Nerf suggestion for reanimate 10 effects

I haven't seen any other people saying this, so I might be alone here, but I think that fatal order and bonenanza necromancer's enhance effect are overpowered.

If you jump the extremely short hurdle of burying a HWOR, fatal order gives you most (if your opponent's followers do nothing for the turn) or all (if your opponent kills it) of the effectiveness of a 10 Mana follower for 4 mana, while BN guarantees the full 10 Mana of effectiveness. If you disagree with my 10 Mana number, you can substitute your own value for what you think 5 storm damage, 5 ward health, a 6/6, and 2+ 4/4's is worth.

I think the simplest fix to this is to change HWOR's "Last Words: Reanimate (8)" into "Fanfare: Gain 'Last Words: Reanimate (8)'" so that he doesn't get it when reanimated.

The only unintended interaction change this causes (that I know of) is that princess knight tutors it now which probably isn't very important.

Posted Aug 20, 2020, 4:58 AM UTC

015
pukahuntus•

A nerf to Cloistered Sacristan will be live in 3 hours, he can no longer destroy followers on evolve. Do feel reanimate needs more nerfs on top of this?

9
DaSlurpyNinjaOP•

Yes. I think that Cloistered Sacristan was overpowered and that reanimate 10 effects are overpowered so they should both be nerfed.

-12
SpiritJuice•

I don't think Bonenanza nor Fatal Order need to be nerfed. Reanimate 10 can be a powerful effect but in this current environment, it's only powerful once you've buried both HWOR and Dreadlord, which doesn't happen every game. It's an ideal situation to have, but it doesn't happen every game and Shadow has to win through other means. Fatal Order and Bonenanza only reach their full potential when the "combo" is met, but otherwise they are kind of situational or bricks until you assemble the combo.

You don't really want to play Fatal Order before you have the combo set up unless you have a specific niche reason like Dreadlord in the graveyard and it's turn 4, making it a pretty good tempo play, but even then you don't want to be drawing your Dreadlords. Another situation would be something like your Reanimate from HWOR will be Sacristan and you really need that double ward. There aren't really any other good targets for HWOR to Reanimate so Fatal Order usually just sits in your hand until you've assembled the pieces you need.

Bonenanza is kind of the same as Fatal Order. His Enhance 7 is really only good once you've assembled the pieces, or at the bare minimum, you've only buried HWOR so you can start pressuring. You pretty much never want to play Bonenanza for Reanimate Dreadlord unless you're ahead on board and need to start pressuring that way.

With all that said, Sacristan is already going to be nerfed, and that nerf is pretty substanial. The nerf should be enough to tone down Shadow a little if the mini-expansion fails to shake things up.

5
BearTornado•

Yeah, I'm pretty sure you're alone here.

This is the first time in years that Reanimate (10) has actually been valuable in Rotation.

Plus Sacristan got the hammer, so.

4
ogbajojCharter of reveals•

The only unintended interaction change this causes (that I know of) is that princess knight tutors it now which probably isn't very important.

This is actually important, but not for Rotation. Some Unlimited Atomy decks run Princess Knight as a tutor for Atomy, and HWOR as one of their many BR targets for Coffin of the Unknown Soul. So you'd no longer be able to run him in that deck as a payoff (of course OG Zeus, Sacristan, Deathbringer, plenty of targets exist, but it would definitely make the deck worse).

Another interaction is that it would be able to gain the Last Words twice with new mostly-buffed Loki, but decks are unlikely to run him any time soon.

3
DaSlurpyNinjaOP•

Thanks for the info, I was only thinking about rotation.

0
DyzunexViXynix•

Um, fatal order banishes rock dude unless he's somehow destroyed.

BN's effects by then usually on turn 7 spawning rock dude kind of have to face the other board which is already set up.

Personally, even will reanimate 10 effects is one of the two ways to get he who once rock with the other which is friends forever.

Fatal order does not permanetly maintain him unless he's used to suside into a flood bethemoth/Some artifact which is discounted with bane. Rarely this closes the game with five damage unless the opponent is down to 7 hp (because of evolution and then direct attack) or does not have award.

Bonezena Necro by turn 7 plus reanimates he who once rock but it consumes a great deal with not much options whereas by then the opponent has his board set up and there's hardly pp to clear. Also, unless their defense is low enough for a direct hit to close.

Besides, now with the scaritan nerf to not being able to take out a follower..It's not going to be easy now that there is an extra step to clear that follower unless the lovers can reanimate jackshovel.

Anyways will see how it goes with the new expansion. Will probably try out rune, dragon and sword since there's some interesting add ons.

3
NerdyDan•

Fatal order going first after burying hwor is super unhealthy. The enemy is forced to ignore the rest of your board for a turn OR give you even more value when they are already behind as player 2

1
DyzunexViXynix•

I've just lost today because i happen to have an opponent who BR his rock dude right on turn 1 and then turn 6, 7 and 8 were fatal orders and boneanza.

Oh well, guess they happen to have all the cards at the right moment.

Since then i've changed my deck. Depends on the craft that answer that turn.

To be honest most of my defeat after the expansion was more of:

  • discard dragon + whale: After they set up the whale, a lot of damage with them having that whale ward. It's practically item shop cept with field clear and direct damage not random of 2s and 1s.

  • blood's baal and corruption: Its the return of the NAM and Corruption ping damage with 6 dmg across clearing everything and also a huge chunk of health.

When playing shadow currently i didn't use both the bonezana and fatal order. I used the nepth's effect for the rock dude to help spawn dreadlord or hade's 6 shadows and ptp.

1
krosis17I hate runecraft•

If they change it to a fanfare then nobody is gonna play hwor, 10pp or even 9pp is way to much be playing him from hand so the only good way for him to be played is through reanimate effects (for now). And since we are gonna get a new nept its even worse if they change it to a fanfare. I like way more the fact that they nerf cloistered as a way to reduce the overall power level of the deck. In conclusion if they change it to a fanfare you basically butcher the card to a point where nobody is gonna play it because you can no longer get the full value (if it they don't banish it or gets banish by fatal order) and getting the full value of the card requires you to play it on turn 9 or 10 at that point its no longer worth its value cause you have already lost or about to lose

2
DaSlurpyNinjaOP•

I don't know of you misunderstood me, but the fact that you only get the full value of the card if you play it from your hand is exactly what I intended. Also, HWOR's fanfare could be buffed to make playing it from your hand actually viable without changing what happens when it is reanimated. Or, HWOR could keep the reanimate last words but have it be nerfed to a much lower value (possibly 3) and still gain the fanfare (not as severe a nerf to the reanimated version, and it also serves as a buff to playing it from your hand).

-5
krosis17I hate runecraft•

Well my point is that if you can only get the full value of the card by playing it from hand then its shit, this card was design to be cheated out with the help of other cards if you change it then nobody is gonna play it because by turn 9 and 10 you want to close the game

2
DaSlurpyNinjaOP•

My point is that with fanfare, you can nerf the cheated version (which I believe to be overpowered) and buff the hand version (which I believe to be underpowered). I don't like the design how it is (although it seems like everybody else does) so I proposed a HWOR design change that acts as a nerf to reanimate 10 effects.

0
Willar71•

Just put on a diaper , you'll be alright .

2†
Idoneyo汝は神に捨てられたー!•

This change not only affects how Princess Knight interacts with HWOR, it also nerfs Fleeting Joy and Neo-Nephythys indirectly, which just outright kills already niche (or at least what looks to be niche in the case of Nephythys) combo choices. The nerf to Sacristan should at least keep Shadow a little more in line so we should wait and see how that pans out before deciding whether or not HWOR or Bonenanza/Fatal Order needs to be hit.

1