Discussion: pet peeve of mine is when the MC's cadre questions/rejects MC's orders because they love MC too much.

Others

I see this quite often: the MC will order his crew to retreat because he doesn't want them to die, but they reject him because they want to stay and fight with him. Like I get it, you love the MC and are willing to fight with him, but that's not good enough. You should be MORE willing to follow his order if you love him so much.

The reason this trope ticks me off so much is because it makes it seem like the cadre is more loyal to the position the MC is in, rather than the MC himself. It's like they don't follow the MC, but an image of MC that they've created. And it pisses me off even more when the MC is "touched" by the "loyalty" of his cadre that they're willing to disobey his order "for him". Yuck!

There are only a few novels that do it right. Usually, it's with a darker cadre member like an assassin or thief who follows the MC's order without skepticism. These character usually know more about the MC though than the other allies and know he's not like the others think he is so it's necessary to take the MC at his word regardless of the circumstance.

Posted Aug 18, 2020, 3:06 AM UTC

07
vi_sucks•

Imagine if you saw your best friend about to get killed and he tells you to run away. Would you just run? What if it was your brother or your mother?

You gotta remember that cultivation novels are about passion and emotion and hot blooded youth. Being calculating and overly rational is the sign of a villain in these novels, while being willing to risk certain death for a companion is an admired virtue.

2
PolyphenolOverdoseOP•

Irrelevant. If a follower pledges to follow you, and then retains his own will and way of doing things even when told to do otherwise, then he's not actually following you but his own desires and goals.

1
vi_sucks•

Yeah, that's the difference between friends and slaves.

Friends have their own will and choose to follow the MC because they have similar goals and desires.

And most of these novels very explicitly rely on the idea of the MC having friends as his followers rather than slaves. Because that very notion of brotherhood and companionship is what makes him an MC. To be contrasted against the dbag villain young masters who go around with a bunch of slavish yes man.

2
PolyphenolOverdoseOP•

It sounds like you want a bunch of no men. Yuck.

1
VortexMagusPass into the Iris!•

It seems to me that you view the ideal relationship as one of obedience while others might consider loyalty or comradeship as a higher virtue. Your idea is rational but I am not sure I agree with it.

2
PolyphenolOverdoseOP•

I'm specifically referring to a follower who pledges to follow you, not just some random friend who didn't make any promise. Such "followers" aren't actually following you, but their own desires and goals.

1
NeoLegendDJ•

I mean, there's also the whole trope of a final AOE attack that would end things, but can't use because the friends are in the way. So, they tell the friends to retreat, friends refuse, one or two small characters die, they get captured, and MC flees to power up to rescue the friends.

1