r/INTP•
sobagi

Am I crazy or could it work?

Been with my bf for 6 months now, had him take MBTI within the first couple weeks but he definitely rushed through it and came out as ENFJ. I was like, hmm this could work (may be tough) but def could work. But I knew he was not an ENFJ. I never cared to really research his ways because I had a doubt. Fast forward to a couple nights ago when he took it again for real this time, and BOOM--ESFJ. WTF! My mom is an ESFJ and we all know how that goes. Anyone have advice? Could it work? Should I keep trying? We've had a lot of fights and arguments but ultimately these have brought us closer and made us more patient. Help.

TLDR; I'm a female INTP and just found out my bf is ESFJ, need advice.

Posted Aug 18, 2020, 4:38 PM UTC · edited

112
VasubandumonINTP since 1964•

He is neither ENFJ nor ESFJ. He is who he is. Personally, I would give MBTI zero consideration in deciding what kind of relationship to have with him.

5
botxinbotINTP•

My previous partner of 14 years is an ESFJ we separated last year. The relationship was easy and in many ways we balanced each other and made a good team. I could count our arguments on one hand over that time which is both a good and bad thing. We are still close friends.

Off the top of my head I have put a list of the positives and negatives of my x esfj. But as we know every person is different.

Pros: Loyal, supportive, stable with moods and lifestyle, very routine like clockwork, practical, helpful, never complains, genuine and gentle, easily pleased and likes a simple life.

Cons: Fear of change, too agreeable, conflict avoidant, not comfortable with deep and meaningful or intellectual conversations, group thinker, lacks passion and ambition.

3
sobagiOP•

sounds about right!! Thanks for this

3
voyage2procyonINTP•

If he gets ENTJ tomorrow will you marry him? Are you sure he actually is ESFJ considering you're basing this on some test? Start asking yourself why you are in a relationship with him in the first place and if you can see a good future for him if you remain together. The rest of the internet can't give you any answers unless you're actually looking for a reason to dump him.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
sobagiOP•

you're right...but saying "it worked for 6 months" implies that things have been harmonious and smooth, and they were definitely not. I know relationships take work etc but is it supposed to be so difficult?! Anyway thank you for the answer, so true that I could subconsciously be attracted to someone like my mother.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
ArtificialAlienationINTP-A 5w6•

You really need to not fuck up your entire life and your relationships based upon what pseud box you're placed into lmfao

2
sobagiOP•

fuck, i know.

3
ganja_gun•

My mom is ISFJ and her controlling nature dreads me, I would never be in a relationship with someone like that. But it worked so far for you so why not?

2
SilhouetteAngylINTJ-Female•

Family are different than lovers. And how your parents were brought up (old school way of thinking vs today’s way of thinking) is different. My dad is istp. He’s abusive, hateful, full on male KAREN, thinks everyone this gen is wretched, lazy, worthless.. IN HIS DAY.. blah blah.. Still tries to control kids. Kids should be seen, not heard and slapped from the table if they talk or don’t like peas.. etc. my istp friend is chill.. Thinks kids have every right to voice their ideas, would knock out any man who hit a woman, spends a lot of time on video games.. You know.. A worthless new generation.. There are a lot of similarities between my dad and him. But because of the generational gap and new way of viewing the world around him, my friend is a good person.

1
sobagiOP•

a fair point

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
sobagiOP•

thanks for the link, thought I'd read/seen most of em but not this one!

1
sobagiOP•
1