Question from a business owner

I am a business owner with an interest in digital assets and cross boarder transfers/payments. We have offices in US, UK, and China and have subcontractors and/or client in our office countries and Canada, Korea, Germany. How can I use Stellar to send/receive payments between my various business associates? IS this appropriate for such low level use or is it more meant for large institutions?

Posted Aug 18, 2020, 6:30 PM UTC

3117
NetworkSkullRipper•

Take everything I say with a massive grain of salt as this is something that I haven't worked on and I'm just giving you my opinion.

There's nothing in Stellar that would prevent you from using it for this particular use-case. On the contrary, that is one of the big objectives of this network: to make cross-border transfers as painless as possible.

The big question mark is whether there are enough supporting services for your use-case. Unless all involved parties are willing to take Lumens as the payment form you will have to rely on anchors to get assets in the stellar network that represent an external asset (USD, EUR, etc). If there are anchors that work across all the different locations or there is enough liquidity so that you can leverage the Stellar DEX to exchange between different anchor assets, there shouldn't be a problem (e.g. you pay with US-Based-Anchor USD to an account that receives EU-Based-Anchor EUR). Then each party is able to convert to their asset using their respective anchors.

Finding that and making sure that the fees the anchors charge, if any, how liquid is the exchange market are things that depend on the choices you make. And I think that is where the potential of finding there's still a lack of supporting services might show up.

15
fenTaTa•

Excuse my ignorance, but isn't this more or less what Ripple is supposed to do with XRP? Witg the Anchors being banks?

I am looking into buying some XRP and was wondering if XLM wouldn't be redundant.

1
sargsauce•

https://www.exodus.io/blog/stellar-vs-ripple/

Note: some info is outdated, such as XLM being inflationary; that ended with the upgrade to protocol version 12 https://www.stellar.org/developers/guides/concepts/inflation.html

1
enqvistx•

Same thing different flavor. As a developer, I prefer the Stellar Network over the XRP Ledger as it is more inclusive to everyone. It seems to me like Ripple is building all these walled gardens and closed "corridors" within their network, while Stellar builds a protocol for moving value that is available to anyone. It's quite a breeze to build on the Stellar Network and the community is amazing, whereas I was having a hard time getting simple questions answered when I was looking into XRPL.

1
cochemuacos•

XRP is aimed for big financial institutions which would definitely benefit from it, the thing is I'm not convinced this benefits will get passed to the users. Anchors and the stellar network are way more powerful imo

1
Timothy_McGirl•

Keybase.io full end to end encrypted messaging, file sharing, built in Stellar wallet that supports path payments with federated addresses. Can now have encrypted Zoom meetings as well in messaging.

12
chalbersma•

Did they add that?

1
arosier2•

Zoom owns Keybase.io now, correct?

1
chalbersma•

Yes, but they haven't added teleconferencing features to keybase.

1
schermmj•

I agree, I'm a developer for a company that has an ERP package for parts/orders including accounting. We integrate with quick books and several other accounting packages rn but i'd really like to get the stellar dex integrated in our software too. We have over 10,000 manufacturing business customers that could use it's dex but our customers will want to use USD and not lumens (at first at least). I'm not an expert on how safe and easy the anchors are on the stellar dex. Convincing our customers and their customers to use it is the big issue and I'm not sure how to solve that. I've loved stellar from the beginning because this seems to be their goal.

9
nikgod•

If both parties are sending and receiving the same asset (USD in your example), you don't need to use the DEX. You can directly send USD from account to account.

3
schermmj•

The majority of our customers customers' are American so I'm not sure there is a point for us to do this. However, they are job shops that make parts and also buy parts and they do a shit of business over seas. I like Stellar so I'd like to see it succeed. I'm possibly in a position to help and I'd jump at the opportunity if it wasn't to cumbersome to integrate within our software. We will see.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
cochemuacos•

As someone who is currently setting up a remmitances startup I can tell you that, from what I've learned/seen stellar works great to achive this in theory. In practice it is not mature yet. As u/NetworkSkullRipper mentions the current issue right now is the lack of anchors/liquidity on the market. There's an anchor for my local currency but the market cap is around $1,800 USD which is really low.

In general I don't believe the cryptocurrency ecosystem can right now offer something better than say transferwise (I'm gessing since I've never used it). We'll get there no doubt, but work remains to be done.

1
preposterousdingleOP•

This is probably a dumb question but what would the approx. cost be for me to operate an anchor in each of my offices? Is it like $20,000 in equipment plus part time IT maintenance per anchor or much more than that?

1
cochemuacos•

I really don't know. I'm guessing the hard part is keeping up with the legal and compliance stuff but that's jst my guess. The process of creating a token is quite simple as far as I know and there are some video tutorials on youtube

1
NetworkSkullRipper•

As u/cochemuacos says, I think the tough part is keeping up with the legal side of things. You are dealing with financial assets here and countries tend to have the management of those tightly regulated.

I think the infrastructure costs are negligible, you can probably run this in a couple of VPS. But it's mostly all the surrounding services: ramp-on, ramp-off, etc. But also making sure the legalities are met, insurance for the underlying asset, audits, etc.

I think there are some efforts to alleviate the surrounding services like a django framework that implements some of the basic blocks of the functionality.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1