Open vs. Concealed Carry

Self Post

I've seen the back and forth arguments for both sides among civilians, but I'm interested in hearing from those in law enforcement (I hope this is the right subreddit to ask). I live in Virginia, and I carry with the mindset of "just in case, but I really hope to only ever pull this out at the range," with absolutely no "I wish someone WOULD test me" ego. I've seen arguments for OC being a deterrent, and OC making you a target. For CC not drawing attention to yourself, and for CC being "too late to draw now."

With the intent of carrying being the last resort protection of family/myself/others, in your experience/opinion as law enforcement, which option is better/safer?

Edit: Again, I appreciate all the professional feedback. On a related sidenote, it's been a bit eye-opening to see and think about the responses from law enforcement. Whereas I had seen many civilian "your average criminal is looking for an easy target, so OC will scare them off" opinions, that's not what I gather from you at all. You expect and prepare for the potential worst in people and face that possibility every day. Thank you all for what you do; stay safe.

Posted Aug 6, 2020, 3:33 PM UTC · edited · locked

4836
Blueonblack42LEO•

Open carry has one undeniable drawback--you WILL receive extra (and often unwanted) attention.

For that reason alone it's the inferior choice.

Some people, however, LIKE the attention that carrying their AR15 on their back into Wal Mart gets them. Those people are carrying for all the wrong reasons.

There is one thing you always know about the "it's a deterrent" folks---they've never dealt with the worst of society. They think that just because most crimes are crimes of opportunity that there aren't hardcore, evil people out there. These folks believe that if their gun is visible it will make criminals "think twice" about targeting them. They will never believe that their gun being visible actually makes them the first target of anyone dead set on committing a crime.

The added benefit of a person carrying concealed is that, in most states, it requires a license/permit. To get said license/permit you have to at least take some sort of course which involves topics like gun safety, when you can pull your gun, when you can actually shoot your gun and a bit of range time to prove that you can actually shoot your gun and hit what you're aiming at. It doesn't necessarily mean you'll make the best choices with your weapon, but it's at least SOME standard of training and education.

There is no standard for open carry. You can open carry just by being able to get your hands on a gun (legally or illegally, honestly). Nobody knows if you've been training on it. Nobody knows if you know when you can/can't point it at someone, much less pull the trigger. Everyone around you has to worry about you and it can create a panic (remember that unwanted attention I mentioned earlier?).

Open carry is just all around bad. Get a concealed carry license, keep your tactical advantage and avoid the unwanted attention.

67
Runyc2000Deputy Sheriff•

It varies by state. GA has a Weapon Carry Permit instead of a CCW. It is required for conceal carry or open carry of handguns (not counting vehicle, place of employment, or home). There is also no training involved, you just apply and receive.

12
Blueonblack42LEO•

You mean the same state that temporarily allowed teenagers with a driver's permit to get a driver's license without taking any sort of driving practical exam?

Color me surprised.

Then again, the governor just signed some pretty nice pro-police legislation so he can't be that bad, right?

And it's not like I can legitimately make fun of any other state....I live in Arkansas.

11
Runyc2000Deputy Sheriff•

We don’t talk about the DDS. We leave them alone and they leave us alone.

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

63
[deleted]•

I think that’s most of us. Like you said, not a lot of people walk around carrying thinking “I wish someone would...”. Personally speaking the only I have RHAT mentality is when I’m hunting... but that’s a different thing entirely n

14
GhettysDeputy Sheriff•

The deer is thinking the same, just you wait

15
LIGHT_COLLUSIONNot a(n) LEO / Unverified User•

The deer is thinking the same, just you wait

https://youtu.be/-WMb6InnZQY?t=76

5
GhettysDeputy Sheriff•

I was thinking more like this

https://youtu.be/uFJz2IMUeDE

7
Lonely-Investigator9Not a(n) LEO / Unverified User•

I’m an open carrier and I don’t even remotely have that mentality. I know very little who do, in fact. I prefer open carry to act as a deterrent. Nothing to do with testing people.

0†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

12
Lonely-Investigator9Not a(n) LEO / Unverified User•

See I can agree with this. It’s all preference my man.

3
VirogenicFawn21Gimmie dat boot daddy 😩 [Former LEO]•

I don’t understand the “I open carry as a deterrent” line of reasoning. All you’re doing is bringing attention TO yourself and painting a rather broad target on yourself if something were to happen.

11
Lonely-Investigator9Not a(n) LEO / Unverified User•

It doesn’t just bring attention to yourself. Who in their right mind would try to rob a place if someone there has a gun? Be observant and you avoid those problems you’re so worried about with open carry.

-1
VirogenicFawn21Gimmie dat boot daddy 😩 [Former LEO]•
10
SpaceforceinforceNot a(n) LEO / Unverified User•

The argument surrounding deterrence vs surprise nullify each other in my opinion. Both have some merit, but in the end its as stupid as a 9mm vs. 45ACP argument. I'll carry a 10mm and carry in the small of my back.

-1
VirogenicFawn21Gimmie dat boot daddy 😩 [Former LEO]•

If I’m a bad guy and I’m planning on doing something bad, and I see someone open carrying, that’s probably gonna be the first person I shoot. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

49
simplistic_autisticLEO•

and now you have two guns.

24
HKhatesyouNot a(n) LEO / Unverified User•

That’s what happened to Sean Collier.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

21
Bitt3rSteelPolice Officer•

Gotta flex that 100 dollah bill paint job, brah

17
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
Bitt3rSteelPolice Officer•

Mah glawk 40 problem solver

8
Mr_FrauncesRetired Fed•

Let's say you open carry. One day you're at the local Mom and Pop, drive up ice cream stand. Someone cuts in front of you in line and words are exchanged. You get your ice cream, get in your car and drive away. Meanwhile, the person you got in a verbal altercation with calls the police and says, "Some guy cut me off, I gave him the finger and he pointed a gun at me. It was a black semi automatic and he was driving a yellow Jeep, the license plate is.....". Now prove it didn't happen.

19
MoreBaconAndEggsNot a(n) LEO / Unverified User•

Well I mean I could be wrong but you don’t have to, they have to prove it did? The burden of proof lies on the state not the defendant?

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

18
OkRazzmatazz2991Not a(n) LEO / Unverified User•

Armed security guards in the big cities near me are frequently jumped or even shot so criminals can obtain another gun. If I’m carrying, I don’t want anyone to know until I use it.

8
CockBlockerNot a(n) LEO / Unverified User•

The phrase "The element of surprise" is something we all recognize for a reason.

8
PhoenixDaddyOPNot a(n) LEO / Unverified User•

Appreciate all the professional input. I hear the consensus loud and clear.

7
mmm_pbj_sammichFrom such a dumb state, he quit his job and fled (former leo)•

AR carryers are dumb and they know they're dumb and they aren't smart enough to figure out how not to be dumb. People who OC pistols comprise of a slightly bumped over circle of that Venn diagram.

5
[deleted]•

[removed]

2
MeowMixSongResident EDP: Not a(n) LEO•

I'm no LEO by any means, but I don't care how you carry your rifle/sidearm as long as it isn't pointed at anyone. Want to walk down the street OC, I don't care. Doesn't matter to me. Hell, I do with mace and several knives. I've only had to pull a knife on somebody once. They are mostly utilitarian.

1
N8WulfCommander•

A medieval mace?

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
DudeCalledTomNot a(n) LEO / Unverified User•

Conceal in most environments. Open carry in rougher neighborhoods for faster draw time and to deter potential criminals.

-10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

9