Looking for feedback on my first homebrew subclass. A monastic tradition, Way of the Jade Panther. For the monks that want to use their surroundings as a weapon and a tool.

Posted Aug 18, 2020, 1:01 PM UTC

Posted Aug 18, 2020, 1:01 PM UTC
I'll start by saying I like the idea of this subclass. A druid type monk is super fun.
Level 3 is really strong compared to other level 3 abilities. 2 proficiencies AND ignore all difficult terrain AND pretty easily achieved advantage AND increased jump distance AND what is effectively flight 20; that's a great deal of extra stuff. Consider dialing that back a bunch.
Level 6 is a mixed bag; Verdant Assault is interesting, but worse than Stunning Strike. Earthen Step seems interesting, but potentially a lot of book keeping for everyone, especially the DM. Barbed Armor is great, but is this magic damage like your unarmed attacks? The fact that you can only keep 1 of these up a turn seems like a good thing, gives you more interesting options for trade off.
Wrath of the Wild is pretty huge too. An always on Speak to Plants and Animals on top of a ranged attack that gets additional damage or effects is a lot better than, say, casti Sanctuary on yourself for 8 hours after completing a long rest or cast Invisibility while in darkness.
Avatar of Jade is neat, but feels under powered compared to other subclass abilities. It's essentially a limited 5th level spell with a 1st level spell attached. Compare to Quivering Palm or Opportunist or Unerring Accuracy, and it's kinda meh.
I'd suggest pairing down level 3 to like 1 or two of those powers, counting the two proficiencies as 1 power, and if movement ends above the ground, you fall. It's 10 feet, so no real worry, but Athletics/Acrobatics check or go prone.
Nature's Might seems fine.
Wrath of the Wild could go to 17 and increase the secondary effect, and move Avatar of Jade to 11, but limit the amount of buds; either because it has a Ki point, or Wis mod times per day.
Sorry im late replying but those are some great ideas.
I was considering the proficiency being a choice between nature or survival, and the difficult terrain being removed as it is basically replaced by the jump feature. The fall idea seems like it could work well, makes it more like an actual jump than a flight.
I was thinking on adjusting the level 6 features, namely making it so verdant assault instead did a weaker but longer lasting debuff but didnt really have any ideas that didnt intrude too much on an existing effect. Earthern Step I wanted to kind of feel like a wall spell but through your own movements instead of a chosen range, but I dont know how much i could change it to make it less difficult to keep track of. Barbed Armor would most likely do non-magic damage since it isnt using an inately magical weapon, just thorns and barbs. I was thinking of increasing the damage with martial arts die, but it seemed like too much for being part of a larger effect.
I did think that the level 17 feature seemed kind of weak, but i couldn't think of a way of buffing it without just doing something ridiculous. Swapping avatar and wrath seem like it could work. I think making the buds a ki point cost to create could balance that out really well though, making it more of a monk thing than just nature stuff.
This is epic! I might use this to make a full class,