowadays, but how equality will totally terminate crime? How can it guarantee that people won't get greedy and steal from others? I'm not trying to prove you wrong I just wanna know how
How are you quantifying “most crime?” There are no guarantees in life. Cops and crime exist together already. What came first the crime or the cop?
"most crime" meaned almost all of them. I too agree that cops are ineffective in stopping crime, but I don't see how equality alone will stop it, if you explain that I'd be really glad. Thanks
By removing material inequality one removes the impetus to gain thru misbegotten means. However we choose to define them.
Edit: because the crimes of enclosure, slavery, colonialism and pollution aren’t investigated by the police yet have done “more” than all the street crime since Cain.
[deleted]