Why the idea of social bubbles might need to be re-evaluated
cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/social-bubble-reeva...Posted Aug 10, 2020, 4:30 PM UTC
Posted Aug 10, 2020, 4:30 PM UTC
Great in theory, but as they point out in practice it falls apart quickly. Reminds me of this article by an epidemiologist https://www.wbur.org/cognoscenti/2020/04/03/hold-the-line-coronavirus-jonathan-smith .
" You should perceive your entire family to function as a single individual unit: If one person puts themselves at risk, everyone in the unit is at risk. Seemingly small social chains get large and complex with alarming speed. If your son visits his girlfriend, and you later sneak over for coffee with a neighbor, your neighbor is now connected to the infected office worker that your son’s girlfriend’s mother shook hands with. This sounds silly, it’s not. This is not a joke or hypothetical. "
i think it was easier to maintain these "bubbles" when everyone was locked down back in March/April. No one was going anywhere, so outside contact for everyone was minimal. But now many ppl are out shopping, paying visits to relatives, running errands, patronizing salons/nail/barbershops, even outdoor gym classes. Unless everyone inside one of these "bubbles" agrees to go back into quarantine and basically be under house arrest again you can't be assured that you're safe.
[deleted]
Smart choice.
I already don't know how to reconcile how to handle this in an individual household, let alone a social bubble. Sure, during lockdown, household members could all quarantine together. But once people in the household start going to work or school? How do you handle that situation safely besides isolating everyone who is going out into the world? The social bubble increases this risk exponentially.
" You should perceive your entire family to function as a single individual unit: If one person puts themselves at risk, everyone in the unit is at risk. Seemingly small social chains get large and complex with alarming speed. If your son visits his girlfriend, and you later sneak over for coffee with a neighbor, your neighbor is now connected to the infected office worker that your son’s girlfriend’s mother shook hands with. This sounds silly, it’s not. This is not a joke or hypothetical. "
https://www.wbur.org/cognoscenti/2020/04/03/hold-the-line-coronavirus-jonathan-smith
Exactly. With some householders needing to go to school/work still, I'm questioning whether I should move out into my own space.
You have your answer. By definition, if a member of the household is going to work or school, that household can't be part of a bubble.
I understand the concept, what I am struggling with is the entire process of deciding how to handle this and what living system to implement in my life/household now. Just knowing that it's no longer a bubble doesn't really make a decision for me on what practical changes to make, if any
In June, the Ontario government announced it would allow social bubbles of up to 10 people.
That meant if you lived in a household of five people, you could mutually agree with another family of five to be in contact with them — no masks or physical distancing required.
This is article is pro-mask, pro-science by the way.
Yeah this probably works. In a perfect world. Where no one interacts with extended family ever and everyone follows the rules and doesn't make exceptions for all the times when social distancing is awkward so they just go along with the situation.
This is so profoundly stupid. Making the simplest thing in the world into a math problem isn't going to increase compliance or reduce risk.
The virus does not give a single fuck if you were in an agreement to be part of a safety bubble. Stop trying to rules lawyer viruses.
It's a way for anti-maskers to shift public opinion. They seriously don't understand that this will kill people. They just don't get it.
It's a way for the oligarchy to shift the blame onto idiots who have been propagandized.
Ahh yes blame shifting is a classic narcissist tactic.
The dumbest thing I saw had to do with guidance for a school where kids had to self-isolate for 14 days if they were in prolonged contact with someone who tested positive. Where 'prolonged contact' was defined to be 15 minutes in close proximity.
A person was like, "What if we just had the classrooms switch all the seats around every 14 minutes so we never had someone around the same person for more than 15 minutes."
That's right children. You can outsmart viruses through an elaborate game of musical chairs
🙃
It's a fool-proof plan!
[deleted]
It's not quite as crazy as you think. It's all about viral load. Think "death by 10000 paper cuts" instead of "one bullet to the brain and you're dead". It is thought (though clearly we're still learning) that short term contact will not be enough viral load to catch the virus (or if you catch it, it will be less serious). Musical chairs probably would help reduce the likelihood of one person getting sicl. Unfortunately it will also increase the risk for a bunch of people. And it's cumulative, so if you have to sit by the person a 2nd or 3rd time, it's really been 28 or 42 minutes.
It's a virus that loves groups of people. All groups.
So avoid all groups whenever possible, and minimize the amount of time that you do spend with them.
The bubble concept doesn't make any sense at all. The last thing that anyone should be doing is looking for excuses to increase the numbers of people with whom they spend time. Every new contact is another potential mechanism for spreading infection.
So avoid all groups whenever possible, and minimize the amount of time that you do spend with them.
Not possible.
Can you imagine if a beehive tried to enforce a lockdown in response to a virus going through its members? The entire colony would be dead in a day. Obviously, humans are not bees, but like bees, humans have a fundamental need for genuine social interaction - emotionally and psychologically (by extension, physically), and materially (in our supply chains, which everyone seems to take for granted and whose ripple effects will be worse than the virus itself). Any public health policy which relies on nearly the entire population practicing abstinence from normal human contact is medievil shit.
But this is reddit - the only solution is total isolation forever.
If this generation had to fight in WWII, we would all be speaking German.
Such weakness. No resolve, no willingness to buckle down and do the right thing.
Not exactly. We spend a lot of money on weapons and like to blow shit up.
Actually world war2 was better because a) we had people to shoot and b) it was actually a fairly social thing, which strengthened social bonds (a natural human connection) between soldiers, support around the military, and the war at home.
So let’s stop with the world war 2 comparisons!
This is true, we lack the resolve to face and survive a pandemic that's closer the order of those that have hardly phased us before ('57 + '68). We expect society to give us a guarantee that we won't be exposed. We're so obsessed with technocratic solutions and so used to controlling nature and having it go our way, that we can't accept our place in nature. We're willing to sacrifice our youth and mortgage our future in a feeble attempt to save the elderly and infirmed.
Nazi Germany was an existential threat to the world. Covid-19 is an existential threat to no nation.
COVID-19 is more akin to the Spanish influenza pandemic than to anything else since then.
Downplaying it has produced 160,000 dead Americans, with a lot more to come.
The bubble concept doesn't make any sense at all.
Bubbles make sense if you maintain their integrity. The NBA and NHL bubbles are large-scale versions of the concept that (thus far) seem to be working. The problem is that it only takes one person in a bubble to destroy that integrity.
So I guess you might be correct in that human beings don't seem capable of maintaining strict bubbles on a scale large enough to have an impact.
"Three can keep a secret if two are dead."
That applies to these situations. Most people just can't be trusted.
Those who are eager to form "bubbles" are the same types of people who are bound to slip up. Give them an inch, and they'll take a mile.
The bubble concept doesn't make any sense at all.
It worked really well for NZ, but that was in conjunction with lockdown. The original idea of the bubble was for getting through the lockdown period - you had to preemptively decide who you were going to spend lockdown with (your household bubble, or if you lived alone, you could join someone else's' bubble). It was not for the period after lockdown, that wouldn't work.
You're only as strong as your weakest friend
Did bubbles even have a published study behind it before it was rolled out?
From watching my friends, I think the idea of the bubble could work if it was really just you and another family.
The problem is that people are forming multiple bubbles and not realizing how many other people they are exposing themselves to. Instead of just family A and family B interacting, Family A is hanging out with family B, but also interacting with families C and D, while family B is also seeing families E, F and G. But they think they’re being very safe and still “bubbled”. In reality, the bubble now has 7 families in it and isn’t even close to being a bubble because families C-G are also interacting with other people.
It's like the STD/HIV/AIDS psa from the 90s: when you sleep with one person, you're sleeping with everyone that person has ever slept with, and everyone those people have ever slept with.
Exactly. And my friends logic is “I’m only hanging out with 4 other people at a time”, but it’s a different 4 people everyday. I don’t even bother trying to educate them anymore, I just stay home or interact with the ones that do get it and are willing to be responsible (we meet outside, use masks, and distance).
I do think that if you can keep the bubble small enough, tight enough, and spread out over time, they're a good thing to have.
Then there are the people that were on Maury. "#97, you too, are not the father..."
Yeah. It’s just a false bubble at that point.
The bubbles can still be useful, even if you are indirectly linked to 100 other bubbles. It's all about the growth. As soon as someone tests positive, you can pass word in your bubble and hopefully they share with their bubbles.from the time someone tests positive, the virus may have spread 2 or 3, or maybe even 4 generations. If everyone has 2 other families in their bubble (and each of those families has 2 other families), then you are talking 2 or 4, or maybe even 8 families that need to be notified. If everyone has 10 families in the bubble, now you are talking about 100 or 1000,or maybe even 10000 other families affected. One is manageable. The other is not.
It's not a guaranteed protection for yourself, but it does provide some level of protection and a value to society to be able to get ahead of the outbreaks a bit faster.