Voting manipulation on Microsoft Open Source thread on r/programming? Or are people clueless? Or something else?

TLDR: Without sounding paranoid, I noticed weird patterns of downvotes in a recent Microsoft thread about open source. Are people just believing that Microsoft is now one of the 'good guys' because they open sourced PowerToys and Windows Shell? I grew up in an era where Microsoft would relentlessly and often illegally choke or buy all competition. Am I out of touch?

Earlier today a post on Microsoft's Open Source effort took off over at r/Programming. I couldnt help but notice a disturbing trend where seemingly reasonable posts questioning were heavily downvoted.

Here are a few examples:

  • At -26 right now:

Nothing they own that really matters is FLOSS. Windows, Office, Active Directory, Server and all the compatibility/interoperability that would actually free the world. Everything else is just a way to get developers (developers developers) mind share, control, collect your data and / or get the community to help them maintain their software. Not to mention patents.

https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/i955fl/microsoft_launches_site_dedicated_to_their_open/g1doide?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x

​

  • Other example. Maybe not the best comment ever written, but got me to chuckle. Does it deserve 28 downvotes?

Wow, embracing and extending, this is great! Can't wait to see what comes next!

https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/i955fl/microsoft_launches_site_dedicated_to_their_open/g1dl1wb?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x

​

  • My own post was making fun of MS's decision to feature PowerToys and Windows Shell over other MS initiatives like TypeScript and VS Code, also downvoted.

https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/i955fl/microsoft_launches_site_dedicated_to_their_open/g1e0l8a?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x

There are many others. Thoughts? Are those just Microsoft employees or fanboys, or am I out of touch on this? Most downvoted posts are downvoted by almost the same amount, making me think of some kind of concerted effort. (they were all at -15 earlier, now hovering around -28)

Posted Aug 14, 2020, 3:32 AM UTC · edited

12061
0101010001001011•

Just as a counterpoint, the 5 most downvoted posts on that thread are all just variants of an eee joke. I think people are just finding that as unnecessarily hostile and not adding anything to the discussion.

The fact is that Microsoft is doing a lot better for the open source community than they have done previously, and I'm not saying it makes up for their past actions but being unwilling to give them a chance doesn't really help the discussion. Also Reddit in general will downvote anything the don't agree with unless you go out of your way to be extremely diplomatic, which I don't think most of those posts were.

48
seraph582•

The fact is that Microsoft is doing a lot better for the open source community than they have done previously

Right, but what you’re saying is “3 open source projects is way better than 1” when all the other companies involved are up to hundreds of much more important and significant contributions.

You seem to be completely missing the point - Microsoft deserves a big kick in the ass for being a computing mega giant for three to four decades now and only open sourcing a few inconsequential tools and “mono” - the worst possible way to code on Linux.

The fact is that there are smaller, newer companies that hit a bajillion times higher on the FOSS scale than their own weight class. Microsoft is the exact opposite of that. They deserve to be absolutely hated by FOSS enthusiasts, even still. It’s not even funny how much more open stuff even Apple has released than MS.

I think the worst part is that MS has never had a unique product go profitable for them. They dip their proprietary toes into markets other companies are already rocking and usually fall right on their face. If they hadn’t started cloning AWS, they’d be bankrupt by now. Hell, Microsoft alone has done more damage to Android OEMs and Open Source solutions than any other entity. Sued any OEM using it so it can’t be “free” free. Used bullshit FAT (proprietary) storage IP claims.

13
KernowRoger•

They open sourced .net core and vscode. Both pretty big projects.

9
drzmv•

Sure, just to get more developers on windows.

1†
KernowRoger•

Both are cross platform.

9
dankydooo•

There are hundreds of projects on there. You are only looking at the landing page. I fact, there are 3.5k repositories on https://github.com/microsoft. I’m not sure where you are getting your information.

8
apentlander•

Even if Typescript was their only OSS project, I'd say it's a pretty big deal. It doesn't lock you in to anything Microsoft specific and its adoption and usefulness is super high. Everyone complaining about Microsoft's OS contributions feels like a "fool me twice, shame on me" situation. Corporations aren't static, as the leadership and employees change, so can the goals and strategies of the company.

At this point, I'm much more worried about Google's OSS projects, as they better seem to fit the first 2 points in the EEE pattern. With Chromium they continue to add the kitchen sink of features as web apis, which makes it pretty much impossible to make another fully compliant browser. Ten they have this trend of releasing overly complicated tools based on something internal (but not actually used internally) to help drive gcloud adoption (see k8s, istio, opencensus, grpc). Sometimes they're useful, but a lot of devs see something shiny from Google and decide they must use it because "that's how Google does it". Then of course gcloud has the best support for those tools, so you might as well pay for the managed service that makes life easier.

5

eee joke

Yeah. It's not a joke tho...

2†
qu83rt•

People typically refuse to discuss microsoft and open source, I certainly don't see microsoft joining in with discussions or answering any of people's concerns or making any credible commitments about the future. Have microsoft formally apologised for their past behaviour and made any commitments about their behaviour in the future?

What parts of open source do microsoft like and not like? Do they help fund any open source projects that aren't their own? Or do they only support projects of their own?

Do they release some of their products open source for reasons other than trying to maximise market share in some areas?

Surely you acknowledge that there's lots of microsoft fanboys who doenvote any attempt from folks to ask these sorts of questions?

Apparently bill gates is also some kind of visionary for predicting pandemics will affect humans again at some unknown time in the fuure, i mean derr given the population size and increased connectivity with international travel becoming more widespread.. also can't educate younger folks about how bill gates managed to amass so much wealth without fanboys vilifying people for not just blindly siding with microsoft having changed..

1
Kiutsunee•

You can't expect anything from r/programming tbh. I bet not even half of that sub are programers and most likely they are just pc afficionados and python newbies.

45
Coz131•

Gotta try asking the same question in r/Linux or something.

15
Headpuncher•

A fair few of the linux subreddits I sub to have gone to shit in recent times.

There are entire threads where people ask a question and the answers are all along the lines of "choose the same distro I use", or just flat out avoid answering the question.

I like that people want to join the discussion and help, but there are a noticeable number of new-to-Linux users who are just muddying the waters and have no actual expertise to offer.

And if one more person asks "i want to use a web browser, what distro should I use?"....

I know, it's just noise, filter filter.

11

Really? The Linux subs routinely offer some of the best answers to noob questions of any sub I’ve seen. I am continually amazed at how willing people are to take time to meticulously explain things to the ignorant.

2
Headpuncher•

And I'm not claiming otherwise. But the amount of useful answers at the top of a thread is often drowned by the number of "install Arch/Tails/Elementary" answers that don't even have relevance to the question asked.

Believe me, I've answered some of those questions, and asked them more.

2
aussie_bob•

The highest rated post in almost every submission of consequence in r/Linux will be critical of Linux and/or FOSS software in general.

I commented in the r/programming thread we're discussing about the obvious influencer activity, and unsurprisingly it's a highly controversial comment.

Which in itself is surprising given that every major company employs armies of influencers for just that purpose. Also especially ironic given Microsoft sell a product to do exactly that. Of course they're dogfooding it!

2
craigtho•

python newbies.

I'm insulted.

7
dagani•

That’s some solid r/gatekeeping.

Edit: Downvote away. Making a blanket generalization that people aren’t qualified to have an opinion on a topic because you look down on them is 100% elitist gatekeeping and totally part of the reason so many people see our industry as toxic.

-5†

Except nobody is keeping anyone out of anything??? Observing the general level of expertise of a crowd isn’t gatekeeping.

7
dagani•

There was very clearly an implied “they aren’t true programmers,” in there.

2

I didn’t think much was implied beyond half are probably not professional programmers. It isn’t a purity test it is an observation of circumstance. Being a professional XYZ or not is a very common point of delineation.

1
craftkiller•

Recent behavior proving they haven't changed: they used to have an open source python language server, but they announced they're dropping support for it in favor of their new closed source Python language server. Doesn't help prove astroturfing but it's good to have examples when people forget who Microsoft is behind the mask.

24
Zulban•

There are many others. Thoughts?

I think it would be literally criminal negligence for a Microsoft executive to ignore platforms like reddit for their business strategies and marketing.

The USA spends over 100 billion a year on advertising. If a subreddit has 2.8m subscribers I think it's time to think of it as a mainstream marketing engine. I guess I'm just surprised we don't see more ads for trucks on reddit, and other boomer obsessions.

It's rare that I stay subscribed to 100k+ subreddits for long.

17
aussie_bob•

You'll be relieved to know they're not negligent...

Digital Marketing Center provides a central platform to efficiently manage your online presence and marketing across paid search advertising, paid social advertising, and organic social media management.

https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/digital-marketing-center

3
StateVsPropsOP•

Alright. That was the answer I was afraid to hear, because I know how much it makes sense.

-1†
SuperQue•

This is confirmation bias. Just because you agree with an opinion doesn't make it true.

Honestly, the whole thing sounds like fanboyism, nothing more. It's the same reason that Linux/DevOps stuff gets downvoted on r/sysadmin. You're not going to get positive responses from a group of mostly old-school Windows sysadmins.

16
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
seraph582•

So is acting like Microsoft deserves some sort of pat on the back for three inconsequential FOSS releases in 4-5 decades of conducting bleeding edge computer biz.

It’s definitely bias, because there’s no other explanation.

-4†
IronSheikYerbouti•

3.5k on their repo <> 3. Just saying.

1
KernowRoger•

I mean .net core and vscode are fully open source. They are both massive projects. MS have made massive moves in that direction over the last few years. It's honestly a bit of a circle jerk at this point.

14
TheByzantineRum•

VScode isn't even open source if you download the binary for it, and extensions for it aren't allowed on 3rd party versions that strip the proprietary bits out.

14
KernowRoger•

Do you have a source for that bit about extensions? Also not sure what you mean by isn't open source if you download the binary.

1
Kaynee490•

There's a section in their FAQ or sth in which they tell you they add stuff (tracking and the like) on top of the open source base and therefore the precompiled binaries aren't actually open source

3
KernowRoger•

Ah I see.

1
LewNeaf•

Also, an example: the remote SSH extension does not work on VSCodium, a fork of VSCode that doesn't include the proprietary bits.

VSCodium is phenomenal otherwise. It's worth trying!

2
Anvoker•

The binary is on a different license than the source code. For it to be FOSS you have to build it yourself. Once you build it yourself you will discover that the C# debugger refuses to run on a community build.

7
KernowRoger•

Ah right interesting.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

11
FewerPunishment•

just a way to get developers (developers developers)

God dammit and lol.

11
Observer14•

As a general rule one should consider Reddit to be completely corrupt and information on it should not be considered as being an even rough approximation of the truth or a mirror of reality in general.

8
Headpuncher•

I've been on reddit a while, this isn't my first account. There has been a long-running discussion about how manipulated reddit is (paid and unpaid), and also how ridiculously biased some sub-reddits are, how most subs are echo chambers, how some communities are just ... nasty.

programming sub attracts a "type" as much as any other sub. Ask: who is likely to be active in that sub?

People with actual programming jobs maybe don't have a lot of time to spend on such a general, broad topic. What I mean here is that if you are a car mechanic, you aren't spending time on /mechanic, but more likely you are on /v6engines, or /ford_repairs, ie specific to your daily/weekly needs for the projects you work on. Who's on the programming sub?

As for the topic, MS & EEE vs FOSS, it seams they did hire a director who understands MS's place int he wider market and what it means to bring MS into 2nd 1/4 of the 21st century.

SaaS and Hardware as a Service (ie cloud) allow MS to sell a service, and not have to put money into developing a Web Server. Nginx, Apache, RHEL, CentOS, Ubuntu etc, they won the market. MS realized they could use those companies to compete instead of trying to compete against them. Why develop MS Server 2030 when you can sell Azure services that use FOSS?

While I certainly don't forgive MS for the past, and I am suspicious still of how they do business in some areas, I think someone there actually cottoned on to the fact that MS would be dead if it didn't change, maybe not today, maybe not tomorrow, but soon and for the rest of the 21st century.

8
qu83rt•

I don't hold much hope for companies who only change their ways to stay alive.

2
MikepGrey•

Dude sock puppets are all over reddit, If I say anything that sound pro biden or pro trump (depending on where I put it) will gett massive up/down votes. Even have people following me around trying to down vote every post I make (its funny that they have NO LIFE, and probably masturbate with their tears every night... may even do that while they are reading this post right here...)

But ya, most sock puppets are paid actors when you deal with hundreds up up/down votes with no comments.

7
JustMrNic3•

You're not paranoid or out of touch.

I get downvoted a lot too when I ask questions or I say to people to be careful with Microsoft products because x or y reason.

I think that there are a few crazy fanboys that are bothered, but sometimes it feels like they have bots or payed people to silence us.

But it's no surprise Microsoft's hostile attitude towards people who don't praise them.

As for open source, they have not changed a bit, they just want to fake it because more and more people are waking up and see the clear advantages for privacy and security of open source.

5
StateVsPropsOP•

I'm wondering if there's a whole new generation of kids (born in 1995 or later) that completely missed the "devil" Microsoft and came of age in a world where the conversation had shifted already to dominance from Google, Facebook, IG, etc.

To these kids, Microsoft is somehow edgy and cool or whatever.

6
Gabernasher•

Microsoft is edgy, just like their new browser.

2

It wouldn't be the first time, they already paid bloggers for positive coverage (or at the very least got caught trying to do that once).

tbf I would not be surprised if some fully FOSS supporting company such as red hat would have been caught doing it. once a company is publicly traded and get's owned by mostly banks and financial institutions the push for profits can become intense.

5
lorean_victor•

Not to refute potential manipulation here. But except your own comment (the extent of negative response to which is indeed surprising), the rest do reflect an unhelpful and tinfoil-hatty attitude.

Look, EVERY company only does stuff to make more money. That's the legal responsibility of the management towards the share-holders. Not to be cool, not be friendly and/or ethical, not to do good for humanity. To make money for the shareholders.

So NO company out there is doing open-source because they ascribe to its noble notions or anything. Everyone is in it for benefits. In that regards, actually MS is the most sincere one, since doing open-source is more than mere PR for them, as its supposed to boost their cloud services furthermore (for example thats the main reason behind acquiring GitHub, not hey lets buy all open-source repos).

Besides, they were the only company that was out-right anti-open-source, which means their switch is the most logical and sincere. They literally lost profits and market share due to that strategy and hence have changed course. They know better than all other companies why you should embrace open-source instead of despising it.

3
IronSheikYerbouti•

As I pointed out for their comment as well - it's completely wrong, windows terminal is a very new application, so that's why they were downvoted. OP didn't read anything just made assumptions, which generally gets a negative reaction from reddit.

1
linear_algebra7•

Hello from the other side- I admit to be guilty of downvoting some recent posts that I thought were unfairly critical of MS (not the above one). Here are few examples.

One was a link to a video that basically said MS have some evil master-plan with VS code. The presenter had honestly no idea what he was talking about- he seemed to confuse OSS with free software, saying stuff like MS is just waiting for Code to become monopoly in IDE market, then they'll charge monthly fee (it's on MIT license). This post had initially over 90% upvote ratio, only when several people started criticizing it in comments it got close to 60% last I checked.

Another post opened with similarly catchy claim that Code isn't actually opensource- since it allows paid extensions to be installed. Really?

A recent one, not on reddit but on Youtube, had the bold title "Linux is faster than windows!". Intrigued, opened the video- turns out it was VS compiler that was slow, gcc-compiled programs had exactly same speed on both platforms. This one had 290 likes to 3 dislikes when I opened it- that ratio got smaller only after people pointed out that the title had not much to do with actual video content.

Notice in both cases initial reception was very positive. To me that implies that people who vote solely based on title without bothering about actual content are far more likely to be anti-MS than not. Please go see some Linux distro communities, there are one million posts basically saying "I just replaced windows with X- everything has become so faster and snappier", people with i7 and 16GB ram. Highly multi-threaded resource intensive programs I understand, but seriously web surfing and file explorer feels faster on Linux now?

I can't comment on vote manipulation from MS, it's not impossible I guess. But if there is a hive mentality prevalent in reddit programming community, among the actual people not bots, it is "hating Microsoft is cool."

3
TheByzantineRum•

VS code's binary isn't open source, and you have to use the official binary if you want extensions. So it's not open source, it's just a foss condom.

1
Slash_Root•

Without sounding paranoid, I noticed weird patterns of downvotes in a recent Microsoft thread about open source. Are people just believing that Microsoft is now one of the 'good guys' because they open sourced PowerToys and Windows Shell?

I think it's a leap to assume that Microsoft is officially attacking a reddit post about this. Is it possible? Sure. However, I think there are valid reasons for people to have a positive opinion of Microsoft's open source projects on r/programming.

You mention two small projects but not the important ones. All of their development tooling apart from VisualStudio has gone open source and has been brought into the 21st century. .NET Core, Powershell, VSCode, Windows Terminal, a package manager, and dotnet cli. In addition, WSL is now a thing. In my area at least, .NET is wildly popular and one of the biggest ecosystems hiring developers. If I were a .NET developer who has been stuck doing WinForms or MVC with nothing but opaque Windows tooling and being married to VisualStudio, I would be ecstatic right now.

The truth is that Microsoft has drastically improved the quality of life for developers in their ecosystem and the new .NET is actually good. Now they get to play with the trendy dev stuff their hipster JavaScript buddies do (containers, Linux, CLI, microservices, etc) and still have their cushy Enterprise gig. I bet a lot of folks on r/programming spend time writing C#. Is Microsoft's plan to attract developers by doing all this so they can make more money? Absolutely. Is it working? Absolutely.

In StackOverflows dev survey, two Microsoft languages made it in the top 8 loved languages. Typescript at 2nd and C# at 8th. Their web framework, ASP.NET Core, was the most popular. .NET Core was the most popular non-web framework. Of course, GitHub, VSCode, Windows, and Teams are popular. Take this with a grain of salt because StackOverflow is asp.net and SQL server with a large .NET following but still it says something.

I'm not a Microsoft employee or fanboy. I'm just a Linux guy who mainly works with Java stacks and deals with IBM, Red Hat, SAP, SUSE, and Oracle. I'm just pointing out my observations of Microsoft's recent actions.

Here are a few examples:

Your first example was a great comment IMO. It's a rational take that none of the Microsoft exclusive infrastructure shows any sign of going open source. They are making big money on that and probably assume Amazon would fork it instantly. The second example was a common joke. Your own comment I think was good too. As I said above, the heavy hitters are the developer tooling and you agree with that.

3
L_darkside•

Every smart person knows what they're doing. Everything they do is unsafe and bloated, all their choices are unethical.

i.e.: they started the monthly payment for online playing on consoles

2
StateVsPropsOP•

Honestly, that's why I posted here. I've been on Reddit daily for a couple years now, and I subscribe exclusively to tech subreddits. I have a bit of a different view than most people, in that it always seemed to me that tech subreddits were pretty reasonable.

That's the first time that I see things so slanted. I wanted to know if either 1) I'm out of touch 2) votes are manipulated 3) it's a new generation of techies that don't know the 'old' Microsoft 4) some of the above 5) all of the above

3
L_darkside•

New people that are not informed about the continuous windows updates disasters, about the customer care, about how much Microsoft loves open source, about what "Embrace, Extend, Extinguish" means

And of course all mixed with the bot and/or manipulated votes.

"Ask Bill why function code 9 (in DOS) ends with a dollar sign . . . . No one in the world knows that but me."

Gary Kildall

(Source)

2
IronSheikYerbouti•

First comment - not really, but I can see it being downvoted because MS has been opening more and more. Complaining that it's not good because it's not everything is stupid to me, and likely stupid to others.

Second comment - this isn't the 90's. Microsoft has been involved more and more in open source for years. This is hardly embrace and extend either.

Your comment - Windows Terminal is new. You'd have had a really hard time using it in 1995 because it didn't exist. So that's probably why you got hit with the downvote paddle.

Are there shills? Yeah probably. But I really doubt it's why you and others were downvoted.

1
aperture_synce•

You're not wrong. Microsoft is still trying to extinguish the competition via SecureBoot. And they still fail to provide proper Office format documentation while lobbying for governments to declare it as an official open source format. They're still a greedy, capitalist company, who will do anything for money.

1
ah_86•

That is all because developers are attached to Github, because most developers use it. I wonder what will happen when they change administration, or make a radical decision that developers don't like. I bet developers will feel sorry for abandoning open-source alternatives to Github when it is too late.

0
humbleSolipsist•

Might be worth posting to r/hailcorporate

-1†