Voting manipulation on Microsoft Open Source thread on r/programming? Or are people clueless? Or something else?
TLDR: Without sounding paranoid, I noticed weird patterns of downvotes in a recent Microsoft thread about open source. Are people just believing that Microsoft is now one of the 'good guys' because they open sourced PowerToys and Windows Shell? I grew up in an era where Microsoft would relentlessly and often illegally choke or buy all competition. Am I out of touch?
Earlier today a post on Microsoft's Open Source effort took off over at r/Programming. I couldnt help but notice a disturbing trend where seemingly reasonable posts questioning were heavily downvoted.
Here are a few examples:
- At -26 right now:
Nothing they own that really matters is FLOSS. Windows, Office, Active Directory, Server and all the compatibility/interoperability that would actually free the world. Everything else is just a way to get developers (developers developers) mind share, control, collect your data and / or get the community to help them maintain their software. Not to mention patents.
- Other example. Maybe not the best comment ever written, but got me to chuckle. Does it deserve 28 downvotes?
Wow, embracing and extending, this is great! Can't wait to see what comes next!
- My own post was making fun of MS's decision to feature PowerToys and Windows Shell over other MS initiatives like TypeScript and VS Code, also downvoted.
There are many others. Thoughts? Are those just Microsoft employees or fanboys, or am I out of touch on this? Most downvoted posts are downvoted by almost the same amount, making me think of some kind of concerted effort. (they were all at -15 earlier, now hovering around -28)
Posted Aug 14, 2020, 3:32 AM UTC · edited
Just as a counterpoint, the 5 most downvoted posts on that thread are all just variants of an eee joke. I think people are just finding that as unnecessarily hostile and not adding anything to the discussion.
The fact is that Microsoft is doing a lot better for the open source community than they have done previously, and I'm not saying it makes up for their past actions but being unwilling to give them a chance doesn't really help the discussion. Also Reddit in general will downvote anything the don't agree with unless you go out of your way to be extremely diplomatic, which I don't think most of those posts were.
Right, but what you’re saying is “3 open source projects is way better than 1” when all the other companies involved are up to hundreds of much more important and significant contributions.
You seem to be completely missing the point - Microsoft deserves a big kick in the ass for being a computing mega giant for three to four decades now and only open sourcing a few inconsequential tools and “mono” - the worst possible way to code on Linux.
The fact is that there are smaller, newer companies that hit a bajillion times higher on the FOSS scale than their own weight class. Microsoft is the exact opposite of that. They deserve to be absolutely hated by FOSS enthusiasts, even still. It’s not even funny how much more open stuff even Apple has released than MS.
I think the worst part is that MS has never had a unique product go profitable for them. They dip their proprietary toes into markets other companies are already rocking and usually fall right on their face. If they hadn’t started cloning AWS, they’d be bankrupt by now. Hell, Microsoft alone has done more damage to Android OEMs and Open Source solutions than any other entity. Sued any OEM using it so it can’t be “free” free. Used bullshit FAT (proprietary) storage IP claims.
They open sourced .net core and vscode. Both pretty big projects.
Sure, just to get more developers on windows.
Both are cross platform.
There are hundreds of projects on there. You are only looking at the landing page. I fact, there are 3.5k repositories on https://github.com/microsoft. I’m not sure where you are getting your information.
Even if Typescript was their only OSS project, I'd say it's a pretty big deal. It doesn't lock you in to anything Microsoft specific and its adoption and usefulness is super high. Everyone complaining about Microsoft's OS contributions feels like a "fool me twice, shame on me" situation. Corporations aren't static, as the leadership and employees change, so can the goals and strategies of the company.
At this point, I'm much more worried about Google's OSS projects, as they better seem to fit the first 2 points in the EEE pattern. With Chromium they continue to add the kitchen sink of features as web apis, which makes it pretty much impossible to make another fully compliant browser. Ten they have this trend of releasing overly complicated tools based on something internal (but not actually used internally) to help drive gcloud adoption (see k8s, istio, opencensus, grpc). Sometimes they're useful, but a lot of devs see something shiny from Google and decide they must use it because "that's how Google does it". Then of course gcloud has the best support for those tools, so you might as well pay for the managed service that makes life easier.
Yeah. It's not a joke tho...
People typically refuse to discuss microsoft and open source, I certainly don't see microsoft joining in with discussions or answering any of people's concerns or making any credible commitments about the future. Have microsoft formally apologised for their past behaviour and made any commitments about their behaviour in the future?
What parts of open source do microsoft like and not like? Do they help fund any open source projects that aren't their own? Or do they only support projects of their own?
Do they release some of their products open source for reasons other than trying to maximise market share in some areas?
Surely you acknowledge that there's lots of microsoft fanboys who doenvote any attempt from folks to ask these sorts of questions?
Apparently bill gates is also some kind of visionary for predicting pandemics will affect humans again at some unknown time in the fuure, i mean derr given the population size and increased connectivity with international travel becoming more widespread.. also can't educate younger folks about how bill gates managed to amass so much wealth without fanboys vilifying people for not just blindly siding with microsoft having changed..