Tapestry Civ Balancing

I am aware that the approach to balance the civilizations thus far is to adjust VPs the beginning of the game. What I'm wondering is whether there is talk/a plan to publish a new edition that either rebalances them or incorporates the current changes into the game directly?

I searched, but couldn't find any discussions about this here or on bgg. If I missed it, apologies for the repeat.

Posted Aug 9, 2020, 1:02 AM UTC

424
FireStorm592Fire Tower 🔥•

There's an expansion coming later this year that will probably deal with the balance issues. Jamie is supposed to start releasing info on it in the next few weeks I believe.

8
tdcsf•

The slight balance changes are supposed to be published on the the back page of the expansion rules. I don't think that will be a permanent fix, but just a way to bring the non-connected people up to date. I imagine that there may be more balancing as more plays happen with the existing and new factions. I don't think he plans to publish a new edition at this point.

4
ShoitaanKingdom Death Monster•

Apart from the eventual 2020 expansion, there's no talks about a second edition with the errata changes. The reason being that the balance changes haven't been universally accepted as a fix like the ROOT changes. I think once a natural equilibrium is found we can talk new editions and upgrade packs.

3
Murraculous1Bitewing Games•

Realistically, the existing VP balance sheet will probably be tossed into the expansion. Or new Civ mats will be provided to replace the changed ones. It seemed like he had most of the expansion designed before any of the major balancing changes occurred, so I doubt it will change much of the core game if anything at all.

I expect simply more Civs and cards, but I’ll be pleasantly surprised if we get core improvements to the base game.

3
Dice_and_DragonsDescent•

If i am not mistaken the Tapestry expansion will be announced and detailed next week or so. I suspect we will get an answer then.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
Boardello•

Is Tapestry really so bad as to require homebrewing to balance?

I ask not as an argument but a genuine curiosity. Haven't played and I mostly heard negative stuff about it, suspiciously the same year people were huffed about not getting their copy of Wingspan sooner.

2
Murraculous1Bitewing Games•

It’s messy to say the least. Some Civs simply don’t have as high of a point potential. Combine that with dozens of other luck-based factors (tech cards, tapestry cards, dice rolls, etc.) and you’ll end up with players that are hundreds of points apart.

The game provides no substantial way for players to interfere with each other’s plans, so there is no way to balance things out through player interaction. On top of that, some of the Civs are pretty lame-feeling to play compared to others. Some of the actions on the board are just awful compared to the other tracks. With enough plays, it becomes clear that Tapestry needed a lot more time in the oven.

9
dannyluxNstuffTzolkin•

I get all the knocks about the game but I still find it very fun to play. We don't play it super often which is probably why the balance issues haven't bothered us much. We now play with the new civ balancing bit despite all the flaws, which I don't disagree with, I find the overall experience enjoyable. I will admit theme isn't that important to me in games, as it is to many people but just my two cents.

1
Murraculous1Bitewing Games•

I agree that it provides a lot of fun despite its flaws, which is why I haven’t wanted to get rid of it until very recently. My biggest gripe with it is that it can often last up to 3 hours with certain groups and that is way too long for a game with this much luck. And like I previously mentioned, the variance in how fun each individual play is far too wide and dependent on which Civ you get and which tracks you pursue.

Also reaching the end of most the tracks is super anticlimactic. The military track end frequently results in drawing a useless Civ. The science track end is highly contextual in how useful it is. The tech track end feels like a blah way to milk a few more points.

1
dannyluxNstuffTzolkin•

Yea. 2 player with a shadow civ is probably the best way to play. Goes much quicker.

1
flyliceplick•

In short, yes.

7
NocturnalAllen•

No, the update has been posted for half a year or more. Just print out the sheet and you're good to go.

3†
Dogtorted•

It depends on what you’re looking for out of the game. If you look at each play as a fun, tactical exercise in what you can squeeze out of your faction it’s not a big deal. If you care about balance and want a more strategic game then it’s an issue.

3
kerredSure, i'll Negotiate...•

Terra Mystica uses balanced VP as well on the base map based on tournament play. Darklings get -5 points, Fakirs get +13 points i think when not using the auction variant.

I think the difference though is Tapestry has more random elements, meaning you can steamroll if you are lucky enough to get cards that synergize your civ's bonuses. Civ 5 is an example of this when you start as Spain and the RNG Gods put El Dorado next to your starting point.

2
lunatic4ever•

Tbh for us it’s such a casual gaming experience that we’d never play it seriously competitively anyway. In short, I never noticed imbalance because we play it for fun and sometimes some Civs and combinations allow you to do crazy things but for us that’s part of the fun

0†
Hogesy05•

I only just got Tapestry and will be playing it solo so I guess balancing doesn't matter to me. But in saying that if there were so many balance issues, Jamey needs to sack his playtesters. My gut feeling is they are all such fans of SM that they aren't ruthless enough in the feedback. You need people who never really play SM games or you don't tell them who the publisher is etc so not to bias the playtests

2
ErikTwice•

It's very unlikely that the playtetesters didn't give enough feedback. It's much more likely, like it has happened countless of times, that the designer did not take the playtesters seriously and chose not to implement balance changes.

5
Dogtorted•

I suspect it’s a bit of both. I don’t think diehard SM fans are the best playtesters of SM. You really need testers who can go in blind without bringing any bias and baggage along with them.

Some of the most vocal online defenders of Tapestry’s balance issues were playtesters. They refused to even entertain the possibility that the balance was off.

8
patches411•

Playtesters can be genuine and give critical feedback. Stegmaier is pretty clear that he doesn't just want praise when he talks about ideal playtesters. Guessing he would stop asking them to test if they did that.

The problem really becomes that you have 16 asymmetric factions. Even with him listening to a ton of playtester advice, he can't emulate the amount of times some people bury themselves into games. Adjustments get made in plenty of games post production; for some reason people got more upset over this one.

1
Jasonred2•

I think putting out the tapestry cards in a similar-to-tech card sort of draft would help alleviate some of the wild "swingyness". But I haven't tried that (but have been meaning to), has anyone else tried that?

2
AgentDibThrough The Ages•

One issue with that approach is trap cards form a key part of the game's military aspect. Any form of draft would spoil that information. Taking two tapestry cards and choosing one to keep each time could accomplish a similar objective without that problem.

Another option would be to rework the trap cards; which I don't particularly care for in the first place.

2
patches411•

Jamey has mentioned in livecasts that there will not be replacement civ mats, however there would be a list of adjustments in the expansion. I'm guessing it isn't cost effective to replace them when it is mostly a matter of adjusting VP.

As others have said, he'll start leaking more official info on Wednesday.

2
Mr___Perfect•

FYI - The expansion announcement will be this upcoming Wednesday, or at least parts of it will trickle out starting Wednesday. Worth it to wait and see whats in there. I would be SHOCKED if they didnt include some replacement faction cards

1
RevKrisOP•

I guess this is good timing then.

1